Leading European engineers say governments are slow to pass legislation that will implement renewable energy technology that is already available
Alok Jha, green technology correspondent
guardian.co.uk,
Wednesday November 05 2008 15.36 GMT
The experts tasked with delivering Europe's green energy revolution have said that a lack of political leadership is their biggest single obstacle in meeting the continent's ambitious targets for renewable power.
At a meeting of more than 100 leading European engineers this week, half said that, while the technology already exists to deliver 20% of all of the EU's primary energy from renewables, governments are slow to pass legislation that would enable it to be introduced quickly.
The engineers, representing 21 European countries, came together under the auspices of the Royal Academy of Engineering (RAEng) in London to discuss the technical challenges in meeting Europe's renewables challenges. When asked to choose the single biggest potential stumbling block, 50% chose a lack of political will.
Consumer behaviour came next but it was far behind the political problem, topping the list for only 19% of the engineers. The next biggest issue was the lack of suitable government incentives for generating renewable power, chosen by 13% and then insufficient capacity in electricity grids with 9%.
Despite the problems, 66% of the expert group felt the EU's 2020 targets could be achieved with a concerted effort.
"There is today a diversity of views of energy security and how serious climate change is," said Jan van der Ejik, chief technology officer at Shell. "That translates to a lack of political resource."
That lack of leadership has fed into a shortage of suitable incentives that could shepherd new technologies into the crowded energy market. The engineers highlighted the example of feed-in tariffs, which pay electricity generators a guaranteed premium price for the power they produce from renewable sources. While these tariffs have accelerated the introduction of solar technology in Germany and wave power in Portugal, the same is not true for the UK.
The Energy Bill, currently making its way through the British parliament, does include an amendment to introduce feed-in tariffs, but environmental campaigners have argued that the government's proposals are too weak.
The experts at the RAEng meeting questioned whether the EU should maintain its commitment to raise its renewable energy target to 30%, if a successor to the Kyoto protocol was agreed next year: 72% of the group felt the rise was unecessary.
"It's much more important that we cut CO2 emissions than raise the targets for new renewables sources," said Irene Aegerter, vice president of the Swiss Academy of Engineering Sciences. "We don't need to go to 30% but we have to include all potential CO2-free energy sources like nuclear."
Others at the meeting agreed that the EU should only set a carbon-reduction target and then let countries individually decide how to reach it, whether by renewables technology or approaches such as energy efficiency. Technologies that increase efficiency are the best, said Paul Caseau of the National Academy of Technologies of France. "Society is quite ready to use them, they are not extremely expensive and they can be used for a long time. If you do only one thing, then you do only that."
Efficiency technologies were seen by 24% of the engineers as one of the top three ways, after renewables, to reduce CO2 emissions. Nuclear power was seen as a priority by 21% of the expert group and carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology by 18%. "Even as far out as 2050, fossil fuels are still accounting for two-thirds of the energy supply," said Van der Ejik. "What needs to be done is find real progress in CCS – it's only if we tackle that source of CO2 that we can hope to bring emissions down."
There was also majority support for the construction of a pan-European energy supergrid: 86% of the engineers thought it a good way to balance out the intermittency of renewable power sources across the continent. The grid could be fed, for example, by solar power plants in southern Europe and the Sahara region and with wave, tidal and biomass plants across the north of the continent. It would allow countries such as the UK and Denmark to export wind energy at times of surplus supply, as well as import from other green sources such as geothermal power in Iceland.
The European supergrid plan already has tentative support from politicians, including Nicolas Sarkozy, who commissioned a study earlier this year into whether such a renewable energy grid would be feasible. The engineers at the RAEng meeting said that any European grid plan should include not only strengthening the existing national grids, so that they can carry more power, but also the construction of a new backbone of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) transmission lines, which can carry electricity long distances without losing as much power as standard alternating-current lines.
Thursday, 6 November 2008
Windfarmers find fertile ground in Welsh hills
Plans to build one of the one of Britain's biggest windfarms were announced yesterday. Costing just under £16m and potentially producing 69MW, it would be operational by the end of 2010. Renewable Energy Holdings decided on the site in Llangurig, Powys, after an independent study revealed that the winds were strong enough to make it one of the most efficient sites in the UK. "You could say this is our cornerstone investment," chief executive Mike Proffitt said. "The study revealed that the site has a net capacity factor of 36%, while the global average for wind farms is 24-32%."Abhinav Ramnarayan
Judge denies Evergreen request on Barclays shares
Reuters
Published: November 6, 2008
By Emily Chasan
A U.S. judge on Wednesday denied a request from solar power panel maker Evergreen Solar Inc's that would have prevented British bank Barclays PLC from trading in 12.2 million shares of Evergreen stock.
In a hearing in U.S. bankruptcy court in Manhattan, Judge James Peck said he was "unconvinced" that Evergreen would be irreparably harmed without a temporary injunction that would have locked up the shares during litigation.
Emanuel Grillo, a lawyer for Evergreen, said at the hearing that Barclays acquired the shares improperly as part of its purchase of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc's core U.S. brokerage business. Barclays is now the company's second-largest shareholder and Grillo said the lack of clarity about the status of the shares could prevent Evergreen from going to the markets to raise more money from the markets.
In the hearing, Evergreen Chief Financial Officer Michael El-Hillow testified that the company is a start-up and does not generate cash, but instead loses about $7 million (4.4 million pounds) to $10 million per month.
"We survive on our ability to access capital markets," El-Hillow said.
Evergreen filed a lawsuit last month, saying that 30.9 million shares of its stock had been loaned to Lehman in connection with a $375 million financing the investment bank ran for the company in July 2008. About 18 million of the shares had been sold into the markets by Lehman, and were not transferred to Barclays, Grillo said.
Peck said he did not believe Evergreen's concern about the Barclays shares would be the primary difficulty in raising money.
"The problems with obtaining financing in today's credit markets are manifest .... It is difficult for me to identify the parking of these particular shares at Barclays as a principal impediment to the successful identification and closing of alternative means to finance the company's operations."
(Reporting by Emily Chasan, editing by Richard Chang)
Published: November 6, 2008
By Emily Chasan
A U.S. judge on Wednesday denied a request from solar power panel maker Evergreen Solar Inc's that would have prevented British bank Barclays PLC from trading in 12.2 million shares of Evergreen stock.
