By Margareta Pagano, Business EditorSunday, 9 November 2008
A growing number of people are warming to nuclear power and more people now favour it rather than oppose it, according to a new YouGov survey for EDF Energy, the French nuclear power operator.
The survey, to be published tomorrow, shows that 53 per cent of the 4,449 people who took part in the online poll are now in favour of nuclear power stations to replace old ones. This compares with 46 per cent last year, and 41 per cent the previous year. At the same time 62 per cent agree that nuclear is needed as part of a balanced energy source for the UK compared with 59 per cent last year, and 54 per cent in 2006.
Vincent de Rivaz, chief executive of EDF Energy, said: "This latest poll shows increasing support for nuclear power to be part of the solution to meet the looming energy gap in the UK. Alongside energy efficiency, EDF Energy believes that nuclear and renewables have a key role to play, alongside clean coal and gas generation. The survey shows that the public has a strong understanding of the nature and scale of the energy challenge facing the UK."
However, according to the survey, people remain worried about the safety issues surrounding nuclear with 76 per cent expressing fears about safety, albeit down from 79 per cent last year. The study found 81 per cent cite disposing of waste as a cause for concern.
Sunday, 9 November 2008
Mini nuclear plants to power 20,000 homes
£13m shed-size reactors will be delivered by lorry
John Vidal and Nick Rosen
guardian.co.uk, Sunday November 9 2008 00.01 GMT
The Observer, Sunday November 9 2008
Nuclear power plants smaller than a garden shed and able to power 20,000 homes will be on sale within five years, say scientists at Los Alamos, the US government laboratory which developed the first atomic bomb.
The miniature reactors will be factory-sealed, contain no weapons-grade material, have no moving parts and will be nearly impossible to steal because they will be encased in concrete and buried underground.
The US government has licensed the technology to Hyperion, a New Mexico-based company which said last week that it has taken its first firm orders and plans to start mass production within five years. 'Our goal is to generate electricity for 10 cents a watt anywhere in the world,' said John Deal, chief executive of Hyperion. 'They will cost approximately $25m [£13m] each. For a community with 10,000 households, that is a very affordable $250 per home.'
Deal claims to have more than 100 firm orders, largely from the oil and electricity industries, but says the company is also targeting developing countries and isolated communities. 'It's leapfrog technology,' he said.
The company plans to set up three factories to produce 4,000 plants between 2013 and 2023. 'We already have a pipeline for 100 reactors, and we are taking our time to tool up to mass-produce this reactor.'
The first confirmed order came from TES, a Czech infrastructure company specialising in water plants and power plants. 'They ordered six units and optioned a further 12. We are very sure of their capability to purchase,' said Deal. The first one, he said, would be installed in Romania. 'We now have a six-year waiting list. We are in talks with developers in the Cayman Islands, Panama and the Bahamas.'
The reactors, only a few metres in diameter, will be delivered on the back of a lorry to be buried underground. They must be refuelled every 7 to 10 years. Because the reactor is based on a 50-year-old design that has proved safe for students to use, few countries are expected to object to plants on their territory. An application to build the plants will be submitted to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission next year.
'You could never have a Chernobyl-type event - there are no moving parts,' said Deal. 'You would need nation-state resources in order to enrich our uranium. Temperature-wise it's too hot to handle. It would be like stealing a barbecue with your bare hands.'
Other companies are known to be designing micro-reactors. Toshiba has been testing 200KW reactors measuring roughly six metres by two metres. Designed to fuel smaller numbers of homes for longer, they could power a single building for up to 40 years.
John Vidal and Nick Rosen
guardian.co.uk, Sunday November 9 2008 00.01 GMT
The Observer, Sunday November 9 2008
Nuclear power plants smaller than a garden shed and able to power 20,000 homes will be on sale within five years, say scientists at Los Alamos, the US government laboratory which developed the first atomic bomb.
The miniature reactors will be factory-sealed, contain no weapons-grade material, have no moving parts and will be nearly impossible to steal because they will be encased in concrete and buried underground.
The US government has licensed the technology to Hyperion, a New Mexico-based company which said last week that it has taken its first firm orders and plans to start mass production within five years. 'Our goal is to generate electricity for 10 cents a watt anywhere in the world,' said John Deal, chief executive of Hyperion. 'They will cost approximately $25m [£13m] each. For a community with 10,000 households, that is a very affordable $250 per home.'
Deal claims to have more than 100 firm orders, largely from the oil and electricity industries, but says the company is also targeting developing countries and isolated communities. 'It's leapfrog technology,' he said.
The company plans to set up three factories to produce 4,000 plants between 2013 and 2023. 'We already have a pipeline for 100 reactors, and we are taking our time to tool up to mass-produce this reactor.'
The first confirmed order came from TES, a Czech infrastructure company specialising in water plants and power plants. 'They ordered six units and optioned a further 12. We are very sure of their capability to purchase,' said Deal. The first one, he said, would be installed in Romania. 'We now have a six-year waiting list. We are in talks with developers in the Cayman Islands, Panama and the Bahamas.'
The reactors, only a few metres in diameter, will be delivered on the back of a lorry to be buried underground. They must be refuelled every 7 to 10 years. Because the reactor is based on a 50-year-old design that has proved safe for students to use, few countries are expected to object to plants on their territory. An application to build the plants will be submitted to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission next year.
'You could never have a Chernobyl-type event - there are no moving parts,' said Deal. 'You would need nation-state resources in order to enrich our uranium. Temperature-wise it's too hot to handle. It would be like stealing a barbecue with your bare hands.'
Other companies are known to be designing micro-reactors. Toshiba has been testing 200KW reactors measuring roughly six metres by two metres. Designed to fuel smaller numbers of homes for longer, they could power a single building for up to 40 years.
SSE tipped to unveil slump in profits after delay in passing on price rises
Published Date: 09 November 2008
By William Lyons
IAN Marchant, chief executive of Scottish & Southern Energy (SSE), is expected this week to reveal a dramatic fall in profits despite hiking retail gas prices by nearly 30% in the summer.
