BRUSSELS (Dow Jones)--The production of green energy must be expanded swiftly across the European Union in order to meet the E.U.'s 2020 environmental targets - but it can be done, E.U. Energy Commissioner Andris Piebalgs said Monday.
As much as 34% of the E.U.'s electricity will likely come from renewables by 2020, with wind and biomass playing a key role, Piebalgs said. Solar energy will also become important as its cost is expected to halve by 2020, he added.
The European Commission has put forward a package of proposals to cut greenhouse gas emissions in the E.U., boost energy efficiency and increase to 20% the share of renewable energy for the bloc's energy needs by 2020.
In Spain, 10% of electricity in an average day is provided by wind energy and France already uses tidal power to produce electricity, Piebalgs said in a speech to the European Council of Applied Sciences, Technologies and Engineering in London.
The commissioner said the cost of meeting the green energy targets is "very modest."
"There is clearly a direct cost of the policy but it is relatively minor, and we believe there is a clear medium-term gain," he said.
In the U.K., the cost of the package would be less than GBP1 billion a year by 2020, he said. Taking into account the investments needed to replace aging power plants and other energy infrastructure, the amount is relatively small and the gains significant, he said.
National governments and the European Parliament are negotiating over the package, and some countries, including Italy and Poland, have complained that the proposals are too costly and will hamper growth at a time of economic downturn.
"We don't have a long-term choice about developing a low-carbon economy," Piebalgs said.
"Climate change, vulnerability to high fossil-fuel prices and energy security mean that we must not let current market turmoil distract us," he added.
-By Alessandro Torello, Dow Jones Newswires; +32 2 741 14 88; alessandro.torello@dowjones.com
Wednesday, 5 November 2008
Brown signs UAE clean energy deal
By Robin Wigglesworth in Abu Dhabi
Published: November 3 2008 23:30
Gordon Brown, the UK’s prime minister, on Monday signed a clean energy co-operation agreement with a leading renewable energy company in the United Arab Emirates.
Mr Brown is on the last leg of a tour of the region to raise money from oil-rich Gulf states for the International Monetary Fund, an effort which, despite visits to Saudi Arabia and Qatar this week, has not yet produced any firm commitments.
The memorandum of understanding with Masdar to develop clean technologies came a day after neighbouring Qatar said it had agreed to invest £150m ($238m, €187m) in a UK low-carbon energy technology fund alongside Britain’s Carbon Trust and private investors.
Gulf states are planning for the day oil and gas runs out and several have targeted renewable energy as a strategic sector into which to diversify.
Masdar – a government-owned company based in Abu Dhabi, capital of the UAE – last month said it was taking a 20 per cent stake in the 1,000 megawatt London Array offshore wind farm for an undisclosed sum.
The company is also building a $22bn (€17bn, £14bn) city in the desert outside Abu Dhabi that it says will be carbon neutral when it is completed.
Mr Brown offered to support Gulf countries that want an increased say in the IMF in return for any contributions.
The Group of 20 countries – which includes Saudi Arabia, the regional heavyweight – will meet this month to try to strengthen the IMF ahead of what is expected to be a series of bail-outs by the fund.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 23:30
Gordon Brown, the UK’s prime minister, on Monday signed a clean energy co-operation agreement with a leading renewable energy company in the United Arab Emirates.
Mr Brown is on the last leg of a tour of the region to raise money from oil-rich Gulf states for the International Monetary Fund, an effort which, despite visits to Saudi Arabia and Qatar this week, has not yet produced any firm commitments.
The memorandum of understanding with Masdar to develop clean technologies came a day after neighbouring Qatar said it had agreed to invest £150m ($238m, €187m) in a UK low-carbon energy technology fund alongside Britain’s Carbon Trust and private investors.
Gulf states are planning for the day oil and gas runs out and several have targeted renewable energy as a strategic sector into which to diversify.
Masdar – a government-owned company based in Abu Dhabi, capital of the UAE – last month said it was taking a 20 per cent stake in the 1,000 megawatt London Array offshore wind farm for an undisclosed sum.
The company is also building a $22bn (€17bn, £14bn) city in the desert outside Abu Dhabi that it says will be carbon neutral when it is completed.
Mr Brown offered to support Gulf countries that want an increased say in the IMF in return for any contributions.
The Group of 20 countries – which includes Saudi Arabia, the regional heavyweight – will meet this month to try to strengthen the IMF ahead of what is expected to be a series of bail-outs by the fund.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Scientists discover Patagonian diesel that grows on trees
Alok Jha, green technology correspondent
The Guardian,
Tuesday November 4 2008
The 'myco-diesel' fungus Gliocladium roseum, which grows inside the ulmo tree in northern Patagonia
A tree fungus could provide green fuel that can be pumped directly into vehicle tanks, US scientists say. The organism, found in the Patagonian rainforest, naturally produces a mixture of chemicals that is remarkably similar to diesel.
"This is the only organism that has ever been shown to produce such an important combination of fuel substances," said Gary Strobel, a plant scientist from Montana State University, who led the work. "We were totally surprised to learn that it was making a plethora of hydrocarbons."
In principle, biofuels are attractive replacements for liquid fossil fuels used in transport that generate greenhouse gases. The European Union has set biofuel targets of 5.75% by 2010 and 10% by 2020. But critics say current biofuels scarcely reduce greenhouse gas emissions and cause food price rises and deforestation. Producing biofuels sustainably is now a target and this latest work has been greeted by experts as an encouraging step.
The fungus, called Gliocladium roseum and discovered growing inside the ulmo tree (Eucryphia cordifolia) in northern Patagonia, produces a range of hydrocarbon molecules that are virtually identical to the fuel-grade compounds in existing fossil fuels. Details of the concoction, which Strobel calls "mycodiesel", will be published in the November issue of the journal Microbiology. "The results were totally unexpected and very exciting and almost every hair on my arms stood on end," said Strobel.
Many simple organisms, such as algae, are known to make chemicals that are similar to the hydrocarbons present in transport fuel but, according to Strobel, none produce the explosive high energy density found in this fungus. Strobel said that the chemical mixture produced could be used in a modern diesel engine without any modification. Another advantage of the fungus is its ability to eat up cellulose, the compound that makes up much of the organic waste that is currently discarded, such as stalks and sawdust. Converting this plant waste into fuels is an important goal for the biofuel industry, which currently uses food crops such as corn.
"Fungi are very important but we often overlook these organisms," said Tariq Butt, a fungus expert at Swansea University. "The discovery and its potential applications are fantastic. However, more research is needed, as well as a pilot study to determine the costs and benefits." John Loughhead, executive director of the UK Energy Research Centre, also welcomed the "encouraging" discovery but noted it was at its earliest stage of development.
The Guardian,
Tuesday November 4 2008
The 'myco-diesel' fungus Gliocladium roseum, which grows inside the ulmo tree in northern Patagonia
A tree fungus could provide green fuel that can be pumped directly into vehicle tanks, US scientists say. The organism, found in the Patagonian rainforest, naturally produces a mixture of chemicals that is remarkably similar to diesel.
"This is the only organism that has ever been shown to produce such an important combination of fuel substances," said Gary Strobel, a plant scientist from Montana State University, who led the work. "We were totally surprised to learn that it was making a plethora of hydrocarbons."