In a hearing in U.S. bankruptcy court in Manhattan, Judge James Peck said he was "unconvinced" that Evergreen would be irreparably harmed without a temporary injunction that would have locked up the shares during litigation.
Emanuel Grillo, a lawyer for Evergreen, said at the hearing that Barclays acquired the shares improperly as part of its purchase of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc's core U.S. brokerage business. Barclays is now the company's second-largest shareholder and Grillo said the lack of clarity about the status of the shares could prevent Evergreen from going to the markets to raise more money from the markets.
In the hearing, Evergreen Chief Financial Officer Michael El-Hillow testified that the company is a start-up and does not generate cash, but instead loses about $7 million (4.4 million pounds) to $10 million per month.
"We survive on our ability to access capital markets," El-Hillow said.
Evergreen filed a lawsuit last month, saying that 30.9 million shares of its stock had been loaned to Lehman in connection with a $375 million financing the investment bank ran for the company in July 2008. About 18 million of the shares had been sold into the markets by Lehman, and were not transferred to Barclays, Grillo said.
Peck said he did not believe Evergreen's concern about the Barclays shares would be the primary difficulty in raising money.
"The problems with obtaining financing in today's credit markets are manifest .... It is difficult for me to identify the parking of these particular shares at Barclays as a principal impediment to the successful identification and closing of alternative means to finance the company's operations."
(Reporting by Emily Chasan, editing by Richard Chang)
US energy sector feeling winds of change
By Ed Crooks and Sheila McNulty
Published: November 5 2008 20:47
In the last few days of the campaign, Republicans attacked Barack Obama in coal-producing states such as Ohio and Pennsylvania by highlighting his warning in January that companies building coal-fired power stations would go “bankrupt” under his plan to cut carbon dioxide emissions.
Although in vain, the tactic was a well-aimed blow.
Energy policy is one of the areas where Mr Obama has the most ambitious goals, and where his administration is likely to make the greatest difference.
The twin objectives of strengthening US energy security and fighting climate change point towards radical policies that are set to raise the cost of energy and bring about the most profound shake-up in the industry for more than two decades.
As oil has fallen from $147 a barrel in July to about $68 on Wednesday, the pressure to cut consumption has also faded. Mr Obama has been careful with talk of “energy independence”, a concept derided by most industry experts, but he is committed to curbing US demand for foreign oil.
His target is a cut equivalent to US imports from the Middle East and Venezuela, – 4.3m barrels per day last year, or 20 per cent of US consumption – in 10 years.
A fall on that scale would not be unprecedented. A deep recession and soaring oil prices brought an equivalent decline between the late 1970s and the early 1980s.
Mr Obama hopes to deliver his cut in imports by measures including raising fuel economy standards for vehicles by 4 per cent per year, and setting a new target for “advanced” second generation biofuels to be brought in by 2030.
In the longer term, the bigger impact is likely to come from the strategy to fight climate change.
Mr Obama is committed to an 80 per cent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, and has set several intermediate objectives.
He wants a national trading scheme for carbon dioxide emissions, in which companies would have to pay for all permits, unlike the European Union, where the introduction of the scheme was smoothed by giving away permits at first.
That explains why Mr Obama rightly identified his plans as bad news for coal-fired power generators.
He has also proposed targets for the proportion of the US’s electricity to be derived from renewable sources: 10 per cent by 2012 and 25 per cent by 2025.
Steve Mitnick, a partner at Oliver Wyman, an international management consulting firm, said: “I think we’re positioned for a major boom for wind and solar.”
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 5 2008 20:47
In the last few days of the campaign, Republicans attacked Barack Obama in coal-producing states such as Ohio and Pennsylvania by highlighting his warning in January that companies building coal-fired power stations would go “bankrupt” under his plan to cut carbon dioxide emissions.
Although in vain, the tactic was a well-aimed blow.
Energy policy is one of the areas where Mr Obama has the most ambitious goals, and where his administration is likely to make the greatest difference.
The twin objectives of strengthening US energy security and fighting climate change point towards radical policies that are set to raise the cost of energy and bring about the most profound shake-up in the industry for more than two decades.
As oil has fallen from $147 a barrel in July to about $68 on Wednesday, the pressure to cut consumption has also faded. Mr Obama has been careful with talk of “energy independence”, a concept derided by most industry experts, but he is committed to curbing US demand for foreign oil.
His target is a cut equivalent to US imports from the Middle East and Venezuela, – 4.3m barrels per day last year, or 20 per cent of US consumption – in 10 years.
A fall on that scale would not be unprecedented. A deep recession and soaring oil prices brought an equivalent decline between the late 1970s and the early 1980s.
Mr Obama hopes to deliver his cut in imports by measures including raising fuel economy standards for vehicles by 4 per cent per year, and setting a new target for “advanced” second generation biofuels to be brought in by 2030.
In the longer term, the bigger impact is likely to come from the strategy to fight climate change.
Mr Obama is committed to an 80 per cent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, and has set several intermediate objectives.
He wants a national trading scheme for carbon dioxide emissions, in which companies would have to pay for all permits, unlike the European Union, where the introduction of the scheme was smoothed by giving away permits at first.
That explains why Mr Obama rightly identified his plans as bad news for coal-fired power generators.
He has also proposed targets for the proportion of the US’s electricity to be derived from renewable sources: 10 per cent by 2012 and 25 per cent by 2025.
Steve Mitnick, a partner at Oliver Wyman, an international management consulting firm, said: “I think we’re positioned for a major boom for wind and solar.”
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Trades on Solar Companies Show Optimism in Sector
By TENNILLE TRACY
NEW YORK -- Options traders rallied around solar stocks, as the price of oil climbed above $70 a barrel and voters headed to the polls for an election that could change the political landscape in Washington.
The trading in First Solar Inc. was particularly heavy, as investors picked up 31,000 calls that allow them to buy the company's stock and 23,000 puts that allow them to sell it, according to Trade Alert.
Traders appeared most interested in November calls that allow them to buy First Solar for $200. Priced at $6.90, the contracts make money if the company's shares pull above $206.90 before Nov. 21. The stock closed at $177.52, up 9.6%, Tuesday on the Nasdaq Stock Market.