In August the UK's second biggest supplier was one of the first of the UK's 'big six' suppliers to raise prices, increasing gas charges by 29.2% and average electricity costs by 19.2%.But Marchant is expected to tell investors on Wednesday that profits in the six months to September 30 will be "substantially lower" than previous years, as the firm absorbed the cost of higher wholesale gas prices for months before passing them on to customers. He will look to reassure investors by saying the majority of its profits will be made between October and March as the impact of price hikes comes through.SSE has also suffered delays with the installation of new gas de-sulphurisation equipment at Fiddler's Ferry and Ferrybridge, which limited the stations' output in the first half of the year. These factors are set to knock the company's pre-tax profits back by more than half to £293m from £665m."Generation and supply profitability needs to be significantly higher in the second half in order to meet full-year expectations. "Most of the ground should be made up by the average 24% increase in retail tariffs effective at the end of August, however, which should restore supply margins," said Merrill Lynch's energy analyst Fraser McLaren.In June Scotland on Sunday revealed that SSE was stepping up its investment in wind farm technology by opening a research and development office in Beijing. The office focuses on procurement of technology from Chinese companies to be used in the UK and the development of wind farms in Asia.Meanwhile, SSE has warned that a swathe of problems in developing wind farms threatens to blow the Government's renewable energy targets off course. SSE, which is involved in developing the £1.3bn 504-megawatt Greater Gabbard farm in the North Sea off the coast of East Anglia, said Britain would need about four schemes the size of Gabbard per year if it is to achieve the 2020 target."We've made significant progress with a number of key projects in the last six months, but there's still much more to do to hit the 2020 target," an SSE spokesman said.
By William Lyons
IAN Marchant, chief executive of Scottish & Southern Energy (SSE), is expected this week to reveal a dramatic fall in profits despite hiking retail gas prices by nearly 30% in the summer.
In August the UK's second biggest supplier was one of the first of the UK's 'big six' suppliers to raise prices, increasing gas charges by 29.2% and average electricity costs by 19.2%.But Marchant is expected to tell investors on Wednesday that profits in the six months to September 30 will be "substantially lower" than previous years, as the firm absorbed the cost of higher wholesale gas prices for months before passing them on to customers. He will look to reassure investors by saying the majority of its profits will be made between October and March as the impact of price hikes comes through.SSE has also suffered delays with the installation of new gas de-sulphurisation equipment at Fiddler's Ferry and Ferrybridge, which limited the stations' output in the first half of the year. These factors are set to knock the company's pre-tax profits back by more than half to £293m from £665m."Generation and supply profitability needs to be significantly higher in the second half in order to meet full-year expectations. "Most of the ground should be made up by the average 24% increase in retail tariffs effective at the end of August, however, which should restore supply margins," said Merrill Lynch's energy analyst Fraser McLaren.In June Scotland on Sunday revealed that SSE was stepping up its investment in wind farm technology by opening a research and development office in Beijing. The office focuses on procurement of technology from Chinese companies to be used in the UK and the development of wind farms in Asia.Meanwhile, SSE has warned that a swathe of problems in developing wind farms threatens to blow the Government's renewable energy targets off course. SSE, which is involved in developing the £1.3bn 504-megawatt Greater Gabbard farm in the North Sea off the coast of East Anglia, said Britain would need about four schemes the size of Gabbard per year if it is to achieve the 2020 target."We've made significant progress with a number of key projects in the last six months, but there's still much more to do to hit the 2020 target," an SSE spokesman said.
Saturday, 8 November 2008
Blow to Brown as BP scraps British renewables plan to focus on US
• Better rate of return across the Atlantic, says oil firm • Company to pull out of projects in India and China
Terry Macalister
guardian.co.uk, Friday November 7 2008 00.01 GMT
The Guardian, Friday November 7 2008
BP has dropped all plans to build wind farms and other renewable schemes in Britain and is instead concentrating the bulk of its $8bn (£5bn) renewables spending programme on the US, where government incentives for clean energy projects can provide a convenient tax shelter for oil and gas revenues.
The decision is a major blow to the prime minister, Gordon Brown, who has promised to sweep away all impediments to ensure Britain is at the forefront of the green energy revolution. BP and Shell - which has also pulled out of renewables in Britain - are heavily influential among investors.
BP has advertised its green credentials widely in the UK and has a representative on the ruling board of the British Wind Energy Association (BWEA). But it said difficulty in getting planning permission and lower economies of scale made the UK wind sector far less attractive than that of the US.
"The best place to get a strong rate of return for wind is the US," said a BP spokesman, who confirmed the group had shelved ideas of building an onshore wind farm at the Isle of Grain, in Kent, and would not bid for any offshore licences.
BP has enormous financial firepower as a result of recent very high crude oil prices. Its move away from wind power in Britain follows a decision by Shell to sell off its stake in the London Array project off Kent, potentially the world's largest offshore wind farm.
Shell gave the same reasons as BP for that move, saying the economics of UK wind were poor compared to those onshore across the Atlantic, where incoming president Barack Obama has promised to spend $150bn over 10 years to kick start a renewable energy revolution .
BP said about $1.5bn would be spent next year on US wind projects and the company expected to spend the $8bn up to the year 2015.
BP is still proceeding with some limited solar, biofuels and other schemes, but the vast majority of its time and energy is now being concentrated on wind. By the end of 2008, BP expects to have one gigawatt of US wind power installed and plans to have trebled this by 2010.
The BWEA shrugged off BP's decision. "The offshore wind market is evolving and getting stronger. Different investors will come and go at different stages of the development cycle. But whoever the players are, we know that the offshore industry will be generating massive amounts of electricity for the UK market in the next few years," said a spokesman.
Britain is not the only country to miss out on BP's largesse. The company said yesterday it was also pulling out of China, India and Turkey, where it had also been looking at projects.
BP had formed a joint venture with Beijing Tianrun New Energy Investment Company, a subsidiary of Goldwind, China's largest turbine maker. The two companies had signed a deal in January under which they planned 148.4MW of wind capacity in Inner Mongolia, China's main wind power region. BP had also started building two wind farms in India and was considering schemes in Turkey. It is now expecting to sell off the Indian facilities and halt work in Turkey.
Green campaigners have been highly sceptical about BP's plans to go "beyond petroleum" and feared that the company's new chief executive, Tony Hayward, would drop this commitment, started under his predecessor, John Browne.