In principle, biofuels are attractive replacements for liquid fossil fuels used in transport that generate greenhouse gases. The European Union has set biofuel targets of 5.75% by 2010 and 10% by 2020. But critics say current biofuels scarcely reduce greenhouse gas emissions and cause food price rises and deforestation. Producing biofuels sustainably is now a target and this latest work has been greeted by experts as an encouraging step.
The fungus, called Gliocladium roseum and discovered growing inside the ulmo tree (Eucryphia cordifolia) in northern Patagonia, produces a range of hydrocarbon molecules that are virtually identical to the fuel-grade compounds in existing fossil fuels. Details of the concoction, which Strobel calls "mycodiesel", will be published in the November issue of the journal Microbiology. "The results were totally unexpected and very exciting and almost every hair on my arms stood on end," said Strobel.
Many simple organisms, such as algae, are known to make chemicals that are similar to the hydrocarbons present in transport fuel but, according to Strobel, none produce the explosive high energy density found in this fungus. Strobel said that the chemical mixture produced could be used in a modern diesel engine without any modification. Another advantage of the fungus is its ability to eat up cellulose, the compound that makes up much of the organic waste that is currently discarded, such as stalks and sawdust. Converting this plant waste into fuels is an important goal for the biofuel industry, which currently uses food crops such as corn.
"Fungi are very important but we often overlook these organisms," said Tariq Butt, a fungus expert at Swansea University. "The discovery and its potential applications are fantastic. However, more research is needed, as well as a pilot study to determine the costs and benefits." John Loughhead, executive director of the UK Energy Research Centre, also welcomed the "encouraging" discovery but noted it was at its earliest stage of development.
Ethanol producers
Published: November 3 2008 09:22
Sometimes, the best cure for a hangover is to keep drinking. But ethanol investors, hit by the shakes since they binged on the corn-based fuel in 2005 and 2006, should think twice before taking the hair of the dog. The bankruptcy of VeraSun Energy, the biggest listed US ethanol producer, is the latest grim news for a sector where listed companies have lost 80-90 per cent of their market value over the past two years. Ironically, for an industry savaged by rising corn costs, VeraSun shows that falling corn prices are one of the biggest short-term threats.
Like some rivals, VeraSun took out hedges to protect against rising prices after corn hit a record price of $8 a bushel in June. Yet those hedges backfired as bushel prices went on to halve, leaving the company strapped for cash. For others also, the recent pullback in corn prices has offered little respite. As recession fears have grown, ethanol prices have plunged in tandem with corn prices, so depriving producers of any hoped-for boost to margins.
Eventually, demand will improve. The amount of ethanol to be blended into gasoline in the US is set to quadruple by 2022 because of government mandates. With annual sales running at about $20bn, the supply glut that has pushed down ethanol prices should ease by 2010 or 2011 as demand catches up. But in the long run, low barriers to entry – all it takes to become a producer is a field of corn and a simple still – means gains will be fleeting. New producers will compete away margins, leaving the biggest buyers of ethanol – the refiners who blend it into gasoline – able to dictate prices. The likely result is prices that are sufficient to keep ethanol plants ticking over, but barely profitable. All the more reason for investors to pull up the covers and go back to bed.
Sometimes, the best cure for a hangover is to keep drinking. But ethanol investors, hit by the shakes since they binged on the corn-based fuel in 2005 and 2006, should think twice before taking the hair of the dog. The bankruptcy of VeraSun Energy, the biggest listed US ethanol producer, is the latest grim news for a sector where listed companies have lost 80-90 per cent of their market value over the past two years. Ironically, for an industry savaged by rising corn costs, VeraSun shows that falling corn prices are one of the biggest short-term threats.
Like some rivals, VeraSun took out hedges to protect against rising prices after corn hit a record price of $8 a bushel in June. Yet those hedges backfired as bushel prices went on to halve, leaving the company strapped for cash. For others also, the recent pullback in corn prices has offered little respite. As recession fears have grown, ethanol prices have plunged in tandem with corn prices, so depriving producers of any hoped-for boost to margins.
Eventually, demand will improve. The amount of ethanol to be blended into gasoline in the US is set to quadruple by 2022 because of government mandates. With annual sales running at about $20bn, the supply glut that has pushed down ethanol prices should ease by 2010 or 2011 as demand catches up. But in the long run, low barriers to entry – all it takes to become a producer is a field of corn and a simple still – means gains will be fleeting. New producers will compete away margins, leaving the biggest buyers of ethanol – the refiners who blend it into gasoline – able to dictate prices. The likely result is prices that are sufficient to keep ethanol plants ticking over, but barely profitable. All the more reason for investors to pull up the covers and go back to bed.
Monday, 3 November 2008
Drought land 'will be abandoned'

Climate change will cause 'economic deserts' even in rich countries, warns UN environment chief
Juliette Jowit, environment editor
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
A farmer surveys dead livestock in drought-stricken Leigh Creek, Australia. Photograph: Ian Waldie/Getty Images
Parts of the world may have to be abandoned because severe water shortages will leave them uninhabitable, the United Nations environment chief has warned.
Achim Steiner, executive director of the UN Environment Programme, said water shortages caused by over-use of rivers and aquifers were already leading to serious problems, even in rich nations. With climate change expected to reduce rainfall in some places and cause droughts in others, some regions could become 'economic deserts', unviable for people or agriculture, he said.
Steiner argued that only urgent action to combat global warming and poverty could prevent the creation of thousands of 'environmental refugees'. Previous UN agreements to reduce global warming emissions and the Millennium Development Goals on poverty had not been met. His warning echoes those of other environment leaders, who have said that water shortages could be the greatest threat posed by climate change.
'In many ways [water] is the most dramatic expression of mismanagement of natural or nature-based assets,' Steiner said. 'The day a person or a community is bereft of water is the day that your chance of even the most basic life or livelihood is gone and economic activity seeps away.
'Unchecked climate change will mean that some parts of the world will simply not have enough water to sustain settlements both small and large, because agriculture becomes untenable and industries relying on water can no longer compete or function effectively. This will trigger structural changes in economies right through to the displacement of people as environmental refugees.'
Steiner said it was not possible to identify specific places at risk, but said vulnerable areas were those which were already considered to be 'water scarce' because of dry weather and a lack of infrastructure to store and transport water. Last week a study of the water footprints of 200 nations led by conservation group WWF warned that 50 countries were already experiencing 'moderate to severe water stress on a year-round basis'.
This week experts from the UN Convention to Combat Desertification meeting in Turkey will warn that high food prices and endemic droughts are jeopardising the lives of hundreds of millions of people, particularly in Africa.
Some of the most dramatic examples of water shortages this year include conflict-stricken Sudan, the dramatic drying of Lake Faguibine in Mali on which 200,000 mostly nomadic people depend, fatal clashes over drying boreholes in northern Kenya, and economic and social crisis on the sparsely populated border between Bolivia and Argentina, according to Unep. Oxfam has estimated that 25 million people have been affected by the most recent drought in Ethiopia.
Rich nations are not immune. California has declared a state of emergency over water shortages, Australia has committed billions of dollars to cope with drought, and governments in Europe have been forced to ship in water to stop communities running dry.
'A plant, never mind a human being, simply cannot live without water,' said Steiner. 'It's not a matter of how we can live for three years without some water; these are not the kind of things we can do for a while and recover.
'In rich countries, there's always the potential of channelling water from one river basin to another. But even there people are hitting the limits of what we can do with money and infrastructure because there simply isn't enough water any more.'