Options traders gravitated toward LDK Solar Co. as well, picking up nearly five times as many calls as puts. In this case, they focused on November $25 calls, which are priced at $2.40 and make money if LDK jumps above $27.40. LDK shares closed at $23.49, up 4.8%, on the New York Stock Exchange.
Investors also showed a preference for bullish contracts in Solarfun Power Holdings Co. With trading in Solarfun heating up to five times the normal level, investors picked up 15,000 calls and 3,000 puts.
The bulk of the action in Solarfun took place in November $10 calls. Those contracts are priced at 75 cents and make money if Solarfun reaches above $10.75. The shares ended the session at $8.95, up 8.6%, on Nasdaq.
Tuesday marked the second day in a row in which traders jumped on solar stocks as the action coincided with a jump in oil prices. Oil prices rose $6.62 to settle at $70.53 a barrel after the dollar lost strength against the euro and a decision by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries to cut production started to take hold.
"Many of the stocks mentioned in this sector have already announced earnings, and yet the implied volatilities are still remaining near their highs for the year," said Brian Overby, senior options analyst with TradeKing.
Options traders also were eager to take up positions in Nasdaq stocks Evergreen Solar Inc. and Canadian Solar Inc.
In Evergreen Solar, traders scooped up three times as many calls as puts and showed interest in November $7.50 calls. Priced at 20 cents, the contracts make money if the company's stock climbs above $7.70. Evergreen closed at $5.29, up 13%.
In Canadian Solar, traders gravitated toward November $12.50 calls. Those contracts are priced at $1.65 and make money if Canadian Solar reaches above $14.15. The shares closed at $12.50, up 15%.
Write to Tennille Tracy at tennille.tracy@dowjones.com
NEW YORK -- Options traders rallied around solar stocks, as the price of oil climbed above $70 a barrel and voters headed to the polls for an election that could change the political landscape in Washington.
The trading in First Solar Inc. was particularly heavy, as investors picked up 31,000 calls that allow them to buy the company's stock and 23,000 puts that allow them to sell it, according to Trade Alert.
Traders appeared most interested in November calls that allow them to buy First Solar for $200. Priced at $6.90, the contracts make money if the company's shares pull above $206.90 before Nov. 21. The stock closed at $177.52, up 9.6%, Tuesday on the Nasdaq Stock Market.
Options traders gravitated toward LDK Solar Co. as well, picking up nearly five times as many calls as puts. In this case, they focused on November $25 calls, which are priced at $2.40 and make money if LDK jumps above $27.40. LDK shares closed at $23.49, up 4.8%, on the New York Stock Exchange.
Investors also showed a preference for bullish contracts in Solarfun Power Holdings Co. With trading in Solarfun heating up to five times the normal level, investors picked up 15,000 calls and 3,000 puts.
The bulk of the action in Solarfun took place in November $10 calls. Those contracts are priced at 75 cents and make money if Solarfun reaches above $10.75. The shares ended the session at $8.95, up 8.6%, on Nasdaq.
Tuesday marked the second day in a row in which traders jumped on solar stocks as the action coincided with a jump in oil prices. Oil prices rose $6.62 to settle at $70.53 a barrel after the dollar lost strength against the euro and a decision by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries to cut production started to take hold.
"Many of the stocks mentioned in this sector have already announced earnings, and yet the implied volatilities are still remaining near their highs for the year," said Brian Overby, senior options analyst with TradeKing.
Options traders also were eager to take up positions in Nasdaq stocks Evergreen Solar Inc. and Canadian Solar Inc.
In Evergreen Solar, traders scooped up three times as many calls as puts and showed interest in November $7.50 calls. Priced at 20 cents, the contracts make money if the company's stock climbs above $7.70. Evergreen closed at $5.29, up 13%.
In Canadian Solar, traders gravitated toward November $12.50 calls. Those contracts are priced at $1.65 and make money if Canadian Solar reaches above $14.15. The shares closed at $12.50, up 15%.
Write to Tennille Tracy at tennille.tracy@dowjones.com
Under Obama, Dark Days Seen Ahead For Fossil Fuels
By Ian Talley
Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES
WASHINGTON (Dow Jones)--Under President-elect Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., the fossil fuels industry may face "dark days ahead," while alternative energy sectors are likely to flourish.
Although it will take years to engineer and implement, an Obama administration energy and environment policy marks a tectonic shift for the nation. He would move the U.S. away from petroleum as its primary energy source and towards renewable energy, advanced biofuels, efficiency and low greenhouse-gas-emitting technologies.
Obama won the U.S. presidential race Tuesday evening, sweeping battleground states such as Ohio and Florida.
Sen. Obama's lynchpin policy is a climate change bill that would cap emissions such as carbon dioxide and auction greenhouse gas credits to encourage a fundamental transition away from high emitting industries to low-carbon alternatives. Obama said such a policy would be more aggressive than any other cap-and-trade system proposed.
As part of that policy shift, renewable energy, natural gas, plug-in hybrid vehicles, and advanced electricity transmission are forecast to receive a major boost. Sen. Obama has proposed using $150 billion from the emissions auction to fund such low-carbon alternatives over the next decade.
And to begin cutting emissions, the president-elect is targeting the fossil fuel industry.
Companies such as ExxonMobil (XOM), ConocoPhillips (COP) and Chevron Corp. (CVX) say they're concerned about returning to policies enacted in the 1970s, including Sen. Obama's proposals for a windfall profits tax and market intervention such as tapping the Strategic Petroleum Reserve.
"It's pretty clear that if we repeat those mistakes again, we're going to see some pretty dark days ahead," said outgoing American Petroleum Institute president Red Cavaney.
Obama shifted his stance on offshore oil and gas drilling in the Outer Continental Shelf under pressure from $145 a barrel oil prices and $4 a gallon gasoline. But he's largely against extensive new domestic petroleum production. Congressional Democrats could reinstate at least parts of a moratorium on such offshore drilling that expired at the end of September.
With oil prices falling to more than half levels seen in July, there will likely be less political opposition to a new ban. Some Capitol Hill watchers say the moratorium is likely to cover 50 miles off the coast and won't include revenue sharing for the states.
The oil industry says for oil companies to tap domestic production quickly it needs access closer to the shore, and sharing the wealth is necessary to get state approval for exploration off their coasts.