The company has always insisted it remained keen to look at green energy solutions and has been investing in biofuels operations in Brazil. BP is also in the middle of a major marketing campaign, with huge posters on the London Underground boasting of its moves to diversify into wind and other energy sources.
The Carbon Trust, a government-funded organisation established to help Britain move from carbon to clean energy, recently published a major report warning ministers that the costs of building wind farms offshore was too high. There was speculation that BP was a major influence on that study, which proposed that turbines should be allowed to be placed much nearer to the shore.
The Crown Estate, which has responsibility for UK inshore waters, is still confident that a long-awaited third offshore wind licensing round in the North Sea will attract a record number of bidders. It has already registered 96 companies, although it has not released names and BP and Shell will clearly be absent.
Terry Macalister
guardian.co.uk, Friday November 7 2008 00.01 GMT
The Guardian, Friday November 7 2008
BP has dropped all plans to build wind farms and other renewable schemes in Britain and is instead concentrating the bulk of its $8bn (£5bn) renewables spending programme on the US, where government incentives for clean energy projects can provide a convenient tax shelter for oil and gas revenues.
The decision is a major blow to the prime minister, Gordon Brown, who has promised to sweep away all impediments to ensure Britain is at the forefront of the green energy revolution. BP and Shell - which has also pulled out of renewables in Britain - are heavily influential among investors.
BP has advertised its green credentials widely in the UK and has a representative on the ruling board of the British Wind Energy Association (BWEA). But it said difficulty in getting planning permission and lower economies of scale made the UK wind sector far less attractive than that of the US.
"The best place to get a strong rate of return for wind is the US," said a BP spokesman, who confirmed the group had shelved ideas of building an onshore wind farm at the Isle of Grain, in Kent, and would not bid for any offshore licences.
BP has enormous financial firepower as a result of recent very high crude oil prices. Its move away from wind power in Britain follows a decision by Shell to sell off its stake in the London Array project off Kent, potentially the world's largest offshore wind farm.
Shell gave the same reasons as BP for that move, saying the economics of UK wind were poor compared to those onshore across the Atlantic, where incoming president Barack Obama has promised to spend $150bn over 10 years to kick start a renewable energy revolution .
BP said about $1.5bn would be spent next year on US wind projects and the company expected to spend the $8bn up to the year 2015.
BP is still proceeding with some limited solar, biofuels and other schemes, but the vast majority of its time and energy is now being concentrated on wind. By the end of 2008, BP expects to have one gigawatt of US wind power installed and plans to have trebled this by 2010.
The BWEA shrugged off BP's decision. "The offshore wind market is evolving and getting stronger. Different investors will come and go at different stages of the development cycle. But whoever the players are, we know that the offshore industry will be generating massive amounts of electricity for the UK market in the next few years," said a spokesman.
Britain is not the only country to miss out on BP's largesse. The company said yesterday it was also pulling out of China, India and Turkey, where it had also been looking at projects.
BP had formed a joint venture with Beijing Tianrun New Energy Investment Company, a subsidiary of Goldwind, China's largest turbine maker. The two companies had signed a deal in January under which they planned 148.4MW of wind capacity in Inner Mongolia, China's main wind power region. BP had also started building two wind farms in India and was considering schemes in Turkey. It is now expecting to sell off the Indian facilities and halt work in Turkey.
Green campaigners have been highly sceptical about BP's plans to go "beyond petroleum" and feared that the company's new chief executive, Tony Hayward, would drop this commitment, started under his predecessor, John Browne.
The company has always insisted it remained keen to look at green energy solutions and has been investing in biofuels operations in Brazil. BP is also in the middle of a major marketing campaign, with huge posters on the London Underground boasting of its moves to diversify into wind and other energy sources.
The Carbon Trust, a government-funded organisation established to help Britain move from carbon to clean energy, recently published a major report warning ministers that the costs of building wind farms offshore was too high. There was speculation that BP was a major influence on that study, which proposed that turbines should be allowed to be placed much nearer to the shore.
The Crown Estate, which has responsibility for UK inshore waters, is still confident that a long-awaited third offshore wind licensing round in the North Sea will attract a record number of bidders. It has already registered 96 companies, although it has not released names and BP and Shell will clearly be absent.
BP pulls out of contest to build emissions plant
By Ed Crooks, Rebecca Bream and Fiona Harvey
Published: November 8 2008 02:00
BP has pulled out of the government's competition to build a prototype power station that will capture and store its carbon dioxide emissions, in a setback to plans to develop technologies for cutting the output of greenhouse gases while continuing to use fossil fuels.
Britain's biggest energy company will instead focus its carbon capture programme on its joint venture with Rio Tinto, the mining group, which is developing projects in California and Abu Dhabi.
It has also emerged that RWE Npower, the UK arm of the German energy group, is considering legal action against the government after failing to reach the short list for the carbon capture competition.
The government is offering a subsidy of several hundred million pounds to the competition winner, to build an integrated project including a coal-fired power station and equipment to separate carbon dioxide from the waste gases and take care of storage.
The winner is to be chosen as the preferred bidder by the end of next year, with the aim of having the project in operation by the end of 2014.
Four groups made the short list chosen by the government over the summer: BP, Eon UK, ScottishPower and Peel Holdings.
However, BP last month told the department of energy and climate change that it would drop out, having failed to find a partner with coal-fired power generation experience.
The move follows BP's decision to focus its wind power business on the US, where most of its activity is concentrated.
It had been looking at possible developments in other countries, including Britain and China, but has decided that the risks in other markets, such as offshore wind in the UK, make them commercially unattractive compared with onshore wind in the US.
The government played down the significance of BP's exit from the carbon capture competition, saying there were still "three strong bidders who are committed to the project".
In spite of its failure to make the government's short list, RWE Npower is also still keen to take part.
It has been in talks with Eon, ScottishPower and Peel about joining their bids, and hopes to make an announcement in the next few weeks.
If it fails to strike a deal, however, RWE plans to challenge the government over how the short list was drawn up.
It said it was "surprised and disappointed" to be excluded.