Suggested solutions include better enforcement of restrictions on over-use of rivers, lakes and aquifers, more efficient use of water and increases in technologies to recycle and desalinate water.
Experts at the International Water Association congress in September called for investment in water infrastructure to at least double from the current level of $80bn (£49bn) a year to avoid widespread flooding, drought and disease.
Unep has calculated that enough rain falls on Africa to theoretically supply the needs of 13 billion people, and has called for a continent-wide rainwater harvesting programme.
Juliette Jowit, environment editor
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
A farmer surveys dead livestock in drought-stricken Leigh Creek, Australia. Photograph: Ian Waldie/Getty Images
Parts of the world may have to be abandoned because severe water shortages will leave them uninhabitable, the United Nations environment chief has warned.
Achim Steiner, executive director of the UN Environment Programme, said water shortages caused by over-use of rivers and aquifers were already leading to serious problems, even in rich nations. With climate change expected to reduce rainfall in some places and cause droughts in others, some regions could become 'economic deserts', unviable for people or agriculture, he said.
Steiner argued that only urgent action to combat global warming and poverty could prevent the creation of thousands of 'environmental refugees'. Previous UN agreements to reduce global warming emissions and the Millennium Development Goals on poverty had not been met. His warning echoes those of other environment leaders, who have said that water shortages could be the greatest threat posed by climate change.
'In many ways [water] is the most dramatic expression of mismanagement of natural or nature-based assets,' Steiner said. 'The day a person or a community is bereft of water is the day that your chance of even the most basic life or livelihood is gone and economic activity seeps away.
'Unchecked climate change will mean that some parts of the world will simply not have enough water to sustain settlements both small and large, because agriculture becomes untenable and industries relying on water can no longer compete or function effectively. This will trigger structural changes in economies right through to the displacement of people as environmental refugees.'
Steiner said it was not possible to identify specific places at risk, but said vulnerable areas were those which were already considered to be 'water scarce' because of dry weather and a lack of infrastructure to store and transport water. Last week a study of the water footprints of 200 nations led by conservation group WWF warned that 50 countries were already experiencing 'moderate to severe water stress on a year-round basis'.
This week experts from the UN Convention to Combat Desertification meeting in Turkey will warn that high food prices and endemic droughts are jeopardising the lives of hundreds of millions of people, particularly in Africa.
Some of the most dramatic examples of water shortages this year include conflict-stricken Sudan, the dramatic drying of Lake Faguibine in Mali on which 200,000 mostly nomadic people depend, fatal clashes over drying boreholes in northern Kenya, and economic and social crisis on the sparsely populated border between Bolivia and Argentina, according to Unep. Oxfam has estimated that 25 million people have been affected by the most recent drought in Ethiopia.
Rich nations are not immune. California has declared a state of emergency over water shortages, Australia has committed billions of dollars to cope with drought, and governments in Europe have been forced to ship in water to stop communities running dry.
'A plant, never mind a human being, simply cannot live without water,' said Steiner. 'It's not a matter of how we can live for three years without some water; these are not the kind of things we can do for a while and recover.
'In rich countries, there's always the potential of channelling water from one river basin to another. But even there people are hitting the limits of what we can do with money and infrastructure because there simply isn't enough water any more.'
Suggested solutions include better enforcement of restrictions on over-use of rivers, lakes and aquifers, more efficient use of water and increases in technologies to recycle and desalinate water.
Experts at the International Water Association congress in September called for investment in water infrastructure to at least double from the current level of $80bn (£49bn) a year to avoid widespread flooding, drought and disease.
Unep has calculated that enough rain falls on Africa to theoretically supply the needs of 13 billion people, and has called for a continent-wide rainwater harvesting programme.
Prince of Wales heads to Sumatra to promote rainforests
Valentine Low in Jambi
The Prince of Wales yields to noone in his love of rainforests, but sometimes it is a love that is hard won. Yesterday he made an epic journey through the storm-lashed tropics, along dirt roads made all but impassable by the rain, to visit a camp that he believes could represent the saving of the world’s rainforests.
It is a subject close to his heart; and nothing was going to stop him getting there. The Harapan rainforest is on the Indonesian island of Sumatra, where illegal loggers have cut vast swaths out of the forest over the years. Three times the size of the Isle of Wight - more than 100,000 hectares - it is now being turned around by a consortium determined to show that rainforests can, in the Prince’s words, be “worth more alive than dead”.
Saving the rainforest is one thing: getting there is another. Harapan is three hours’ drive from the nearest town, a difficult journey at the best of times. At the start of the rainy season, when dirt tracks have been turned into mudbaths, it is one only embarked upon by the brave.
As the Prince’s convoy set out from the regional capital of Jambi, the short stretch of tarmac soon gave way to a forest road pitted with ruts and craters where the only way across the numerous rivers that criss-cross the landscape was by rickety wooden bridges that looked as if they would scarcely bear the weight of the large 4x4s carrying the Prince and his party — now lacking the Duchess of Cornwall, who has returned to Britain.
The 4x4s might have been able to cope with the road - the police water cannon truck could not. Quite what protests the police were expecting that they felt it necessary to send a water cannon into the jungle was unclear, but once it had crashed into a ditch it was not going to be much use in a riot. For 20 minutes it also looked as if it was going to prevent the convoy reaching its destination, until a tow truck appeared to drag it out of the way.
If the journey to the forest was less than straightforward, the Prince - not a man who appreciates delay - did not seem unduly concerned; according to one of his party, he found it all “just hilarious”. More pertinently, he no doubt thought it a price worth paying for reaching a place which highlights perfectly the problems faced by the world’s rainforests. Twenty years ago, Harapan - home to 10 per cent of the world’s surviving Sumatran tigers - was twice the size it is today, but loggers and the palm oil industry have caused serious deforestation.
The resulting damage is about more than the loss of trees. At the Harapan Base Camp, a small community of wooden huts on stilts run by the RSPB and Birdlife, the Prince heard an impassioned plea from a local villager who, like so many others in the area, was forced off his land by the palm growers.
“All we want to do is grow our rice,” said Hasan Bada, 51, who has to support a family of 12 on an income of £2 a day. “Our community is very poor. I find it very difficult to feed my family.” The consortium is trying to help by creating jobs - as forest rangers, or in the nursery where trees are raised before being planted out - and researching better methods for growing crops such as fruit trees.
In the future, they hope to raise money by encouraging eco-tourism.
At the end of his tour the Prince, who was wearing chinos, suede boots and a safari jacket, planted a tree, giving the trowelful of compost an appreciate sniff before he put it in the hole, then stamping it down with his boot. He must have planted hundreds of trees in his time, but that must have been one of the most remote.
What with the tree planting and tramping round the forest, the time he had finished at Harapan the normally sartorially fastidious Prince found himself with a pair of trousers that were proof that the rainforest in the wet season can be a very muddy place. But once again the Prince did not seem to mind; he was muddy, but happy.
The Prince of Wales yields to noone in his love of rainforests, but sometimes it is a love that is hard won. Yesterday he made an epic journey through the storm-lashed tropics, along dirt roads made all but impassable by the rain, to visit a camp that he believes could represent the saving of the world’s rainforests.