It's unlikely Obama will use all of his new presidential political capital to try and force a contentious greenhouse gas bill through Congress. But the president-elect is expected to start working piecemeal towards a climate change bill early in his tenure.
A federal renewable energy mandate is a central piece of his policy to ax man-made contributions to global warming. Obama wants reductions of 25% by 2025, with a 10% standard achieved early in the next decade. A similar mandate has passed in the House, though it narrowly failed in the Senate. Democrats picked up several seats in the Senate, and with that, "the RPS is almost a certainty," said Dave Hamilton, Sierra Club director of its Global Warming and Energy Program.
Southern utility companies, including Duke Energy Corp. (DUK) and Southern Co. (SO), have lobbied against a federal renewable portfolio standard, though some encourage state mandates.
Wind turbine manufacturers such as GE Energy, a unit of the General Electric Co. (GE), India's Suzlon Energy (532667.BY) and Denmark's Vestas Wind Systems (VWS.OS), as well as solar firms such as Norway's Renewable Energy Corp. ASA (REC.OS), and U.S.-headquartered First Solar Inc. (FSLR) and Evergreen Solar Inc. (ESLR) would benefit under a renewable portfolio standard.
Sen. Obama - as well as Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. - believe spurring the renewable industry would help the country recover from its current economic crisis.
The coal-fired power generation sector, one of the biggest emitters of greenhouse gases, will likely find the investment climate more difficult under stricter environmental regulations.
Longer-term, the president-elect said he plans to funnel federal money to pay for carbon capture and sequestration technology.
The coal industry, however, is concerned that Obama's pursuit of stringent greenhouse gas laws could strangle the industry. Obama has said his cap-and-trade bill would encourage carbon capture and sequestration for coal-fired power plants. Yet he admits that without such technology, new construction of traditional coal-fired power plants could face bankruptcy.
The National Mining Association, whose members include Peabody Energy Corp. (BTU) and Consol Energy (CNX), said it feared Obama's climate change policy could destroy the U.S. coal industry, "break(ing) America's energy backbone."
One of the real questions is how quickly Obama and congressional Democrats can move the country swiftly away from petroleum and coal use without damaging the economy. Obama contends a transition to a lower carbon economy will create up to 5 million jobs.
But it will also raise manufacturing, transportation, and material costs because of higher energy prices and put U.S. goods and services at a competitive disadvantage to economies that lack similar emission standards, such as China, India, Russia or the South American and Middle Eastern countries.
It's also questionable whether the president-elect could pass climate change policy early in his tenure amid a focus on rescuing the U.S. economy from a deep recession.
As the oil and coal industries may see their market share of energy production fall, the biofuels, natural gas and nuclear industries could grow.
For the biofuels market, next-generation fuels such as cellulosic and algae-based ethanol and biodiesel will benefit under Obama's energy and environment policies.
Democrats have also warmed to the natural gas industry. The fuel emits half the greenhouse gas pollution that coal producers when conventionally burned, and the U.S. has massive domestic sources that wouldn't require a major change in the sector's transportation infrastructure.
Many Democratic leaders, including Obama, are open to proposals to convert a large portion of the nation's vehicle fleet to run on natural gas.
And though Obama would try to change the current waste storage policy, a long-term expansion of the nuclear power industry is seen as essential to meet the climate change goals propounded by the President-elect.
-By Ian Talley, Dow Jones Newswires, 202-862-9285; ian.talley@dowjones.com
Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES
WASHINGTON (Dow Jones)--Under President-elect Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., the fossil fuels industry may face "dark days ahead," while alternative energy sectors are likely to flourish.
Although it will take years to engineer and implement, an Obama administration energy and environment policy marks a tectonic shift for the nation. He would move the U.S. away from petroleum as its primary energy source and towards renewable energy, advanced biofuels, efficiency and low greenhouse-gas-emitting technologies.
Obama won the U.S. presidential race Tuesday evening, sweeping battleground states such as Ohio and Florida.
Sen. Obama's lynchpin policy is a climate change bill that would cap emissions such as carbon dioxide and auction greenhouse gas credits to encourage a fundamental transition away from high emitting industries to low-carbon alternatives. Obama said such a policy would be more aggressive than any other cap-and-trade system proposed.
As part of that policy shift, renewable energy, natural gas, plug-in hybrid vehicles, and advanced electricity transmission are forecast to receive a major boost. Sen. Obama has proposed using $150 billion from the emissions auction to fund such low-carbon alternatives over the next decade.
And to begin cutting emissions, the president-elect is targeting the fossil fuel industry.
Companies such as ExxonMobil (XOM), ConocoPhillips (COP) and Chevron Corp. (CVX) say they're concerned about returning to policies enacted in the 1970s, including Sen. Obama's proposals for a windfall profits tax and market intervention such as tapping the Strategic Petroleum Reserve.
"It's pretty clear that if we repeat those mistakes again, we're going to see some pretty dark days ahead," said outgoing American Petroleum Institute president Red Cavaney.
Obama shifted his stance on offshore oil and gas drilling in the Outer Continental Shelf under pressure from $145 a barrel oil prices and $4 a gallon gasoline. But he's largely against extensive new domestic petroleum production. Congressional Democrats could reinstate at least parts of a moratorium on such offshore drilling that expired at the end of September.
With oil prices falling to more than half levels seen in July, there will likely be less political opposition to a new ban. Some Capitol Hill watchers say the moratorium is likely to cover 50 miles off the coast and won't include revenue sharing for the states.
The oil industry says for oil companies to tap domestic production quickly it needs access closer to the shore, and sharing the wealth is necessary to get state approval for exploration off their coasts.
It's unlikely Obama will use all of his new presidential political capital to try and force a contentious greenhouse gas bill through Congress. But the president-elect is expected to start working piecemeal towards a climate change bill early in his tenure.
A federal renewable energy mandate is a central piece of his policy to ax man-made contributions to global warming. Obama wants reductions of 25% by 2025, with a 10% standard achieved early in the next decade. A similar mandate has passed in the House, though it narrowly failed in the Senate. Democrats picked up several seats in the Senate, and with that, "the RPS is almost a certainty," said Dave Hamilton, Sierra Club director of its Global Warming and Energy Program.