"As a prudent measure to preserve our position, we are submitting an application to seek a judicial review of the process," it said.
Jeff Chapman, chief executive of the Carbon Capture and Storage Association, said he was "concerned" that the timetable for the competition appeared to be slipping.
He said Britain needed to grasp carbon capture and storage as a matter of urgency.
Finalists going head-to-head
Remaining entries left in the government's carbon capture competition: Eon UK plans to build a controversial coal-fired power station at Kingsnorth in Kent, and would fit carbon capture equipment to half of one of the two units at the plant. Its partners include Tullow Oil and Arup and Fluor, two engineers. ScottishPower bought last year by Iberdrola of Spain, is in a consortium with Marathon Oil of the US and Aker, a Norwegian engineer. It hopes to add carbon capture equipment to one of the four units at Longannet, a 1970s coal-fired power station on the Firth of Forth. Peel Holdings , the owner of John Lennon airport, Mersey Docks and the Trafford Centre, has a partnership with Dong Energy, a Danish gas and electricity group. It has not yet specified which power station it would want to fit.
And one other hopeful: RWE Npower submitted an entry for its proposed power station at Tilbury in Essex, but was rejected on a technicality. It hopes to re-enter the race.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 8 2008 02:00
BP has pulled out of the government's competition to build a prototype power station that will capture and store its carbon dioxide emissions, in a setback to plans to develop technologies for cutting the output of greenhouse gases while continuing to use fossil fuels.
Britain's biggest energy company will instead focus its carbon capture programme on its joint venture with Rio Tinto, the mining group, which is developing projects in California and Abu Dhabi.
It has also emerged that RWE Npower, the UK arm of the German energy group, is considering legal action against the government after failing to reach the short list for the carbon capture competition.
The government is offering a subsidy of several hundred million pounds to the competition winner, to build an integrated project including a coal-fired power station and equipment to separate carbon dioxide from the waste gases and take care of storage.
The winner is to be chosen as the preferred bidder by the end of next year, with the aim of having the project in operation by the end of 2014.
Four groups made the short list chosen by the government over the summer: BP, Eon UK, ScottishPower and Peel Holdings.
However, BP last month told the department of energy and climate change that it would drop out, having failed to find a partner with coal-fired power generation experience.
The move follows BP's decision to focus its wind power business on the US, where most of its activity is concentrated.
It had been looking at possible developments in other countries, including Britain and China, but has decided that the risks in other markets, such as offshore wind in the UK, make them commercially unattractive compared with onshore wind in the US.
The government played down the significance of BP's exit from the carbon capture competition, saying there were still "three strong bidders who are committed to the project".
In spite of its failure to make the government's short list, RWE Npower is also still keen to take part.
It has been in talks with Eon, ScottishPower and Peel about joining their bids, and hopes to make an announcement in the next few weeks.
If it fails to strike a deal, however, RWE plans to challenge the government over how the short list was drawn up.
It said it was "surprised and disappointed" to be excluded.
"As a prudent measure to preserve our position, we are submitting an application to seek a judicial review of the process," it said.
Jeff Chapman, chief executive of the Carbon Capture and Storage Association, said he was "concerned" that the timetable for the competition appeared to be slipping.
He said Britain needed to grasp carbon capture and storage as a matter of urgency.
Finalists going head-to-head
Remaining entries left in the government's carbon capture competition: Eon UK plans to build a controversial coal-fired power station at Kingsnorth in Kent, and would fit carbon capture equipment to half of one of the two units at the plant. Its partners include Tullow Oil and Arup and Fluor, two engineers. ScottishPower bought last year by Iberdrola of Spain, is in a consortium with Marathon Oil of the US and Aker, a Norwegian engineer. It hopes to add carbon capture equipment to one of the four units at Longannet, a 1970s coal-fired power station on the Firth of Forth. Peel Holdings , the owner of John Lennon airport, Mersey Docks and the Trafford Centre, has a partnership with Dong Energy, a Danish gas and electricity group. It has not yet specified which power station it would want to fit.
And one other hopeful: RWE Npower submitted an entry for its proposed power station at Tilbury in Essex, but was rejected on a technicality. It hopes to re-enter the race.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
BP Pulls Out of Bidding for U.K. Climate-Change Project
By GUY CHAZAN
LONDON -- The United Kingdom's hopes of becoming a world leader in the battle against global warming suffered a potential setback when British oil major BP PLC said it had pulled out of a competition to design the country's first carbon capture and storage project.
The announcement came as BP said it would be concentrating its wind investments in the U.S., effectively exiting the U.K. wind power market.
Carbon capture and storage -- known as CCS -- is critical to U.K. energy policy. Coal, which is in plentiful supply in Britain, is a big part of the U.K. energy mix. The U.K. says it will cut carbon emissions by 80% by 2050 -- a target it can achieve only if it can work out a way to sequester and safely store the carbon dioxide emitted by its coal-fired power stations.
CCS has so far never been applied on a commercial scale, and there are fears the costs will be prohibitive. Some companies developing the technology say it won't work without big financial incentives.
The U.K. government announced in July it had shortlisted four bidders to develop the country's first CCS demonstration project -- BP Alternative Energy, E.ON AG, Peel Holdings and ScottishPower, the U.K. arm of Spain's Iberdrola SA.
But BP is pulling out. "We don't believe we can put together a consortium that would win the competition," said spokesman David Nicholas. He said BP had failed to find a power generator that it could partner with.
The government said BP's move wouldn't affect the competition. "We continue to have three strong bidders who are committed to the project and to CCS," said a spokeswoman. "BP's decision does not compromise the integrity of the competition, nor will it have a material impact on the robustness of the procurement process."
But the project is facing problems on other fronts. RWE npower, the U.K. subsidiary of German utility RWE AG, has said it will seek a judicial review of the government's decision to leave it off the shortlist for the competition.
BP has already backed out of one CCS venture in the U.K. Last year, it abandoned a trial project in Peterhead, Scotland, saying the government's timetable for a competition to win financing for a prototype plant was too slow.