It is a subject close to his heart; and nothing was going to stop him getting there. The Harapan rainforest is on the Indonesian island of Sumatra, where illegal loggers have cut vast swaths out of the forest over the years. Three times the size of the Isle of Wight - more than 100,000 hectares - it is now being turned around by a consortium determined to show that rainforests can, in the Prince’s words, be “worth more alive than dead”.
Saving the rainforest is one thing: getting there is another. Harapan is three hours’ drive from the nearest town, a difficult journey at the best of times. At the start of the rainy season, when dirt tracks have been turned into mudbaths, it is one only embarked upon by the brave.
As the Prince’s convoy set out from the regional capital of Jambi, the short stretch of tarmac soon gave way to a forest road pitted with ruts and craters where the only way across the numerous rivers that criss-cross the landscape was by rickety wooden bridges that looked as if they would scarcely bear the weight of the large 4x4s carrying the Prince and his party — now lacking the Duchess of Cornwall, who has returned to Britain.
The 4x4s might have been able to cope with the road - the police water cannon truck could not. Quite what protests the police were expecting that they felt it necessary to send a water cannon into the jungle was unclear, but once it had crashed into a ditch it was not going to be much use in a riot. For 20 minutes it also looked as if it was going to prevent the convoy reaching its destination, until a tow truck appeared to drag it out of the way.
If the journey to the forest was less than straightforward, the Prince - not a man who appreciates delay - did not seem unduly concerned; according to one of his party, he found it all “just hilarious”. More pertinently, he no doubt thought it a price worth paying for reaching a place which highlights perfectly the problems faced by the world’s rainforests. Twenty years ago, Harapan - home to 10 per cent of the world’s surviving Sumatran tigers - was twice the size it is today, but loggers and the palm oil industry have caused serious deforestation.
The resulting damage is about more than the loss of trees. At the Harapan Base Camp, a small community of wooden huts on stilts run by the RSPB and Birdlife, the Prince heard an impassioned plea from a local villager who, like so many others in the area, was forced off his land by the palm growers.
“All we want to do is grow our rice,” said Hasan Bada, 51, who has to support a family of 12 on an income of £2 a day. “Our community is very poor. I find it very difficult to feed my family.” The consortium is trying to help by creating jobs - as forest rangers, or in the nursery where trees are raised before being planted out - and researching better methods for growing crops such as fruit trees.
In the future, they hope to raise money by encouraging eco-tourism.
At the end of his tour the Prince, who was wearing chinos, suede boots and a safari jacket, planted a tree, giving the trowelful of compost an appreciate sniff before he put it in the hole, then stamping it down with his boot. He must have planted hundreds of trees in his time, but that must have been one of the most remote.
What with the tree planting and tramping round the forest, the time he had finished at Harapan the normally sartorially fastidious Prince found himself with a pair of trousers that were proof that the rainforest in the wet season can be a very muddy place. But once again the Prince did not seem to mind; he was muddy, but happy.
In search of the smart grid
By Fiona Harvey, Environment Correspondent
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
Few electricity users even think about the power grid until their lights go out. When that happens, the stresses of the energy transmission system become all too apparent.
Developed countries take the constant availability of electricity for granted but, around the world, the networks of power stations, transmission lines, substations and other equipment that carries power from generator to user are under strain.
"These assets are getting old," says Bob Gilligan, vice president at GE Energy. Some of the equipment has already been in use longer than envisaged when it was installed, and at times of high demand when several power stations are unexpectedly out of service at once, brownouts or blackouts can result.
But the investment needed to restore the ageing grid infrastructure has been lacking. In the US, for instance, an estimated $50bn to $75bn would be needed to update the existing infrastructure and give the US what it has never had - a truly national transmission network that would balance the load across the entire country.
The ageing of existing electricity networks is not the only reason to opt for upgrading. Today's grids are centralised, built to take power from a small number of large power stations and carry it to the millions of homes and businesses where it is used. Electricity grids also balance the supply and demand, so that at any given time the amount being generated matches that being used.
But modern energy requires more than that. Renewable sources of energy require very different grid management techniques than those in use for the past 50 years. Wind turbines and solar power plants produce energy intermittently and unpredictably - not like the nuclear or fossil fuel plants of old.
The rise in popularity of micro-generation, such as solar panels and mini-wind turbines, means homes and offices can now be producers of energy as well as consumers, requiring two-way traffic on a network that was once all one-way.
There are also moves towards building smaller power stations, such as those burning waste or biomass, which are closer to where the energy is used, cutting some of the 5 per cent or more of electricity that is lost down power lines and enabling the waste heat produced to be used to warm local buildings.
Moreover, today's grids incur large costs because of their inefficient use. In order to balance peak demand with the necessary supply, many power stations must be kept on standby, ticking over and ready to supply energy at short notice, which results in massive waste.
For all these reasons, many energy experts now believe the answer lies in upgrading existing energy networks to a new form of grid - the smart grid. Making the electricity grid smart means improving data and communications across it.
Communication hardware and software would be installed to allow operators to monitor in real time where power was coming from and where it was needed. These control systems would allow grid operators to ensure that, while there was enough power when needed, there was no need to keep vast reservoirs of power on standby.
Paul Karr, vice president of market management at Trilliant, a metering and smart grid company, explains: "The grid we have today is dumb. We have very limited visibility [on supply and demand and grid performance]. But by improving the communications intelligence, you can make the grid smarter, which enables you to cut the waste and operate much more efficiently."
The smart grid would be able to cope with taking in power from micro-generation units, and its improved load balancing would mean that intermittent sources of power, such as wind turbines, could be used without needing so much back-up constantly available from fossil-fuel generation.
The peaks and troughs of demand could also be smoothed by making the appliances that use electricity smarter, explains Andrew Howe, chief executive of RLtec, which makes "dynamic demand" technology. He gives fridges, which do not need to have their motor running constantly to maintain an even temperature, as an example. Instead, the motor cuts in and out to cool the fridge when the top of the preferred temperature range is reached. If fridges incorporated "dynamic demand" technology, they could be made to cut in and out at the optimal times for electricity demand.
Other household equipment, such as hot water tanks and electric cars, could similarly be programmed to draw electricity from the grid at quieter times.
Smart electricity meters installed in homes could also help people manage their own electricity use more efficiently. For instance, they could be charged lower prices to use their appliances during off-peak periods, encouraging people to wait or leave devices such as washing machines on timers to start at quiet times of day.
This would also help electricity providers even out usage patterns, lowering peak demand and resulting in greater efficiency.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
Few electricity users even think about the power grid until their lights go out. When that happens, the stresses of the energy transmission system become all too apparent.
Developed countries take the constant availability of electricity for granted but, around the world, the networks of power stations, transmission lines, substations and other equipment that carries power from generator to user are under strain.
"These assets are getting old," says Bob Gilligan, vice president at GE Energy. Some of the equipment has already been in use longer than envisaged when it was installed, and at times of high demand when several power stations are unexpectedly out of service at once, brownouts or blackouts can result.
But the investment needed to restore the ageing grid infrastructure has been lacking. In the US, for instance, an estimated $50bn to $75bn would be needed to update the existing infrastructure and give the US what it has never had - a truly national transmission network that would balance the load across the entire country.
The ageing of existing electricity networks is not the only reason to opt for upgrading. Today's grids are centralised, built to take power from a small number of large power stations and carry it to the millions of homes and businesses where it is used. Electricity grids also balance the supply and demand, so that at any given time the amount being generated matches that being used.