Southern utility companies, including Duke Energy Corp. (DUK) and Southern Co. (SO), have lobbied against a federal renewable portfolio standard, though some encourage state mandates.
Wind turbine manufacturers such as GE Energy, a unit of the General Electric Co. (GE), India's Suzlon Energy (532667.BY) and Denmark's Vestas Wind Systems (VWS.OS), as well as solar firms such as Norway's Renewable Energy Corp. ASA (REC.OS), and U.S.-headquartered First Solar Inc. (FSLR) and Evergreen Solar Inc. (ESLR) would benefit under a renewable portfolio standard.
Sen. Obama - as well as Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif. - believe spurring the renewable industry would help the country recover from its current economic crisis.
The coal-fired power generation sector, one of the biggest emitters of greenhouse gases, will likely find the investment climate more difficult under stricter environmental regulations.
Longer-term, the president-elect said he plans to funnel federal money to pay for carbon capture and sequestration technology.
The coal industry, however, is concerned that Obama's pursuit of stringent greenhouse gas laws could strangle the industry. Obama has said his cap-and-trade bill would encourage carbon capture and sequestration for coal-fired power plants. Yet he admits that without such technology, new construction of traditional coal-fired power plants could face bankruptcy.
The National Mining Association, whose members include Peabody Energy Corp. (BTU) and Consol Energy (CNX), said it feared Obama's climate change policy could destroy the U.S. coal industry, "break(ing) America's energy backbone."
One of the real questions is how quickly Obama and congressional Democrats can move the country swiftly away from petroleum and coal use without damaging the economy. Obama contends a transition to a lower carbon economy will create up to 5 million jobs.
But it will also raise manufacturing, transportation, and material costs because of higher energy prices and put U.S. goods and services at a competitive disadvantage to economies that lack similar emission standards, such as China, India, Russia or the South American and Middle Eastern countries.
It's also questionable whether the president-elect could pass climate change policy early in his tenure amid a focus on rescuing the U.S. economy from a deep recession.
As the oil and coal industries may see their market share of energy production fall, the biofuels, natural gas and nuclear industries could grow.
For the biofuels market, next-generation fuels such as cellulosic and algae-based ethanol and biodiesel will benefit under Obama's energy and environment policies.
Democrats have also warmed to the natural gas industry. The fuel emits half the greenhouse gas pollution that coal producers when conventionally burned, and the U.S. has massive domestic sources that wouldn't require a major change in the sector's transportation infrastructure.
Many Democratic leaders, including Obama, are open to proposals to convert a large portion of the nation's vehicle fleet to run on natural gas.
And though Obama would try to change the current waste storage policy, a long-term expansion of the nuclear power industry is seen as essential to meet the climate change goals propounded by the President-elect.
-By Ian Talley, Dow Jones Newswires, 202-862-9285; ian.talley@dowjones.com
Wednesday, 5 November 2008
Greenpeace calls off Japanese anti-whaling mission
Campaigners focus resources on defending activists accused of stealing whale meat instead of following Antarctic boats
Justin McCurry in Tokyo
guardian.co.uk,
Tuesday November 04 2008 12.26 GMT
Greenpeace said today it had decided not to harass Japanese whalers in the Antarctic this year so it can focus on clearing two activists being held for allegedly stealing whale meat it says was bound for the black market.
The group said it would plough its resources into building an anti-whaling coalition in Japan and defending Junichi Sato and Toru Suzuki against the theft charges. If convicted, they could be sent to prison for 10 years.
"Our actions have taken the plight of the whales to the top of the political agenda," Jun Hoshikawa, Greenpeace Japan's executive director, said in a statement. "But if we are to bring this hunt to an end, we have to bring change in Tokyo."
Greenpeace denied it had bowed to pressure from the Japanese authorities. "The key country we need to influence is Japan, and we want to do that inside Japan," Greenpeace spokesman Dave Walsh told the Guardian. "We do have an international impact, but there's not a lot of point in preaching to the converted.
"We have saved whales every year we've been in the Antarctic, but we want to end whaling for good and we can't do that if all our resources and energy are focused on the Southern Ocean."
However, the whaling fleet, which is due to leave for the Southern Ocean later this month, will not be able to carry out its cull unhampered.
Sea Shepherd, a marine conservation group that advocates direct action, has vowed to disrupt the fleet's attempts to slaughter whales as part of Japan's controversial scientific whaling programme.
"We intend to be more aggressive and even more relentless," Peter Hammarstedt, a Sea Shepherd activist, said in a statement. "We intend to make sure no whales are caught on our watch."
Last year Japan's whalers had planned to catch 850 minke whales but returned this spring with 551 after being frustrated by Greenpeace and Sea Shepherd activists.
Although commercial whaling was banned in 1986, Japan is permitted to catch whales for "lethal research" into the mammals' migratory and other habits in anticipation of a return to sustainable commercial culls.
Sato and Suzuki were arrested in June after intercepting 23kg of whale meat they claimed had been pilfered by crew from the factory ship the Nisshin Maru and sold on Japan's lucrative black market. They will go on trial early next year.
"Junichi and Toru's trial is politically motivated," said Sara Holden, Greenpeace's whale campaign coordinator. "If the Japanese government wants to make political prisoners out of people who oppose whaling, then they are going to have to take a lot more prisoners."
The group said 250,000 people had emailed the Japanese prime minister, Taro Aso, demanding that the charges be dropped.
Justin McCurry in Tokyo
guardian.co.uk,
Tuesday November 04 2008 12.26 GMT
Greenpeace said today it had decided not to harass Japanese whalers in the Antarctic this year so it can focus on clearing two activists being held for allegedly stealing whale meat it says was bound for the black market.
The group said it would plough its resources into building an anti-whaling coalition in Japan and defending Junichi Sato and Toru Suzuki against the theft charges. If convicted, they could be sent to prison for 10 years.
"Our actions have taken the plight of the whales to the top of the political agenda," Jun Hoshikawa, Greenpeace Japan's executive director, said in a statement. "But if we are to bring this hunt to an end, we have to bring change in Tokyo."
Greenpeace denied it had bowed to pressure from the Japanese authorities. "The key country we need to influence is Japan, and we want to do that inside Japan," Greenpeace spokesman Dave Walsh told the Guardian. "We do have an international impact, but there's not a lot of point in preaching to the converted.