Mr. Nicholas said the decision on the demonstration project didn't reflect a change in BP's views on carbon capture. He said BP remained committed to Hydrogen Energy, its 50-50 joint venture with mining giant Rio Tinto PLC, which is developing two carbon-capture projects, one in California and the other in Abu Dhabi. Hydrogen Energy abandoned plans for a CCS plant in western Australia earlier this year after it failed to find geological formations suitable for long-term storage of CO2.
BP also said this week that it wouldn't be pursuing wind power initiatives in the U.K., concentrating instead on the U.S. where it said the economics made more sense. BP already has a large development portfolio in the U.S., with 15,000 megawatts of capacity.
"We can get much higher returns from the large wind farms we can put up in the U.S., due to the economies of scale," Mr. Nicholas said.
BP isn't involved in any major wind projects in Britain, though it had been looking into a wind farm on the Isle of Grain in Kent. Its rival, Royal Dutch Shell PLC, announced last May that it was pulling out of the London Array, a massive offshore-wind project, because rising costs raised doubts about its profitability. The company said the economics of investing in onshore wind power in the U.S. are "significantly better."
Write to Guy Chazan at guy.chazan@wsj.com
LONDON -- The United Kingdom's hopes of becoming a world leader in the battle against global warming suffered a potential setback when British oil major BP PLC said it had pulled out of a competition to design the country's first carbon capture and storage project.
The announcement came as BP said it would be concentrating its wind investments in the U.S., effectively exiting the U.K. wind power market.
Carbon capture and storage -- known as CCS -- is critical to U.K. energy policy. Coal, which is in plentiful supply in Britain, is a big part of the U.K. energy mix. The U.K. says it will cut carbon emissions by 80% by 2050 -- a target it can achieve only if it can work out a way to sequester and safely store the carbon dioxide emitted by its coal-fired power stations.
CCS has so far never been applied on a commercial scale, and there are fears the costs will be prohibitive. Some companies developing the technology say it won't work without big financial incentives.
The U.K. government announced in July it had shortlisted four bidders to develop the country's first CCS demonstration project -- BP Alternative Energy, E.ON AG, Peel Holdings and ScottishPower, the U.K. arm of Spain's Iberdrola SA.
But BP is pulling out. "We don't believe we can put together a consortium that would win the competition," said spokesman David Nicholas. He said BP had failed to find a power generator that it could partner with.
The government said BP's move wouldn't affect the competition. "We continue to have three strong bidders who are committed to the project and to CCS," said a spokeswoman. "BP's decision does not compromise the integrity of the competition, nor will it have a material impact on the robustness of the procurement process."
But the project is facing problems on other fronts. RWE npower, the U.K. subsidiary of German utility RWE AG, has said it will seek a judicial review of the government's decision to leave it off the shortlist for the competition.
BP has already backed out of one CCS venture in the U.K. Last year, it abandoned a trial project in Peterhead, Scotland, saying the government's timetable for a competition to win financing for a prototype plant was too slow.
Mr. Nicholas said the decision on the demonstration project didn't reflect a change in BP's views on carbon capture. He said BP remained committed to Hydrogen Energy, its 50-50 joint venture with mining giant Rio Tinto PLC, which is developing two carbon-capture projects, one in California and the other in Abu Dhabi. Hydrogen Energy abandoned plans for a CCS plant in western Australia earlier this year after it failed to find geological formations suitable for long-term storage of CO2.
BP also said this week that it wouldn't be pursuing wind power initiatives in the U.K., concentrating instead on the U.S. where it said the economics made more sense. BP already has a large development portfolio in the U.S., with 15,000 megawatts of capacity.
"We can get much higher returns from the large wind farms we can put up in the U.S., due to the economies of scale," Mr. Nicholas said.
BP isn't involved in any major wind projects in Britain, though it had been looking into a wind farm on the Isle of Grain in Kent. Its rival, Royal Dutch Shell PLC, announced last May that it was pulling out of the London Array, a massive offshore-wind project, because rising costs raised doubts about its profitability. The company said the economics of investing in onshore wind power in the U.S. are "significantly better."
Write to Guy Chazan at guy.chazan@wsj.com
Wind investment at a standstill
Robin Pagamenta: Analysis
The Government wants to build an unprecedented 33 gigawatts of wind power capacity by 2020 to help to meet Britain's carbon reduction targets, but sceptics question whether the 15,000 turbines will ever be built.
Thirty-three gigawatts represents one third of UK power generation and on some days it would be enough to power every home in the country. However, a lack of financial incentives, a trebling of costs since 2003 and now the falling price of oil are undermining confidence in the industry.
Several investors are shunning Britain in favour of the bigger subsidies and the more established investment climate available for onshore windfarms in Spain, Germany and the United States.
Developers also complain about the convoluted UK planning system and the difficulty of getting connections to the National Grid.
Such problems have encouraged the Government to push increasingly for offshore windfarms, but these are more expensive and remain a relatively unproven technology.
The projected cost of one project, the London Array, has soared from £1 billion in 2003 to £3 billion. Many developers are also struggling because they have been locked out of the debt markets by the credit crunch.
The collapse in oil prices is also hampering the industry by making it less economically attractive than polluting fossil fuels.
The Government wants to build an unprecedented 33 gigawatts of wind power capacity by 2020 to help to meet Britain's carbon reduction targets, but sceptics question whether the 15,000 turbines will ever be built.
Thirty-three gigawatts represents one third of UK power generation and on some days it would be enough to power every home in the country. However, a lack of financial incentives, a trebling of costs since 2003 and now the falling price of oil are undermining confidence in the industry.
Several investors are shunning Britain in favour of the bigger subsidies and the more established investment climate available for onshore windfarms in Spain, Germany and the United States.
Developers also complain about the convoluted UK planning system and the difficulty of getting connections to the National Grid.
Such problems have encouraged the Government to push increasingly for offshore windfarms, but these are more expensive and remain a relatively unproven technology.
The projected cost of one project, the London Array, has soared from £1 billion in 2003 to £3 billion. Many developers are also struggling because they have been locked out of the debt markets by the credit crunch.
The collapse in oil prices is also hampering the industry by making it less economically attractive than polluting fossil fuels.
Setback for Government's green agenda as BP quits key projects
From The Times
November 8, 2008
Robin Pagnamenta, energy and environment editor
Government plans for Britain to become a world leader in clean energy technology suffered a double setback yesterday after BP said that it was abandoning the country's wind energy industry and pulling out of a competition to build a demonstration carbon-capture and storage plant.