But modern energy requires more than that. Renewable sources of energy require very different grid management techniques than those in use for the past 50 years. Wind turbines and solar power plants produce energy intermittently and unpredictably - not like the nuclear or fossil fuel plants of old.
The rise in popularity of micro-generation, such as solar panels and mini-wind turbines, means homes and offices can now be producers of energy as well as consumers, requiring two-way traffic on a network that was once all one-way.
There are also moves towards building smaller power stations, such as those burning waste or biomass, which are closer to where the energy is used, cutting some of the 5 per cent or more of electricity that is lost down power lines and enabling the waste heat produced to be used to warm local buildings.
Moreover, today's grids incur large costs because of their inefficient use. In order to balance peak demand with the necessary supply, many power stations must be kept on standby, ticking over and ready to supply energy at short notice, which results in massive waste.
For all these reasons, many energy experts now believe the answer lies in upgrading existing energy networks to a new form of grid - the smart grid. Making the electricity grid smart means improving data and communications across it.
Communication hardware and software would be installed to allow operators to monitor in real time where power was coming from and where it was needed. These control systems would allow grid operators to ensure that, while there was enough power when needed, there was no need to keep vast reservoirs of power on standby.
Paul Karr, vice president of market management at Trilliant, a metering and smart grid company, explains: "The grid we have today is dumb. We have very limited visibility [on supply and demand and grid performance]. But by improving the communications intelligence, you can make the grid smarter, which enables you to cut the waste and operate much more efficiently."
The smart grid would be able to cope with taking in power from micro-generation units, and its improved load balancing would mean that intermittent sources of power, such as wind turbines, could be used without needing so much back-up constantly available from fossil-fuel generation.
The peaks and troughs of demand could also be smoothed by making the appliances that use electricity smarter, explains Andrew Howe, chief executive of RLtec, which makes "dynamic demand" technology. He gives fridges, which do not need to have their motor running constantly to maintain an even temperature, as an example. Instead, the motor cuts in and out to cool the fridge when the top of the preferred temperature range is reached. If fridges incorporated "dynamic demand" technology, they could be made to cut in and out at the optimal times for electricity demand.
Other household equipment, such as hot water tanks and electric cars, could similarly be programmed to draw electricity from the grid at quieter times.
Smart electricity meters installed in homes could also help people manage their own electricity use more efficiently. For instance, they could be charged lower prices to use their appliances during off-peak periods, encouraging people to wait or leave devices such as washing machines on timers to start at quiet times of day.
This would also help electricity providers even out usage patterns, lowering peak demand and resulting in greater efficiency.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
The dawn of a disturbing new reality
By Carola Hoyos
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
In the past month, the world has witnessed one of the largest financial and economic upheavals in a generation. The fallout may have been most immediately felt on Wall Street, but the effect on energy, and perhaps even the environment, will also be profound.
Christophe de Margerie, chief executive of Total, the French oil company, who usually argues for governments to get out of the way of those trying to bring enough energy to the market to satisfy demand, this week said recent events meant lawmakers needed to consider extending a helping hand to environmentally friendly energy sources and technologies made uneconomical by falling oil prices.
Executives say environmental initiatives such as carbon capture and storage must not be abandoned and oilfields need to be developed in an as environmentally friendly way as possible. But Chevron has already warned that Australia's cap and trade initiative could make the development of the Gorgon gas field uneconomical.
Royal Dutch Shell has dropped its proposed investment in plans to build the world's biggest offshore wind farm, the London Array, to concentrate on less risky US onshore wind power.
On the government side, the trend could be similar, as environmentalists worry that the billions being spent on bailing out banks may not leave much for the environment. Indeed, amid the fiercely contested US presidential election, the credit crunch has firmly overtaken energy security as issue number one, at least in terms of rhetoric.
But Mr De Margerie's main message centred on security of supply, rather than the environment. He and other executives contend that the drop in oil prices will make it more difficult to develop enough energy to meet the future demand of countries, such as China and India, and could prolong the downturn.
The Opec oil cartel made that same point in its communiqué last week, in the hope of justifying its decision to cut production by as much as 1.8m barrels a day. "Oil prices have witnessed a dramatic collapse - unprecedented in speed and magnitude - with these falling to levels which may put at jeopardy many existing oil projects and lead to the cancellation or delay of others, possibly resulting in a medium-term supply shortage."
Projects in high-cost areas, such as Canada's oil sands and in the deep waters of west Africa, are already being delayed, while the development of giant fields such as Russia's Shtokman gasfield have become more tenuous, as Gazprom, the monopoly, struggles under the credit squeeze.
In fact, the International Energy Agency, the developed countries' watchdog, does not see Russia, the world's second largest oil exporter, being able to increase its production at all in a draft of the Paris-based agency's latest forecast to 2030.
Many of Russia's biggest oil fields are ageing and declining, and tax cuts meant to give companies incentives to develop new fields and help boost the production of old onesare too little, too late, executives and analysts say.
But the problem is far from limited to Russia.
In fact, the IEA believes the single most important factor in deciding how hard the energy industry will have to work to meet demand is the rate at which ageing oil fields are declining.
Preliminary results of a study of the world's largest oilfields, due to be published by the IEA next month, indicate that the scale of the challenge is great.
The world will need to invest $360bn a year in boosting oil production to meet demand, initial data in an early draft of the report obtained by the FT, states. Much of that money will need to be spent in countries where oil reserves are controlled by national oil companies that are either too badly managed or technically incapable of making the necesary investments.
Worldwide, oilfields are declining at an annual natural rate of 9.1 per cent and, even with investment to boost production, are still declining at 6.4 per cent, the IEA's draft report states.
Making the kinds of investments to arrest decline is more difficult when prices are low. Oil companies often choose to shut down a field, rather than pour more money in for little gain. It is a reality that could be felt in the North Sea, where years of high oil prices have prompted a flotilla of niche companies to sail in to save small oilfields.
In fact, many of those small oil companies are now struggling as their share prices have dropped and, in some cases, the credit crunch has eaten into their ability to fund production programmes.
This new reality is one of the other leading forces that have emerged to change the industry, as credit has become tight and oil prices have fallen.
Ian Taylor, head of Vitol, the energy trader, says he believes the industry stands at the edge of a wave of consolidation. "This is the best opportunity for 15-20 years. Many companies are trading at below the value of their assets," he says.
Indeed, on the day he was speaking, BG announced a deal to acquire Queensland Gas for A$5.6bn ($3.8bn). The bid was at an 80 per cent premium to the previous QGC share price, but still valued the Australian company's gas reserves at less than half the implied value paid by ConocoPhillips of the US for similar assets over the summer.
The pickings are richest for the biggest companies by market capitalisation. Their shares have for years traded at relatively low earning multiples despite record revenues, as their inability to grow by finding new fields or taking over large companies has let them down.
These companies are now sitting on unspent cash ($40bn in the case of ExxonMobil, the largest of the group) and very low debt.
As Tony Hayward, chief executive of BP, put it: "We think the current turmoil may create opportunities for us and we will look at those very closely."
Total is said to be eyeing Nexen, a Canadian oil company, whose shares have fallen more than 50 per cent in the past six months, meaning it is no longer too expensive to buy.
Executives from other big oil companies, meanwhile, say they are looking at US players, such as Anadarko.
BG, whose liquefied natural gas portfolio had for years made it attractive to the majors, but which was too big and expensive to be bought, is now again on radar screens, executives say.