"We have saved whales every year we've been in the Antarctic, but we want to end whaling for good and we can't do that if all our resources and energy are focused on the Southern Ocean."
However, the whaling fleet, which is due to leave for the Southern Ocean later this month, will not be able to carry out its cull unhampered.
Sea Shepherd, a marine conservation group that advocates direct action, has vowed to disrupt the fleet's attempts to slaughter whales as part of Japan's controversial scientific whaling programme.
"We intend to be more aggressive and even more relentless," Peter Hammarstedt, a Sea Shepherd activist, said in a statement. "We intend to make sure no whales are caught on our watch."
Last year Japan's whalers had planned to catch 850 minke whales but returned this spring with 551 after being frustrated by Greenpeace and Sea Shepherd activists.
Although commercial whaling was banned in 1986, Japan is permitted to catch whales for "lethal research" into the mammals' migratory and other habits in anticipation of a return to sustainable commercial culls.
Sato and Suzuki were arrested in June after intercepting 23kg of whale meat they claimed had been pilfered by crew from the factory ship the Nisshin Maru and sold on Japan's lucrative black market. They will go on trial early next year.
"Junichi and Toru's trial is politically motivated," said Sara Holden, Greenpeace's whale campaign coordinator. "If the Japanese government wants to make political prisoners out of people who oppose whaling, then they are going to have to take a lot more prisoners."
The group said 250,000 people had emailed the Japanese prime minister, Taro Aso, demanding that the charges be dropped.
Ozone hole over Antarctica grows again
Stratospheric levels of harmful CFCs will take between 40 and 100 years to dissipate and have only dropped a few per cent since reaching a peak in 2000, scientists warn
John Vidal
guardian.co.uk,
Tuesday November 04 2008 11.20 GMT
The ozone hole over Antarctica grew to the size of North America this year – the fifth largest on record – according to the latest satellite observations.
US government scientists from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) say this year's ozone hole reached its maximum level on September 12, extending to 10.5m sq miles and four miles deep. That is bigger than 2007 but smaller than 2006, when the hole covered over 11.4m sq miles.
Scientists blamed colder-than-average temperatures in the stratosphere for the ozone hole's unusually large size this year. "Weather is the most important factor in the fluctuation of the size of the ozone hole from year to year," said Bryan Johnson, a scientist at NOAA's Earth System Research Laboratory in Boulder, which monitors ozone, ozone-depleting chemicals, and greenhouse gases around the globe. "How cold the stratosphere is and what the winds do determine how powerfully the chemicals can perform their dirty work."
The main cause of the ozone hole is human-produced compounds called chlorofluorocarbons, or CFCs, which release ozone-destroying chlorine and bromine into the atmosphere. The Earth's protective ozone layer acts like a giant parasol, blocking the sun's ultraviolet-B rays. Though banned for the past 21 years to reduce their harmful build up, CFCs still take many decades to dissipate from the atmosphere
The 1987 Montreal Protocol and other regulations banning CFCs reversed the build-up of chlorine and bromine, first noticed in the 1980s.
"These chemicals – and signs of their reduction – take several years to rise from the lower atmosphere into the stratosphere and then migrate to the poles," said NOAA's Craig Long, a research meteorologist at NOAA's National Centers for Environmental Prediction. "The chemicals also typically last 40 to 100 years in the atmosphere. For these reasons, stratospheric CFC levels have dropped only a few per cent below their peak in the early 2000s."
"The decline of these harmful substances to their pre–ozone hole levels in the Antarctic stratosphere will take decades," said NOAA atmospheric chemist Stephen Montzka of the Earth System Research Laboratory. "We don't expect a full recovery of Antarctic ozone until the second half of the century."
Starting in May, as Antarctica moves into a period of 24-hour-a-day darkness, winds create a vortex of cold, stable air centred near the South Pole that isolates CFCs over the continent. When spring sunshine returns in August, the sun's ultraviolet light sets off a series of chemical reactions inside the vortex that consume the ozone. The colder and more isolated the air inside the vortex, the more destructive the chemistry. By late December the southern summer is in full swing, the vortex has crumbled, and the ozone has returned – until the process begins anew the following winter.
John Vidal
guardian.co.uk,
Tuesday November 04 2008 11.20 GMT
The ozone hole over Antarctica grew to the size of North America this year – the fifth largest on record – according to the latest satellite observations.
US government scientists from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) say this year's ozone hole reached its maximum level on September 12, extending to 10.5m sq miles and four miles deep. That is bigger than 2007 but smaller than 2006, when the hole covered over 11.4m sq miles.
Scientists blamed colder-than-average temperatures in the stratosphere for the ozone hole's unusually large size this year. "Weather is the most important factor in the fluctuation of the size of the ozone hole from year to year," said Bryan Johnson, a scientist at NOAA's Earth System Research Laboratory in Boulder, which monitors ozone, ozone-depleting chemicals, and greenhouse gases around the globe. "How cold the stratosphere is and what the winds do determine how powerfully the chemicals can perform their dirty work."
The main cause of the ozone hole is human-produced compounds called chlorofluorocarbons, or CFCs, which release ozone-destroying chlorine and bromine into the atmosphere. The Earth's protective ozone layer acts like a giant parasol, blocking the sun's ultraviolet-B rays. Though banned for the past 21 years to reduce their harmful build up, CFCs still take many decades to dissipate from the atmosphere
The 1987 Montreal Protocol and other regulations banning CFCs reversed the build-up of chlorine and bromine, first noticed in the 1980s.
"These chemicals – and signs of their reduction – take several years to rise from the lower atmosphere into the stratosphere and then migrate to the poles," said NOAA's Craig Long, a research meteorologist at NOAA's National Centers for Environmental Prediction. "The chemicals also typically last 40 to 100 years in the atmosphere. For these reasons, stratospheric CFC levels have dropped only a few per cent below their peak in the early 2000s."
"The decline of these harmful substances to their pre–ozone hole levels in the Antarctic stratosphere will take decades," said NOAA atmospheric chemist Stephen Montzka of the Earth System Research Laboratory. "We don't expect a full recovery of Antarctic ozone until the second half of the century."