The oil company informed the Government last week that it would no longer be submitting a bid for a government-funded scheme to develop a coal-fired power plant using carbon capture and storage (CCS), an experimental technology that strips out CO2 emissions for safe storage. The CCS competition was announced in November last year and is a key feature of the Government's plans to fight climate change while creating one million green-collar jobs in renewable energy.
A spokesman for BP, which announced record third-quarter profits of £6.4 billion last week, said that the group had withdrawn because it had struggled to find suitable partners.
“We came to the conclusion that we could no longer put together a winning consortium,” the spokesman said. He added that BP was dropping plans to invest in UK windfarm projects in favour of better returns in the industry in the United States.
BP's move triggered protests from green groups, which accused the company of abandoning its stated commitment to move “beyond petroleum”.
Keith Allott, the head of the climate change programme of WWF-UK, said: “It's deeply disappointing that one of Britain's leading companies in this field is choosing not to invest in the green energy revolution we so desperately need while continuing to invest in conventional hydrocarbons. It seems incompatible with the company's previous positioning of moving ‘beyond petroleum'.”
The development of CCS technology is considered a critical step in tackling climate change. In theory, CCS equipment could be retrofitted to existing coal-fired power stations around the world, allowing for rapid cuts in CO2 emissions. BP Alternative Energy had been on a shortlist of four companies that was announced in July. It included E.ON UK, which wants to deploy CCS technology at its proposed coal-fired power station at Kingsnorth, Kent, as well as Peel Holdings and ScottishPower.
By reducing the field to only three players, the withdrawal of BP represents a significant blow for the Government's competition.
A spokeswoman for the Department of Energy and Climate Change sought to play down the significance of BP's decision. “We continue to have three strong bidders who are committed to the project and to CCS,” she said. “BP's decision does not compromise the integrity of the competition.”
BP insisted that it remained committed to renewable energy throughout the world. “We remain very supportive of alternative energy technology and we continue to invest in hydrogen energy projects in Abu Dhabi and California,” a spokesman said.
Royal Dutch Shell, the largest UK company by market value, also withdrew from the UK wind energy industry this year, citing rising costs.
Compounding the problems facing the Government's CCS project, RWE npower is preparing to initiate a legal challenge over the selection process for the competition. Npower was excluded from the shortlist because of a technicality.
November 8, 2008
Robin Pagnamenta, energy and environment editor
Government plans for Britain to become a world leader in clean energy technology suffered a double setback yesterday after BP said that it was abandoning the country's wind energy industry and pulling out of a competition to build a demonstration carbon-capture and storage plant.
The oil company informed the Government last week that it would no longer be submitting a bid for a government-funded scheme to develop a coal-fired power plant using carbon capture and storage (CCS), an experimental technology that strips out CO2 emissions for safe storage. The CCS competition was announced in November last year and is a key feature of the Government's plans to fight climate change while creating one million green-collar jobs in renewable energy.
A spokesman for BP, which announced record third-quarter profits of £6.4 billion last week, said that the group had withdrawn because it had struggled to find suitable partners.
“We came to the conclusion that we could no longer put together a winning consortium,” the spokesman said. He added that BP was dropping plans to invest in UK windfarm projects in favour of better returns in the industry in the United States.
BP's move triggered protests from green groups, which accused the company of abandoning its stated commitment to move “beyond petroleum”.
Keith Allott, the head of the climate change programme of WWF-UK, said: “It's deeply disappointing that one of Britain's leading companies in this field is choosing not to invest in the green energy revolution we so desperately need while continuing to invest in conventional hydrocarbons. It seems incompatible with the company's previous positioning of moving ‘beyond petroleum'.”
The development of CCS technology is considered a critical step in tackling climate change. In theory, CCS equipment could be retrofitted to existing coal-fired power stations around the world, allowing for rapid cuts in CO2 emissions. BP Alternative Energy had been on a shortlist of four companies that was announced in July. It included E.ON UK, which wants to deploy CCS technology at its proposed coal-fired power station at Kingsnorth, Kent, as well as Peel Holdings and ScottishPower.
By reducing the field to only three players, the withdrawal of BP represents a significant blow for the Government's competition.
A spokeswoman for the Department of Energy and Climate Change sought to play down the significance of BP's decision. “We continue to have three strong bidders who are committed to the project and to CCS,” she said. “BP's decision does not compromise the integrity of the competition.”
BP insisted that it remained committed to renewable energy throughout the world. “We remain very supportive of alternative energy technology and we continue to invest in hydrogen energy projects in Abu Dhabi and California,” a spokesman said.
Royal Dutch Shell, the largest UK company by market value, also withdrew from the UK wind energy industry this year, citing rising costs.
Compounding the problems facing the Government's CCS project, RWE npower is preparing to initiate a legal challenge over the selection process for the competition. Npower was excluded from the shortlist because of a technicality.
Suzlon lifted by US green agenda
By Andrew Wood in Hong Kong
Published: November 8 2008 02:00
One of Asia's best-performing stocks this week as a result of Barack Obama's victory in the US presidential election was Suzlon , an Indian maker of wind-powered electricity generators.
Suzlon shares climbed 59 per cent to Rs70.6 - the biggest percentage gain among the 1,120 members of the FTSE Asia-Pacific index - on hopes that Mr Obama's enthusiasm for green power would translate into bigger profits for the sector.
It was a volatile week packed with interest rate cuts; central banks in India, Australia and South Korea joined in the global trend for loosening monetary policy.
The region broadly welcomed Mr Obama's victory, although pessimism about the outlook for the world economy resurfaced.
The FTSE Asia-Pacific index managed a 2 per cent rise over the week - a small but welcome bounce after the benchmark's 20.2 per cent decline in October.
That headline gain masked a range of performances by individual markets: the Nikkei 225 Average in Japan lost 4.9 per cent during the week but Thai stocks gained 11.4 per cent.
Hong Kong rose 2 per cent and Australian stocks edged up 0.8 per cent.
Gains in alternative energy stocks seemed to be one of the few clear themes.
