By Robert Anderson
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
Finland's Olkiluoto power station was meant to symbolise the resurrection of nuclear power after the 1986 Chernobyl disaster and to act as a showcase for Areva of France's new EPR reactor technology.
The first nuclear power station to be built in western Europe since Chernobyl, Olkiluoto 3 would demonstrate that nuclear energy was the obvious solution to growing concerns about CO 2 emissions, high fossil fuel prices and dependence on imported energy sources.
It would also advertise that Areva had an efficient technology that could be rolled out to all the countries now considering building nuclear plants. To meet safety fears, Olkiluoto's outer shell is designed to withstand the impact of an airliner and nuclear waste will be stored underground on site.
Instead, Olkiluoto has become a showcase for the hassles, delays and cost-overruns that critics say always bedevil nuclear projects. Finland's fifth nuclear plant is now only expected to start operation in 2012 - three years late - and to cost €4.5bn, 50 per cent more than originally planned.
If it remains any kind of showcase for Areva, it will be an expensive one. Since Areva and Siemens of Germany (which supplies the turbine unit) agreed to deliver the plant as a turnkey project, they will have to cover the bulk of the cost overruns, although they are likely to try to dispute the final amount.
The Finnish side is adamant that Areva and Siemens will have to foot the bill.
"They have to take all the responsibility," insists Jorma Aurela, senior engineer of the Finnish ministry of employment and the economy.
Finland took the plunge to build a nuclear power station because it wants to reduce its acute dependence on expensive imported energy sources, particularly gas from neighbouring Russia. It also needs nuclear energy to help fulfil its commitments to reduce CO 2 emissions by 16 per cent before 2020. Renewable energy, primarily biomass and hydro-electric power, already represents around one-third of total generation and ramping it up further while consumption continues to grow will be difficult.
Nuclear power - already a quarter of the country's generating capacity - seemed the obvious answer and parliament voted in 2002 to re-start the nuclear programme, halted in 1993 in the wake of contamination by the Chernobyl fallout.
TVO, a consortium of big energy users, held a tender and chose Areva in October 2003 to build an extra 1,600MW unit at the Olkiluoto power station on an island in western Finland.
Areva needed a showcase for its EPR third-generation reactor and agreed highly aggressive terms to win the project. It agreed a price tag of €3bn and pledged to have the plant up and running in the first half of 2009 - just five years after it applied for a construction licence.
This was unrealistic because a conventional nuclear reactor normally takes six years to build and the EPR is far more complex. It was also Areva's first turnkey contract and they had no experience of running such a large project, the largest single unit ever built.
More fundamentally, the almost two-decade moratorium on nuclear plants in western Europe has caused reactor-building expertise to atrophy. There have been delays in receiving vital components and quality problems. The construction companies at the site underestimated how many workers they needed and how rigorous the safety procedures would be.
There has also been a culture clash between the French and Finnish approaches to building regulation. The French side has grumbled that the Finnish nuclear regulator has demanded huge amounts of documentation in advance and has been sluggish in processing it.
For their part, the Finns are unapologetic and blame the French for being unprepared. "They should have known what is the Finnish system," says Mr Aurela. "We have very strict authorities. We have not seen any important delays there."
Whether Olkiluoto's problems deter others from building nuclear plants or commissioning Areva's EPR will depend on whether the French company can stick to its latest targets and whether it becomes embroiled in a squabble over cost overruns with TVO.
Areva will try to write Olkiluoto off as a loss-leading prototype and hope that its experience there will enable it to win new contracts that it can complete under budget.
Areva is also building a second EPR at Flamanville in northern France - which is currently only slightly delayed and over budget - and is competing in a vital tender in South Africa. EdF, the French utility, is also planning to build four EPR reactors in the UK following its recent acquisition of British Energy.
For their part the Finns are not disheartened by their pathbreaking nuclear project. The government has already received proposals from TVO for a fourth unit at Olkiluoto and two separate proposals for new plants are expected to be submitted next year.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Monday, 3 November 2008
Atomic revival gathers momentum
By Rebecca Bream
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
The revival of interest in nuclear energy has been in full swing for several years, and the list of countries considering building new reactors is lengthening all the time. Concerns about energy security and climate change are gaining political momentum around the world, and are winning over many former opponents to nuclear power.
As well as established nuclear powers such as the US, the UK and China planning to boost nuclear investment, countries that have never hosted atomic reactors are talking about getting involved in the industry.
For example, Poland, which gets more than 90 per cent of its electricity from coal-fired power stations, has asked South Korea for help in building its first nuclear reactor and hopes to start construction by 2012.
The United Arab Emirates, also a newcomer to nuclear power, has awarded a contract to US engineering and construction company CH2M Hill to manage its atomic investment programme. Although the UAE has large amounts of oil and gas, it wants to move into nuclear energy in order to satisfy a rising demand for electricity. CH2M Hill will be responsible for planning the UAE's nuclear investment programme in accordance with United Nations standards.