Maurice Berns of the Boston Consulting Group, says: "In previous downturns, what have we seen the successful companies do? They consolidate and build competitive strength to come out in a better position when the dust has settled."
But the future will not lie in the hands of those companies. Instead, it will be the investment decisions of national oil companies, many of which are in Opec countries, that will decide whether there is enough oil to see the world out of economic turmoil. And it will be up to governments to ensure the environment is considered in times of economic sickness, as well as in times of economic health.
So far, the signs that either will be able to act in the world's best interest are growing weaker - with the fall in the oil price and the onset of recession - rather than stronger.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
In the past month, the world has witnessed one of the largest financial and economic upheavals in a generation. The fallout may have been most immediately felt on Wall Street, but the effect on energy, and perhaps even the environment, will also be profound.
Christophe de Margerie, chief executive of Total, the French oil company, who usually argues for governments to get out of the way of those trying to bring enough energy to the market to satisfy demand, this week said recent events meant lawmakers needed to consider extending a helping hand to environmentally friendly energy sources and technologies made uneconomical by falling oil prices.
Executives say environmental initiatives such as carbon capture and storage must not be abandoned and oilfields need to be developed in an as environmentally friendly way as possible. But Chevron has already warned that Australia's cap and trade initiative could make the development of the Gorgon gas field uneconomical.
Royal Dutch Shell has dropped its proposed investment in plans to build the world's biggest offshore wind farm, the London Array, to concentrate on less risky US onshore wind power.
On the government side, the trend could be similar, as environmentalists worry that the billions being spent on bailing out banks may not leave much for the environment. Indeed, amid the fiercely contested US presidential election, the credit crunch has firmly overtaken energy security as issue number one, at least in terms of rhetoric.
But Mr De Margerie's main message centred on security of supply, rather than the environment. He and other executives contend that the drop in oil prices will make it more difficult to develop enough energy to meet the future demand of countries, such as China and India, and could prolong the downturn.
The Opec oil cartel made that same point in its communiqué last week, in the hope of justifying its decision to cut production by as much as 1.8m barrels a day. "Oil prices have witnessed a dramatic collapse - unprecedented in speed and magnitude - with these falling to levels which may put at jeopardy many existing oil projects and lead to the cancellation or delay of others, possibly resulting in a medium-term supply shortage."
Projects in high-cost areas, such as Canada's oil sands and in the deep waters of west Africa, are already being delayed, while the development of giant fields such as Russia's Shtokman gasfield have become more tenuous, as Gazprom, the monopoly, struggles under the credit squeeze.
In fact, the International Energy Agency, the developed countries' watchdog, does not see Russia, the world's second largest oil exporter, being able to increase its production at all in a draft of the Paris-based agency's latest forecast to 2030.
Many of Russia's biggest oil fields are ageing and declining, and tax cuts meant to give companies incentives to develop new fields and help boost the production of old onesare too little, too late, executives and analysts say.
But the problem is far from limited to Russia.
In fact, the IEA believes the single most important factor in deciding how hard the energy industry will have to work to meet demand is the rate at which ageing oil fields are declining.
Preliminary results of a study of the world's largest oilfields, due to be published by the IEA next month, indicate that the scale of the challenge is great.
The world will need to invest $360bn a year in boosting oil production to meet demand, initial data in an early draft of the report obtained by the FT, states. Much of that money will need to be spent in countries where oil reserves are controlled by national oil companies that are either too badly managed or technically incapable of making the necesary investments.
Worldwide, oilfields are declining at an annual natural rate of 9.1 per cent and, even with investment to boost production, are still declining at 6.4 per cent, the IEA's draft report states.
Making the kinds of investments to arrest decline is more difficult when prices are low. Oil companies often choose to shut down a field, rather than pour more money in for little gain. It is a reality that could be felt in the North Sea, where years of high oil prices have prompted a flotilla of niche companies to sail in to save small oilfields.
In fact, many of those small oil companies are now struggling as their share prices have dropped and, in some cases, the credit crunch has eaten into their ability to fund production programmes.
This new reality is one of the other leading forces that have emerged to change the industry, as credit has become tight and oil prices have fallen.
Ian Taylor, head of Vitol, the energy trader, says he believes the industry stands at the edge of a wave of consolidation. "This is the best opportunity for 15-20 years. Many companies are trading at below the value of their assets," he says.
Indeed, on the day he was speaking, BG announced a deal to acquire Queensland Gas for A$5.6bn ($3.8bn). The bid was at an 80 per cent premium to the previous QGC share price, but still valued the Australian company's gas reserves at less than half the implied value paid by ConocoPhillips of the US for similar assets over the summer.
The pickings are richest for the biggest companies by market capitalisation. Their shares have for years traded at relatively low earning multiples despite record revenues, as their inability to grow by finding new fields or taking over large companies has let them down.
These companies are now sitting on unspent cash ($40bn in the case of ExxonMobil, the largest of the group) and very low debt.
As Tony Hayward, chief executive of BP, put it: "We think the current turmoil may create opportunities for us and we will look at those very closely."
Total is said to be eyeing Nexen, a Canadian oil company, whose shares have fallen more than 50 per cent in the past six months, meaning it is no longer too expensive to buy.
Executives from other big oil companies, meanwhile, say they are looking at US players, such as Anadarko.
BG, whose liquefied natural gas portfolio had for years made it attractive to the majors, but which was too big and expensive to be bought, is now again on radar screens, executives say.
Maurice Berns of the Boston Consulting Group, says: "In previous downturns, what have we seen the successful companies do? They consolidate and build competitive strength to come out in a better position when the dust has settled."
But the future will not lie in the hands of those companies. Instead, it will be the investment decisions of national oil companies, many of which are in Opec countries, that will decide whether there is enough oil to see the world out of economic turmoil. And it will be up to governments to ensure the environment is considered in times of economic sickness, as well as in times of economic health.
So far, the signs that either will be able to act in the world's best interest are growing weaker - with the fall in the oil price and the onset of recession - rather than stronger.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Stalemate in the struggle over untapped local sources
By Sheila McNulty
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
When petrol prices rose to $4 a gallon, Americans pulled back on demand and supported opening environmentally protected areas to exploration and production.
Yet the financial crisis has led to a drop in oil prices that has pushed petrol down below $3 a gallon. The crisis for many Americans has passed. And with it has gone the momentum for finding new sources of oil and gas.
"People were traumatised for a while," says Robin West, chairman of PFC Energy, the consultancy. "Unfortunately," he says, "an extended period of lower prices is likely to usher in complacency again."
The problems oil and gas companies have trying to grow reserves in the US will continue. About half of all federal lands are off-limits to the industry. Restrictive regulations mean even more land, while officially open to production, is not producing.
Yet, until this year, there has not been much appetite among Americans to change that, in part because environmentalism was on the rise, but also because other anti-drilling lobbyists had the ear of the people. The consequence has been a stalemate between the oil and gas developers and those opposing their rapid development of resources.
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM), which controls federal land, is stuck in the middle, trying to carrying out its mandate to allocate land for multiple uses.
"Someone is always unhappy," says Mike Stiewig, head of the bureau's office in Price, Utah, overseeing the Nine Mile Canyon, where a battle between industry and historians is raging over plans to develop natural gas resources amid ancient Indian carvings. "If everybody is mad at me, I'm probably about where I have to be."