Starting in May, as Antarctica moves into a period of 24-hour-a-day darkness, winds create a vortex of cold, stable air centred near the South Pole that isolates CFCs over the continent. When spring sunshine returns in August, the sun's ultraviolet light sets off a series of chemical reactions inside the vortex that consume the ozone. The colder and more isolated the air inside the vortex, the more destructive the chemistry. By late December the southern summer is in full swing, the vortex has crumbled, and the ozone has returned – until the process begins anew the following winter.
Eco-town plan in disarray as sites fail to meet targets
Jill Sherman, Whitehall Editor
Gordon Brown’s eco-town programme was in disarray last night with only one of 12 shortlisted sites meeting the Government’s criteria.
Rural campaigners and opposition parties demanded a halt to the scheme, which has enraged residents across the country. The policy has been beset with difficulties in the past year as developers and councils have pulled out of the zero-carbon schemes, which are expensive to build and depend on huge infrastructure support.
Three projects have already been withdrawn, and Margaret Beckett, the Housing Minister, has now vetoed another in Leeds, suggesting that it should be a pilot for an urban eco-community instead. Only three of the 12 have local council backing and the Local Government Association is threatening legal action over the failure to follow planning procedures.
But Mrs Beckett confounded critics and angered town halls by pressing ahead with the scheme yesterday and adding two more sites – in Oxford and Norwich. Rackheath, near Norwich, has been propelled to the top of the shortlist as the only site with a grade A for its suitability for an eco-town site. The other, at northwest Bicester, Oxfordshire, has been put forward as an alternative to Weston Otmoor, Oxfordshire (given the lowest grade C) after a protest campaign by Tony Henman, Tim Henman’s father.
The remaining ten proposed towns were given B ratings, suggesting that they could be suitable locations “subject to planning and design objectives”. They include many of the schemes that have been strongly opposed, such as Ford, West Sussex; Middle Quinton, Warwickshire; and Pennbury, Leicestershire.
The Conservatives claimed yesterday that Mrs Beckett had moved the goalposts for building eco-towns and altered the list in an attempt to keep the project alive. She has also delayed any announcement of the final shortlist until March or April by announcing a second consultation to cover the 12 schemes outlined yesterday.
Gordon Brown’s eco-town programme was in disarray last night with only one of 12 shortlisted sites meeting the Government’s criteria.
Rural campaigners and opposition parties demanded a halt to the scheme, which has enraged residents across the country. The policy has been beset with difficulties in the past year as developers and councils have pulled out of the zero-carbon schemes, which are expensive to build and depend on huge infrastructure support.
Three projects have already been withdrawn, and Margaret Beckett, the Housing Minister, has now vetoed another in Leeds, suggesting that it should be a pilot for an urban eco-community instead. Only three of the 12 have local council backing and the Local Government Association is threatening legal action over the failure to follow planning procedures.
But Mrs Beckett confounded critics and angered town halls by pressing ahead with the scheme yesterday and adding two more sites – in Oxford and Norwich. Rackheath, near Norwich, has been propelled to the top of the shortlist as the only site with a grade A for its suitability for an eco-town site. The other, at northwest Bicester, Oxfordshire, has been put forward as an alternative to Weston Otmoor, Oxfordshire (given the lowest grade C) after a protest campaign by Tony Henman, Tim Henman’s father.
The remaining ten proposed towns were given B ratings, suggesting that they could be suitable locations “subject to planning and design objectives”. They include many of the schemes that have been strongly opposed, such as Ford, West Sussex; Middle Quinton, Warwickshire; and Pennbury, Leicestershire.
The Conservatives claimed yesterday that Mrs Beckett had moved the goalposts for building eco-towns and altered the list in an attempt to keep the project alive. She has also delayed any announcement of the final shortlist until March or April by announcing a second consultation to cover the 12 schemes outlined yesterday.
Policy leap vital for any serious cut in carbon emissions
From The Times
November 5, 2008
Carl Mortished: World business briefing
While you were distracted by crashing banks and clashing senators, you may have missed a small environmental earthquake. The price of carbon has collapsed.
In only three months, life has become a lot cheaper for polluters; the financial cost of warming the planet has plummeted in Europe’s emissions trading system (ETS) and the effectiveness of such a volatile market mechanism in curbing carbon is being questioned.
You may recall that the ETS is a mechanism to encourage businesses to reduce their carbon output. Europe’s larger companies are allocated permits to emit CO2 , and these allowances, called EUAs, can be traded on exchanges. Companies that emit less CO2 than their allocation can sell EUAs for cash, but inefficient polluters must buy EUAs or face bigger financial penalties.
The idea is that a shortfall in EUAs allocated by government will cause the carbon price to rise, stimulating investment in carbon reduction. It’s a market solution to pollution, but this carbon market is showing a distressing tendency to behave like most financial markets - hysterically. In July, the right to spew out one tonne of CO2 from a chimney would have cost a power generator €29.33, but yesterday it could be bought for only €18.25.
The sudden collapse of the carbon price mirrors the rout in the wider commodity markets. Carbon peaked in July, its price summit occurring within ten days of the peak in the crude oil price. Since then, everything from steel to potash has been tumbling and you might think it unsurprising that carbon has tracked the general retreat. Hedge funds and other financial investors dabbled in EUAs, as they fiddled with palm oil and soya. The rush to convert hedge fund investments into cash and US Treasury bills has resulted in rapid closure of positions on various carbon exchanges.
Obviously, the credit crunch has little to do with underlying demand for EUAs in a market artificially created by regulators in Brussels. However, economic downturn and recession will have an impact on the carbon market. Less industrial and transport activity implies fewer emissions, and so the shortfall between actual emissions and allowances will shrink, reducing demand for EUAs, thereby causing the carbon price to fall.
Some analysts reckon that the carbon price has fallen far enough, even allowing for a recession.
IDEAcarbon, a rating agency, has halved its estimate of the allocation shortfall from 206 million tonnes of carbon to 98 million tonnes in 2008 and 83 million tonnes in 2009. The point is that there will still be a shortfall. Société Générale reckons that EUAs will find a floor at €15 per tonne before rebounding next year into the low €20s per tonne.