As more countries decide to enter the nuclear world, questions are being asked about how governments can most effectively encourage investment in reactors and avoid mistakes of the past.
Safety considerations are paramount; another accident on the scale of those at Three Mile Island in 1979 or Chernobyl in 1986 would destroy public confidence in the nuclear industry and would kill off much of the political and commercial interest in nuclear expansion. Countries that have either never built a nuclear reactor before or those, like Italy and the UK, that have had a hiatus of several decades since their last plant was constructed, need to prove that their nuclear safety regulatory regimes are robust and that risks will be minimised.
Another issue is cost. In the early days of nuclear power, proponents said that electricity would be generated so cheaply it could almost be given away for free. But in the decades that followed, many reactor projects missed deadlines and ran over budget. In the UK, a tendency to change the reactor technology each time a new power station was built meant that there was only a very shallow pool of expertise and spare parts to draw on when the plants broke down, leading to lengthy outages.
This time around, standardisation is the nuclear industry's buzzword. Reactor manufacturers such as Westinghouse, Areva and GE stress that the best way to keep costs down and limit outages is to build large fleets of standardised reactors. This would provide economies of scale, and mean that each country could draw on an established global supply chain and source of skills and technical information.
In the past, nuclear power has been more expensive than power generated from gas-, oil- or coal-fired plants, when measured over the life of the plant. But as fossil fuel costs have risen in recent years, nuclear energy has started to look more commercially-viable.
There are fierce debates about the real cost of nuclear energy, once the expense of dealing with spent fuel and radioactive waste has been included. As yet there is little impartial data available, but experts argue that nuclear power offers countries advantages that outweigh the costs.
Tony Ward, a partner in the power and utilities team at Ernst & Young, says that governments' desire to diversify sources of power and cut emissions of CO 2 will continue to drive investment in nuclear power, no matter how much coal, oil and gas prices fluctuate. "Nuclear is at the moment the only truly scaleable provider of base-load power that is also low carbon," he says, adding that falling steel and construction costs should help projects keep to budgets.
Governments differ in how they expect nuclear investment to be paid for. In China and France, plants are being built by government-owned companies and it is not yet clear how much of the cost will be passed on to customers through bills and how much will be subsidised by the governments. In the US and the UK, investment is coming from the private sector, with the full cost being recovered from customers over time.
But to kick-start nuclear investment, all governments are offering some sort of incentive. "The US has chosen to provide financial incentives for the first tranche of reactors built and the UK is seeking to refine its energy policies," says Mr Ward at Ernst & Young.
It remains to be seen whether there will be enough skilled engineers and specialised components to support the revival. Mr Ward says projects could be delayed by shortages.
"Despite major investments around the world in the manufacturing plant, equipment and nuclear certifications on which the industry depends, demand is expected to outrun supply for at least the next two decades," he says.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
The revival of interest in nuclear energy has been in full swing for several years, and the list of countries considering building new reactors is lengthening all the time. Concerns about energy security and climate change are gaining political momentum around the world, and are winning over many former opponents to nuclear power.
As well as established nuclear powers such as the US, the UK and China planning to boost nuclear investment, countries that have never hosted atomic reactors are talking about getting involved in the industry.
For example, Poland, which gets more than 90 per cent of its electricity from coal-fired power stations, has asked South Korea for help in building its first nuclear reactor and hopes to start construction by 2012.
The United Arab Emirates, also a newcomer to nuclear power, has awarded a contract to US engineering and construction company CH2M Hill to manage its atomic investment programme. Although the UAE has large amounts of oil and gas, it wants to move into nuclear energy in order to satisfy a rising demand for electricity. CH2M Hill will be responsible for planning the UAE's nuclear investment programme in accordance with United Nations standards.
As more countries decide to enter the nuclear world, questions are being asked about how governments can most effectively encourage investment in reactors and avoid mistakes of the past.
Safety considerations are paramount; another accident on the scale of those at Three Mile Island in 1979 or Chernobyl in 1986 would destroy public confidence in the nuclear industry and would kill off much of the political and commercial interest in nuclear expansion. Countries that have either never built a nuclear reactor before or those, like Italy and the UK, that have had a hiatus of several decades since their last plant was constructed, need to prove that their nuclear safety regulatory regimes are robust and that risks will be minimised.
Another issue is cost. In the early days of nuclear power, proponents said that electricity would be generated so cheaply it could almost be given away for free. But in the decades that followed, many reactor projects missed deadlines and ran over budget. In the UK, a tendency to change the reactor technology each time a new power station was built meant that there was only a very shallow pool of expertise and spare parts to draw on when the plants broke down, leading to lengthy outages.