Congress has yet to recognise energy decisions may have a cost for the consumer. By continuing to side with the special-interest groups against increasing domestic production, it is maintaining such stalemates to keep energy costs high.
Yet Robin West, chairman of PFC Energy, says, "The intrusion of oil exploration and production [in the US] - the footprint - is quite modest. The potential for environmental damage is very, very slight. Politicians must recognise the cost of their decisions and that refusal to act will have a cost.''
If Senator John McCain is elected president, protected areas off the Florida coast are likely to be opened to exploration and production.
Yet the industry will approach any drop in regulations cautiously. They remember that, in the 1980s, Chevron leased acreage off the Florida coast from the federal government and discovered what it estimated to be up to 1,300 bn cubic feet of gas. The Destin Dome project was estimated to be one of the nation's largest gas reserves, and Chevron invested almost 10 years in planning the field's development before the protests of environmentalists led Washington to block the project.
"I'm one of the guys who lived the experience," says David Duplantier, Chevron's senior counsel on the project, adding that it left him "black and blue". Chevron sued the government and spent three years in litigation before recovering $47m to cover out-of-pocket expenses - but not the legal fees or wasted commitment of equipment and people.
"Governments understand we have the ability to produce in a way that is sensitive to the environment in other parts of the world," Mr Duplantier says. "Why this government doesn't accept that is beyond me."
Except for the Exxon Valdez disaster in Alaska in 1989, when the tanker ran aground, spilling 11m gallons of oil in Prince William Sound, there has not been a big disaster in the US in recent years.
Yet environmentalists note countless examples of land, sea and air spills each year in the development of fossil fuels in the US.
"Throughout the entire lifecycle of the oil process, from exploration to extraction to transport to burning, there are routine releases of oil and other contaminants into land, air and water, not to mention when we are burning that oil, it is like a spill in the sky because it contributes to global warming," says Melanie Duchin, climate campaigner for Greenpeace.
She says increasing oil and gas production in the US will only give the country a false sense of security.
New technologies being used to tap unconventional sources - tar sands, for example, or shale gas - are not only more expensive, but more damaging to the environment. Ms Duchin thinks money being poured into finding and producing more oil and gas in the US should be used to improve fuel efficiencies and develop alternative energies.
This is the position Senator Barack Obama, the Democratic presidential candidate, appears to favour.
Yet Mr West insists the US needs every responsible energy source it can get given that an oil production crunch is coming. And while alternative energies were competitive when oil and gas prices were high, it is more difficult for them to compete with the commodities at these levels.
"The challenge,'' he says, "is how you sustain these alternative businesses between the boom and bust cycles, because we're going to need these energy sources in the future."
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
When petrol prices rose to $4 a gallon, Americans pulled back on demand and supported opening environmentally protected areas to exploration and production.
Yet the financial crisis has led to a drop in oil prices that has pushed petrol down below $3 a gallon. The crisis for many Americans has passed. And with it has gone the momentum for finding new sources of oil and gas.
"People were traumatised for a while," says Robin West, chairman of PFC Energy, the consultancy. "Unfortunately," he says, "an extended period of lower prices is likely to usher in complacency again."
The problems oil and gas companies have trying to grow reserves in the US will continue. About half of all federal lands are off-limits to the industry. Restrictive regulations mean even more land, while officially open to production, is not producing.
Yet, until this year, there has not been much appetite among Americans to change that, in part because environmentalism was on the rise, but also because other anti-drilling lobbyists had the ear of the people. The consequence has been a stalemate between the oil and gas developers and those opposing their rapid development of resources.
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM), which controls federal land, is stuck in the middle, trying to carrying out its mandate to allocate land for multiple uses.
"Someone is always unhappy," says Mike Stiewig, head of the bureau's office in Price, Utah, overseeing the Nine Mile Canyon, where a battle between industry and historians is raging over plans to develop natural gas resources amid ancient Indian carvings. "If everybody is mad at me, I'm probably about where I have to be."
Congress has yet to recognise energy decisions may have a cost for the consumer. By continuing to side with the special-interest groups against increasing domestic production, it is maintaining such stalemates to keep energy costs high.
Yet Robin West, chairman of PFC Energy, says, "The intrusion of oil exploration and production [in the US] - the footprint - is quite modest. The potential for environmental damage is very, very slight. Politicians must recognise the cost of their decisions and that refusal to act will have a cost.''
If Senator John McCain is elected president, protected areas off the Florida coast are likely to be opened to exploration and production.
Yet the industry will approach any drop in regulations cautiously. They remember that, in the 1980s, Chevron leased acreage off the Florida coast from the federal government and discovered what it estimated to be up to 1,300 bn cubic feet of gas. The Destin Dome project was estimated to be one of the nation's largest gas reserves, and Chevron invested almost 10 years in planning the field's development before the protests of environmentalists led Washington to block the project.
"I'm one of the guys who lived the experience," says David Duplantier, Chevron's senior counsel on the project, adding that it left him "black and blue". Chevron sued the government and spent three years in litigation before recovering $47m to cover out-of-pocket expenses - but not the legal fees or wasted commitment of equipment and people.
"Governments understand we have the ability to produce in a way that is sensitive to the environment in other parts of the world," Mr Duplantier says. "Why this government doesn't accept that is beyond me."
Except for the Exxon Valdez disaster in Alaska in 1989, when the tanker ran aground, spilling 11m gallons of oil in Prince William Sound, there has not been a big disaster in the US in recent years.
Yet environmentalists note countless examples of land, sea and air spills each year in the development of fossil fuels in the US.
"Throughout the entire lifecycle of the oil process, from exploration to extraction to transport to burning, there are routine releases of oil and other contaminants into land, air and water, not to mention when we are burning that oil, it is like a spill in the sky because it contributes to global warming," says Melanie Duchin, climate campaigner for Greenpeace.
She says increasing oil and gas production in the US will only give the country a false sense of security.
New technologies being used to tap unconventional sources - tar sands, for example, or shale gas - are not only more expensive, but more damaging to the environment. Ms Duchin thinks money being poured into finding and producing more oil and gas in the US should be used to improve fuel efficiencies and develop alternative energies.
This is the position Senator Barack Obama, the Democratic presidential candidate, appears to favour.
Yet Mr West insists the US needs every responsible energy source it can get given that an oil production crunch is coming. And while alternative energies were competitive when oil and gas prices were high, it is more difficult for them to compete with the commodities at these levels.
"The challenge,'' he says, "is how you sustain these alternative businesses between the boom and bust cycles, because we're going to need these energy sources in the future."
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Litter and waste provide a tidy solution
By Dan Ilett
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
The United Nations Foundation says that heavier use and manufacturing of biomass fuels in West Africa could help to cut poverty and boost economic development.
The organisation argues that biomass - fuel derived from plant material, wood, agricultural and municipal waste - could aid these countries to "avoid high food and oil prices and open up new economic opportunities".
West Africa is not the only region eyeing up biomass as an attractive source of energy. Whether that source is a pure alternative to fossil fuels or just a cleaner addition is yet to be seen. But many other countries have started using it in projects ranging from coal-powered energy stations down the chain to wood-burning stoves in homes that warm central heating systems.
"Biomass means you can keep fossil fuels underground," says Gaynor Hartnell, deputy director of the Renewable Energy Association. "If you burn wood, there are still trees growing. If you burn waste, we produce this all the time.