South Korea's Yonghyun , a maker of parts for wind turbines, surged 49.2 per cent to Won14,450. Solargiga , which produces solar panels in mainland China, rose 23 per cent to HK$2.19. In spite of that rise, the company was still worth a quarter less than when it floated in Hong Kong in March.
GS Yuasa , a maker of rechargeable batteries, was the Nikkei 225's best performer. Its shares gained 41.5 per cent to Y351 in the week. Sanyo Electric , which also makes power storage devices, was next, rising 39 per cent to Y203, although its rally was more to do with talk that Panasonic would launch a takeover bid.
But as green-related stocks rose, carmakers suffered. Toyota Motor , the world's second-biggest carmaker, dropped by 13 per centyesterday after it cut its forecast for annual profit by two-thirds. Toyota ended the week with an 11.3 per cent loss at Y3,460.
Nissan Motor , which has scrapped its dividend, was the Nikkei's third-worst performer over the week. It fell 21.6 per cent to Y422. Honda , which said sales in the US would fall sharply, lost 18.1 per cent to Y2,260.
Hyundai Motor lost as much as 21 per cent during the week but a sharp rally for South Korean stocks yesterday after the Bank of Korea cut interest rates for the third time in a month meant Hyundai ended the week with a loss of 7.3 per cent at Won54,500.
One sign of calmer markets - in Hong Kong at least - was that volatility implied by three-month options on the Hang Seng index stayed below the level of volatility recorded for all of this week - the first time this has happened since June.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 8 2008 02:00
One of Asia's best-performing stocks this week as a result of Barack Obama's victory in the US presidential election was Suzlon , an Indian maker of wind-powered electricity generators.
Suzlon shares climbed 59 per cent to Rs70.6 - the biggest percentage gain among the 1,120 members of the FTSE Asia-Pacific index - on hopes that Mr Obama's enthusiasm for green power would translate into bigger profits for the sector.
It was a volatile week packed with interest rate cuts; central banks in India, Australia and South Korea joined in the global trend for loosening monetary policy.
The region broadly welcomed Mr Obama's victory, although pessimism about the outlook for the world economy resurfaced.
The FTSE Asia-Pacific index managed a 2 per cent rise over the week - a small but welcome bounce after the benchmark's 20.2 per cent decline in October.
That headline gain masked a range of performances by individual markets: the Nikkei 225 Average in Japan lost 4.9 per cent during the week but Thai stocks gained 11.4 per cent.
Hong Kong rose 2 per cent and Australian stocks edged up 0.8 per cent.
Gains in alternative energy stocks seemed to be one of the few clear themes.
South Korea's Yonghyun , a maker of parts for wind turbines, surged 49.2 per cent to Won14,450. Solargiga , which produces solar panels in mainland China, rose 23 per cent to HK$2.19. In spite of that rise, the company was still worth a quarter less than when it floated in Hong Kong in March.
GS Yuasa , a maker of rechargeable batteries, was the Nikkei 225's best performer. Its shares gained 41.5 per cent to Y351 in the week. Sanyo Electric , which also makes power storage devices, was next, rising 39 per cent to Y203, although its rally was more to do with talk that Panasonic would launch a takeover bid.
But as green-related stocks rose, carmakers suffered. Toyota Motor , the world's second-biggest carmaker, dropped by 13 per centyesterday after it cut its forecast for annual profit by two-thirds. Toyota ended the week with an 11.3 per cent loss at Y3,460.
Nissan Motor , which has scrapped its dividend, was the Nikkei's third-worst performer over the week. It fell 21.6 per cent to Y422. Honda , which said sales in the US would fall sharply, lost 18.1 per cent to Y2,260.
Hyundai Motor lost as much as 21 per cent during the week but a sharp rally for South Korean stocks yesterday after the Bank of Korea cut interest rates for the third time in a month meant Hyundai ended the week with a loss of 7.3 per cent at Won54,500.
One sign of calmer markets - in Hong Kong at least - was that volatility implied by three-month options on the Hang Seng index stayed below the level of volatility recorded for all of this week - the first time this has happened since June.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Does Green Energy Add 5 Million Jobs? Potent Pitch, but Numbers Are Squishy
By JEFFREY BALL
Calls for a clean-energy system in the U.S. have long met with sticker shock. Now, the cost of making the transition -- hundreds of billions of dollars -- is being touted as a selling point.
President-elect Barack Obama and his energy advisers have been making the case that a multibillion-dollar government investment in everything from wind turbines to a "smart" electrical grid is just what's needed to help revive the economy. The lure is millions of government-subsidized "green jobs."
On the campaign trail, Mr. Obama argued that spending $150 billion over the next decade to boost energy efficiency would help create five million jobs. The jobs would include insulation installers, to make houses more energy-efficient, wind-turbine builders, to displace coal-fired electricity, and construction workers, to build greener buildings and upgrade the electrical grid.
The numbers are debated by the Obama advisers themselves, and are likely to spark debate when Congress considers a stimulus package including green jobs. But a big government push, focused on jobs, may represent the best chance in years for renewable energy and energy efficiency to take root in the U.S., a voracious energy consumer.
"It's a terrible situation that we find ourselves in," says Bracken Hendricks, an energy adviser to Mr. Obama and a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, a left-leaning Washington think tank. "But it's exciting that these issues are getting some attention."
The green-jobs argument rests on the notion that big capital investments in new-energy technology today will be more than offset by savings in reduced fossil-fuel costs. Though oil prices have fallen, the International Energy Agency predicted Thursday that once the economy picks up again, they will resume climbing, potentially topping $200 a barrel by 2030. The IEA called the current energy system "patently unsustainable" and called for "radical action by governments."
The added allure of clean-energy spending as economic stimulus is that the industry is relatively young and growing fast. Unlike the fossil-fuel industry, which has matured over decades, it is just starting to build its basic infrastructure -- wind turbines, solar panels and a more-sophisticated electric-transmission grid.
Several studies estimate that $1 invested in renewable energy or energy efficiency would yield up to four times as many jobs as $1 invested in oil and gas, whose basic infrastructure of wells, refineries and pipelines has been around for years. Moreover, those studies say, clean-energy jobs are likely to be centered in the U.S., unlike jobs in the oil and gas industry, which increasingly are spread around the world.