This time around, standardisation is the nuclear industry's buzzword. Reactor manufacturers such as Westinghouse, Areva and GE stress that the best way to keep costs down and limit outages is to build large fleets of standardised reactors. This would provide economies of scale, and mean that each country could draw on an established global supply chain and source of skills and technical information.
In the past, nuclear power has been more expensive than power generated from gas-, oil- or coal-fired plants, when measured over the life of the plant. But as fossil fuel costs have risen in recent years, nuclear energy has started to look more commercially-viable.
There are fierce debates about the real cost of nuclear energy, once the expense of dealing with spent fuel and radioactive waste has been included. As yet there is little impartial data available, but experts argue that nuclear power offers countries advantages that outweigh the costs.
Tony Ward, a partner in the power and utilities team at Ernst & Young, says that governments' desire to diversify sources of power and cut emissions of CO 2 will continue to drive investment in nuclear power, no matter how much coal, oil and gas prices fluctuate. "Nuclear is at the moment the only truly scaleable provider of base-load power that is also low carbon," he says, adding that falling steel and construction costs should help projects keep to budgets.
Governments differ in how they expect nuclear investment to be paid for. In China and France, plants are being built by government-owned companies and it is not yet clear how much of the cost will be passed on to customers through bills and how much will be subsidised by the governments. In the US and the UK, investment is coming from the private sector, with the full cost being recovered from customers over time.
But to kick-start nuclear investment, all governments are offering some sort of incentive. "The US has chosen to provide financial incentives for the first tranche of reactors built and the UK is seeking to refine its energy policies," says Mr Ward at Ernst & Young.
It remains to be seen whether there will be enough skilled engineers and specialised components to support the revival. Mr Ward says projects could be delayed by shortages.
"Despite major investments around the world in the manufacturing plant, equipment and nuclear certifications on which the industry depends, demand is expected to outrun supply for at least the next two decades," he says.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Dash for gas as it becomes fuel of choice
By Ed Crooks
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
Natural gas is the fossil fuel that has undergone the most profound change over the past decade, in its production, transportation and use.
The transformation of the economics of liquefied natural gas by exploiting economies of scale has enabled previously "stranded" resources to be be developed, at the same time as gas has established itself as the fuel of choice for power generation in Europe and the US.
Advances in technology have made possible a flourishing industry, particularly in the US, producing "unconventional" gas, trapped in rocks where it has not previously been accessible.
Gas has also emerged as an attractive prospect for the big international oil companies, struggling to secure access to resources. When the IOCs make their pitches to resource-rich countries, two of the principal benefits they will cite are technology and access to markets.
In oil production, much of the technology is in the hands of national oil companies or the service companies that they can hire, and access to markets is an irrelevance: oil is a liquid global market, and there will always be someone to take it if the price is right. In gas, on the other hand, some of the technology is held by relatively few companies, and a downstream position in markets in developed countries is important for maximising the value of sales.
For all those attractions, however, the gas industry is facing problems: above all, the delays and cost overruns to production and transportation projects caused by shortages of personnel, equipment and materials.
The demand pressure for gas comes from its growing use for power generation, and as a source of heat in emerging economies.
Combined-cycle gas turbine stations are among the cheapest forms of power generation in terms of investment, and can be among the cheapest to run. They are also the quickest to build, making them attractive for generators seeking to manage medium-term variations in supply and demand.
Pressure to control greenhouse gas emissions is also driving the use of natural gas. CO 2 emissions per kilowatt hour of electricity generated for the best-performing gas-fired power stations are typically only about half those for the best-performing coal-fired plants.
In Europe, the majority of new power generation capacity under construction is gas-fired. As 3i, the private equity group, put it in a recent report: "We believe the lack of other economically viable and rapidly scaleable energy sources to power Europe's growing needs have led to a new 'dash for gas'."
In the US, coal still generates almost half the country's electricity, but gas-fired power generation capacity grew at 4.6 per cent a year on average during 1995-2006. A study by the Energy Information Administration found last year that from 2007-11 US utilities planned to add 46,000 megawatts of gas-fired capacity and only 29,600MW of coal-fired, and those coal projects have faced stiff opposition from environmentalists.
In emerging economies, the International Energy Agency, the rich countries' watchdog, expects gas to grow as a fuel for power generation. But there is also a rising demand for gas for heating and cooking.
The IEA projects that China's demand for gas will rise by 6.5 per cent a year between 2005 and 2030, by which time the proportion used for power will have grown from about a sixth to about a third.
Meeting that growing demand will be a challenge. Big gas production projects such as Gorgon off the coast of Australia have been hit by delays and soaring costs. The global financial turmoil may ease pressures in the supply chain, but also threatens the financing gas producers need to invest.