"There will be some carbon, but it's not the same as it is using fossil fuels. It makes a lot of sense to use it, as a lot is a by-product of crop waste. You can have dedicated plants that can burn litter or waste wood or combined heat and power schemes that take briquettes."
There are many different sources of biomass. Ms Hartnell argues that methane emitted from landfill and sewage gas are regarded as biomass, as is olive cake (the pulp left over from making olive oil), straw, and the cut-offs from wood.
Many of these materials, especially wood and straw, are made into pellets for a larger surface area to make the biomass burn better.
Drax Power is currently building a co-firing biomass injection system at its 4,000MW power station in Yorkshire to burn coal and biomass pellets together.
"We've been in biomass for about five years to cut CO 2 ," says Melanie Wedgbury, external relations for Drax Power. "If you use it to produce electricity, it's deemed to be carbon neutral."
While some people argue carbon neutrality is something of an oxymoron, the company believes the biomass initiative will by 2010 power around 12.5 per cent (500MW) of the station.
"Typically, 2 to 3 per cent of our output has been biomass," adds Ms Wedgbury. "The engineers say we could go up to 20 per cent for co-fired, but biomass is different to coal. It's got two-thirds of the heat but it's a very efficient way of burning materials."
There are many companies in the biomass field however, as there are many sources, processes and final products of the fuel.
For instance, Drax awarded Doosan Babcock a £10m contract to build the co-firing stations, but local farmers provide the fuel.
In the case of bin-bag-waste biomass, local governments are the providers, but other firms carry out processing, packaging and sales. Land Energy, for example, plans to generate renewable power from virgin wood, by producing and selling wood pellets. The company is building plants in Wales, Scotland and England, at sites close to forests.
O-Gen is set to build 15 plants around the UK to convert biomass into a combustible gas, which is then used to produce heat and power around the country.
"The type of land that biomass is grown on is marginal land - not high quality," adds Ms Wedgbury. "The materials are all very well and good but they have to be sustainable. That's the big issue in biomass as you know the food versus fuel debate with bioethanol."
According to the WWF, "bioenergy [also known as biomass] production can have negative environmental impacts such as acidification, eutrophication or summer smog. The production of energy crops can also have negative impacts depending on what agricultural or forestry methods are used."
But it adds that, worldwide, "biomass could deliver 9 per cent of global primary energy and 24 per cent of electricity requirements by the year 2020". Recent figures from the European Biomass Association suggest that biomass use is slowly increasing in use, but this is still comparatively low compared to fossil fuel use.
Figures also show that burning municipal solid waste is becoming more popular in Europe, although unpopular with campaign groups, who believe it encourages people to forget about recycling.
"Is it popular to have a waste-to-energy plant in your backyard?" asks Matt Taylor, a partner at investment firm Foresight. "You'd say no, but in Scandinavia, no city would be without its waste-to-energy plant.
"One way of looking at this is that about 60 per cent of waste goes into landfill in the UK. The rest is incinerated. In [mainland] Europe landfill is down to 20 per cent. In the UK a lot of people think they will be importing biomass from the US, but they're on a similar curve to us. There is a lot more biomass per head in the US, though.
"It will take us between five and 10 years to get there in the biomass market. There are some clear timetables in terms of using municipal waste and to stop landfill. The targets for this are between 2013 to 2020."
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
The United Nations Foundation says that heavier use and manufacturing of biomass fuels in West Africa could help to cut poverty and boost economic development.
The organisation argues that biomass - fuel derived from plant material, wood, agricultural and municipal waste - could aid these countries to "avoid high food and oil prices and open up new economic opportunities".
West Africa is not the only region eyeing up biomass as an attractive source of energy. Whether that source is a pure alternative to fossil fuels or just a cleaner addition is yet to be seen. But many other countries have started using it in projects ranging from coal-powered energy stations down the chain to wood-burning stoves in homes that warm central heating systems.
"Biomass means you can keep fossil fuels underground," says Gaynor Hartnell, deputy director of the Renewable Energy Association. "If you burn wood, there are still trees growing. If you burn waste, we produce this all the time.
"There will be some carbon, but it's not the same as it is using fossil fuels. It makes a lot of sense to use it, as a lot is a by-product of crop waste. You can have dedicated plants that can burn litter or waste wood or combined heat and power schemes that take briquettes."
There are many different sources of biomass. Ms Hartnell argues that methane emitted from landfill and sewage gas are regarded as biomass, as is olive cake (the pulp left over from making olive oil), straw, and the cut-offs from wood.
Many of these materials, especially wood and straw, are made into pellets for a larger surface area to make the biomass burn better.
Drax Power is currently building a co-firing biomass injection system at its 4,000MW power station in Yorkshire to burn coal and biomass pellets together.
"We've been in biomass for about five years to cut CO 2 ," says Melanie Wedgbury, external relations for Drax Power. "If you use it to produce electricity, it's deemed to be carbon neutral."
While some people argue carbon neutrality is something of an oxymoron, the company believes the biomass initiative will by 2010 power around 12.5 per cent (500MW) of the station.
"Typically, 2 to 3 per cent of our output has been biomass," adds Ms Wedgbury. "The engineers say we could go up to 20 per cent for co-fired, but biomass is different to coal. It's got two-thirds of the heat but it's a very efficient way of burning materials."
There are many companies in the biomass field however, as there are many sources, processes and final products of the fuel.
For instance, Drax awarded Doosan Babcock a £10m contract to build the co-firing stations, but local farmers provide the fuel.
In the case of bin-bag-waste biomass, local governments are the providers, but other firms carry out processing, packaging and sales. Land Energy, for example, plans to generate renewable power from virgin wood, by producing and selling wood pellets. The company is building plants in Wales, Scotland and England, at sites close to forests.
O-Gen is set to build 15 plants around the UK to convert biomass into a combustible gas, which is then used to produce heat and power around the country.
"The type of land that biomass is grown on is marginal land - not high quality," adds Ms Wedgbury. "The materials are all very well and good but they have to be sustainable. That's the big issue in biomass as you know the food versus fuel debate with bioethanol."
According to the WWF, "bioenergy [also known as biomass] production can have negative environmental impacts such as acidification, eutrophication or summer smog. The production of energy crops can also have negative impacts depending on what agricultural or forestry methods are used."
But it adds that, worldwide, "biomass could deliver 9 per cent of global primary energy and 24 per cent of electricity requirements by the year 2020". Recent figures from the European Biomass Association suggest that biomass use is slowly increasing in use, but this is still comparatively low compared to fossil fuel use.
Figures also show that burning municipal solid waste is becoming more popular in Europe, although unpopular with campaign groups, who believe it encourages people to forget about recycling.
"Is it popular to have a waste-to-energy plant in your backyard?" asks Matt Taylor, a partner at investment firm Foresight. "You'd say no, but in Scandinavia, no city would be without its waste-to-energy plant.
"One way of looking at this is that about 60 per cent of waste goes into landfill in the UK. The rest is incinerated. In [mainland] Europe landfill is down to 20 per cent. In the UK a lot of people think they will be importing biomass from the US, but they're on a similar curve to us. There is a lot more biomass per head in the US, though.
"It will take us between five and 10 years to get there in the biomass market. There are some clear timetables in terms of using municipal waste and to stop landfill. The targets for this are between 2013 to 2020."
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