Critics say analyzing only new green jobs misses half the story.
"It's not looking at the other side of the coin: You are spending more money for your energy," says Anne Smith, a vice president at CRA International. The consulting firm wrote a report for the coal-mining industry in April that concluded that, under a bill to cap global-warming emissions, gains in green jobs would be "more than offset" by job losses elsewhere in the economy. That bill failed, but Mr. Obama has said he supports capping emissions.
The green-jobs argument isn't new. In the 1970s, amid an energy and economic crisis, President Jimmy Carter cited job creation as one reason for his calls to increase federal spending on renewable-energy research and development. But the argument has taken on new life in the past few years, as environmental activists have concluded that saving the planet isn't enough to make most Americans support higher government spending.
The job creation number cited by Mr. Obama has its roots in several green-jobs studies. Each projected different numbers, because each made different assumptions -- for instance, about the number of additional jobs that would be created by the spending of every person directly employed in a green job.
Robert Pollin, a professor at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, who co-wrote another study, questions the job target touted by the Obama campaign, saying it would cost much more.
Mr. Pollin's study, sponsored by the Center for American Progress, came out in September, after green jobs had become a theme on the presidential campaign trail. It said that $100 billion spent over two years could produce two million green jobs.
Even Mr. Pollin's study assessed only the number of jobs that might be added if the government spent more money on clean energy. It didn't count jobs that might be lost elsewhere in the economy if the country shifted to costlier sources of energy.
Mr. Pollin says he's working on a fuller study now. He and other green-jobs advocates say that, on balance, shifting to cleaner sources of energy creates more jobs than it destroys.
The Apollo Alliance, a San Francisco coalition of environmental and labor groups, also released a study in September. It concluded that five million green jobs could be had with an investment of $500 billion -- more than three times Mr. Obama's number.
Kate Gordon, co-director of the Apollo Alliance, says the numbers are less important than the message. "Honestly," she says, "it's just to inspire people."
Write to Jeffrey Ball at jeffrey.ball@wsj.com
Calls for a clean-energy system in the U.S. have long met with sticker shock. Now, the cost of making the transition -- hundreds of billions of dollars -- is being touted as a selling point.
President-elect Barack Obama and his energy advisers have been making the case that a multibillion-dollar government investment in everything from wind turbines to a "smart" electrical grid is just what's needed to help revive the economy. The lure is millions of government-subsidized "green jobs."
On the campaign trail, Mr. Obama argued that spending $150 billion over the next decade to boost energy efficiency would help create five million jobs. The jobs would include insulation installers, to make houses more energy-efficient, wind-turbine builders, to displace coal-fired electricity, and construction workers, to build greener buildings and upgrade the electrical grid.
The numbers are debated by the Obama advisers themselves, and are likely to spark debate when Congress considers a stimulus package including green jobs. But a big government push, focused on jobs, may represent the best chance in years for renewable energy and energy efficiency to take root in the U.S., a voracious energy consumer.
"It's a terrible situation that we find ourselves in," says Bracken Hendricks, an energy adviser to Mr. Obama and a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress, a left-leaning Washington think tank. "But it's exciting that these issues are getting some attention."
The green-jobs argument rests on the notion that big capital investments in new-energy technology today will be more than offset by savings in reduced fossil-fuel costs. Though oil prices have fallen, the International Energy Agency predicted Thursday that once the economy picks up again, they will resume climbing, potentially topping $200 a barrel by 2030. The IEA called the current energy system "patently unsustainable" and called for "radical action by governments."
The added allure of clean-energy spending as economic stimulus is that the industry is relatively young and growing fast. Unlike the fossil-fuel industry, which has matured over decades, it is just starting to build its basic infrastructure -- wind turbines, solar panels and a more-sophisticated electric-transmission grid.
Several studies estimate that $1 invested in renewable energy or energy efficiency would yield up to four times as many jobs as $1 invested in oil and gas, whose basic infrastructure of wells, refineries and pipelines has been around for years. Moreover, those studies say, clean-energy jobs are likely to be centered in the U.S., unlike jobs in the oil and gas industry, which increasingly are spread around the world.
Critics say analyzing only new green jobs misses half the story.
"It's not looking at the other side of the coin: You are spending more money for your energy," says Anne Smith, a vice president at CRA International. The consulting firm wrote a report for the coal-mining industry in April that concluded that, under a bill to cap global-warming emissions, gains in green jobs would be "more than offset" by job losses elsewhere in the economy. That bill failed, but Mr. Obama has said he supports capping emissions.
The green-jobs argument isn't new. In the 1970s, amid an energy and economic crisis, President Jimmy Carter cited job creation as one reason for his calls to increase federal spending on renewable-energy research and development. But the argument has taken on new life in the past few years, as environmental activists have concluded that saving the planet isn't enough to make most Americans support higher government spending.
The job creation number cited by Mr. Obama has its roots in several green-jobs studies. Each projected different numbers, because each made different assumptions -- for instance, about the number of additional jobs that would be created by the spending of every person directly employed in a green job.
Robert Pollin, a professor at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, who co-wrote another study, questions the job target touted by the Obama campaign, saying it would cost much more.
Mr. Pollin's study, sponsored by the Center for American Progress, came out in September, after green jobs had become a theme on the presidential campaign trail. It said that $100 billion spent over two years could produce two million green jobs.
Even Mr. Pollin's study assessed only the number of jobs that might be added if the government spent more money on clean energy. It didn't count jobs that might be lost elsewhere in the economy if the country shifted to costlier sources of energy.
Mr. Pollin says he's working on a fuller study now. He and other green-jobs advocates say that, on balance, shifting to cleaner sources of energy creates more jobs than it destroys.
The Apollo Alliance, a San Francisco coalition of environmental and labor groups, also released a study in September. It concluded that five million green jobs could be had with an investment of $500 billion -- more than three times Mr. Obama's number.
Kate Gordon, co-director of the Apollo Alliance, says the numbers are less important than the message. "Honestly," she says, "it's just to inspire people."
Write to Jeffrey Ball at jeffrey.ball@wsj.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