Maybe so, but the ETS is making a mockery of Europe’s stumbling attempts to lead the world in a market-based carbon strategy. It is causing irritation and frustration to the armies of advisers and investors who seek to cajole utilities into big investments in carbon reduction. James Cameron, the director of Climate Change Capital, a financial adviser and fund manager, said: “The whole purpose [of the ETS] is to take carbon out. It’s not there to benefit funds or to support trading.”
It’s those “speculators” again, the ones that pushed the oil price up the hill to $147 a barrel and then let it roll back to $60. It is a terrible irony that one aim of creating a carbon market was to provide a measure of certainty to the energy industry in estimating the future price of carbon for the purpose of planning investments in new power generators. Estimates of the carbon price at which carbon capture and storage technology might be economically viable vary between €40 and €60 per tonne. Suffice it to say we are nowhere near these levels.
More political action is needed, Mr Cameron says, with smaller carbon allocations by governments to industry, which would entail a much bigger shortfall in EUAs and a much higher carbon price. It is a moot point, however, whether there is political appetite in Europe for such a burden. The European Commission is already struggling to create a coalition of the willing to do battle with carbon emissions, and Silvio Berlusconi, the Italian Prime Minister, has made clear his preference for a gentle regime.
It’s a measure of the speed at which politics moves in response to market prices that the green agenda has almost vanished from media political chatter. Carbon’s falling price spells companies going bust, the loss of jobs and the shredding of political reputations. Over the next year, no politician with reelection hopes will back a policy that would triple the price of carbon for industry and raise consumers’ energy costs. But there is a wider question about the ETS that must be addressed and that is whether it is a sensible mechanism to regulate carbon.
Price volatility, whether in oil, gas or coal, is a huge burden for the energy industry. Violent movements in price cause financial damage and promote short-termism, the sort of thinking that is anathema to the climate change lobby.
If there is to be any prospect of a serious cut in carbon, there must be stability in carbon pricing. Although a financial market gives useful price signals, it cannot provide stability.
Only a stable regulatory regime can provide certainty, but that means carbon taxes and a policy leap that no one is yet willing to make.
November 5, 2008
Carl Mortished: World business briefing
While you were distracted by crashing banks and clashing senators, you may have missed a small environmental earthquake. The price of carbon has collapsed.
In only three months, life has become a lot cheaper for polluters; the financial cost of warming the planet has plummeted in Europe’s emissions trading system (ETS) and the effectiveness of such a volatile market mechanism in curbing carbon is being questioned.
You may recall that the ETS is a mechanism to encourage businesses to reduce their carbon output. Europe’s larger companies are allocated permits to emit CO2 , and these allowances, called EUAs, can be traded on exchanges. Companies that emit less CO2 than their allocation can sell EUAs for cash, but inefficient polluters must buy EUAs or face bigger financial penalties.
The idea is that a shortfall in EUAs allocated by government will cause the carbon price to rise, stimulating investment in carbon reduction. It’s a market solution to pollution, but this carbon market is showing a distressing tendency to behave like most financial markets - hysterically. In July, the right to spew out one tonne of CO2 from a chimney would have cost a power generator €29.33, but yesterday it could be bought for only €18.25.
The sudden collapse of the carbon price mirrors the rout in the wider commodity markets. Carbon peaked in July, its price summit occurring within ten days of the peak in the crude oil price. Since then, everything from steel to potash has been tumbling and you might think it unsurprising that carbon has tracked the general retreat. Hedge funds and other financial investors dabbled in EUAs, as they fiddled with palm oil and soya. The rush to convert hedge fund investments into cash and US Treasury bills has resulted in rapid closure of positions on various carbon exchanges.
Obviously, the credit crunch has little to do with underlying demand for EUAs in a market artificially created by regulators in Brussels. However, economic downturn and recession will have an impact on the carbon market. Less industrial and transport activity implies fewer emissions, and so the shortfall between actual emissions and allowances will shrink, reducing demand for EUAs, thereby causing the carbon price to fall.
Some analysts reckon that the carbon price has fallen far enough, even allowing for a recession.
IDEAcarbon, a rating agency, has halved its estimate of the allocation shortfall from 206 million tonnes of carbon to 98 million tonnes in 2008 and 83 million tonnes in 2009. The point is that there will still be a shortfall. Société Générale reckons that EUAs will find a floor at €15 per tonne before rebounding next year into the low €20s per tonne.
Maybe so, but the ETS is making a mockery of Europe’s stumbling attempts to lead the world in a market-based carbon strategy. It is causing irritation and frustration to the armies of advisers and investors who seek to cajole utilities into big investments in carbon reduction. James Cameron, the director of Climate Change Capital, a financial adviser and fund manager, said: “The whole purpose [of the ETS] is to take carbon out. It’s not there to benefit funds or to support trading.”
It’s those “speculators” again, the ones that pushed the oil price up the hill to $147 a barrel and then let it roll back to $60. It is a terrible irony that one aim of creating a carbon market was to provide a measure of certainty to the energy industry in estimating the future price of carbon for the purpose of planning investments in new power generators. Estimates of the carbon price at which carbon capture and storage technology might be economically viable vary between €40 and €60 per tonne. Suffice it to say we are nowhere near these levels.
More political action is needed, Mr Cameron says, with smaller carbon allocations by governments to industry, which would entail a much bigger shortfall in EUAs and a much higher carbon price. It is a moot point, however, whether there is political appetite in Europe for such a burden. The European Commission is already struggling to create a coalition of the willing to do battle with carbon emissions, and Silvio Berlusconi, the Italian Prime Minister, has made clear his preference for a gentle regime.
It’s a measure of the speed at which politics moves in response to market prices that the green agenda has almost vanished from media political chatter. Carbon’s falling price spells companies going bust, the loss of jobs and the shredding of political reputations. Over the next year, no politician with reelection hopes will back a policy that would triple the price of carbon for industry and raise consumers’ energy costs. But there is a wider question about the ETS that must be addressed and that is whether it is a sensible mechanism to regulate carbon.
Price volatility, whether in oil, gas or coal, is a huge burden for the energy industry. Violent movements in price cause financial damage and promote short-termism, the sort of thinking that is anathema to the climate change lobby.
If there is to be any prospect of a serious cut in carbon, there must be stability in carbon pricing. Although a financial market gives useful price signals, it cannot provide stability.
Only a stable regulatory regime can provide certainty, but that means carbon taxes and a policy leap that no one is yet willing to make.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