For example, Gazprom, the state-controlled Russian company, is under growing pressure that some analysts believe threatens plans to invest in gas production and transport in Russia.
Launching the IEA's report on the medium-term outlook for the gas industry in September, Nobuo Tanaka, its director-general, said: "Investment uncertainties, cost increases and delays continue to be a major problem in most gas markets and are continuing to constitute a threat to long-term security of supply."
Like oil, the price of gas has been falling as forecasts of demand have been scaled back.
But just as with oil, the prospect of sustained growth in demand, once the downturn has passed, coupled with limited increase in supply, which is likely to be made even worse as projects are delayed or stopped as a result of the financial crisis, promises a tight supply/demand balance and higher prices in the future.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 3 2008 02:00
Natural gas is the fossil fuel that has undergone the most profound change over the past decade, in its production, transportation and use.
The transformation of the economics of liquefied natural gas by exploiting economies of scale has enabled previously "stranded" resources to be be developed, at the same time as gas has established itself as the fuel of choice for power generation in Europe and the US.
Advances in technology have made possible a flourishing industry, particularly in the US, producing "unconventional" gas, trapped in rocks where it has not previously been accessible.
Gas has also emerged as an attractive prospect for the big international oil companies, struggling to secure access to resources. When the IOCs make their pitches to resource-rich countries, two of the principal benefits they will cite are technology and access to markets.
In oil production, much of the technology is in the hands of national oil companies or the service companies that they can hire, and access to markets is an irrelevance: oil is a liquid global market, and there will always be someone to take it if the price is right. In gas, on the other hand, some of the technology is held by relatively few companies, and a downstream position in markets in developed countries is important for maximising the value of sales.
For all those attractions, however, the gas industry is facing problems: above all, the delays and cost overruns to production and transportation projects caused by shortages of personnel, equipment and materials.
The demand pressure for gas comes from its growing use for power generation, and as a source of heat in emerging economies.
Combined-cycle gas turbine stations are among the cheapest forms of power generation in terms of investment, and can be among the cheapest to run. They are also the quickest to build, making them attractive for generators seeking to manage medium-term variations in supply and demand.
Pressure to control greenhouse gas emissions is also driving the use of natural gas. CO 2 emissions per kilowatt hour of electricity generated for the best-performing gas-fired power stations are typically only about half those for the best-performing coal-fired plants.
In Europe, the majority of new power generation capacity under construction is gas-fired. As 3i, the private equity group, put it in a recent report: "We believe the lack of other economically viable and rapidly scaleable energy sources to power Europe's growing needs have led to a new 'dash for gas'."
In the US, coal still generates almost half the country's electricity, but gas-fired power generation capacity grew at 4.6 per cent a year on average during 1995-2006. A study by the Energy Information Administration found last year that from 2007-11 US utilities planned to add 46,000 megawatts of gas-fired capacity and only 29,600MW of coal-fired, and those coal projects have faced stiff opposition from environmentalists.
In emerging economies, the International Energy Agency, the rich countries' watchdog, expects gas to grow as a fuel for power generation. But there is also a rising demand for gas for heating and cooking.
The IEA projects that China's demand for gas will rise by 6.5 per cent a year between 2005 and 2030, by which time the proportion used for power will have grown from about a sixth to about a third.
Meeting that growing demand will be a challenge. Big gas production projects such as Gorgon off the coast of Australia have been hit by delays and soaring costs. The global financial turmoil may ease pressures in the supply chain, but also threatens the financing gas producers need to invest.
For example, Gazprom, the state-controlled Russian company, is under growing pressure that some analysts believe threatens plans to invest in gas production and transport in Russia.
Launching the IEA's report on the medium-term outlook for the gas industry in September, Nobuo Tanaka, its director-general, said: "Investment uncertainties, cost increases and delays continue to be a major problem in most gas markets and are continuing to constitute a threat to long-term security of supply."
Like oil, the price of gas has been falling as forecasts of demand have been scaled back.
But just as with oil, the prospect of sustained growth in demand, once the downturn has passed, coupled with limited increase in supply, which is likely to be made even worse as projects are delayed or stopped as a result of the financial crisis, promises a tight supply/demand balance and higher prices in the future.
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Axe fossil-fuel handouts, says Browne
By Fiona Harvey, Environment Correspondent
Published: November 2 2008 23:36
Subsidies to fossil-fuel companies must be “dismantled”, says the former chief of BP, who has given warning of a “shake-out” among green energy companies that are struggling to survive.
Globally, about $200bn (£124bn) a year is spent on subsidies to the fossil-fuel energy industry – for example in the form of tax breaks on development. But only about $33bn is spent on subsidies to renewable and nuclear energy, says Lord Browne.
To move to a low-carbon economy requires a “level playing field” among energy companies, which would require the “dismantling” of subsidies to fossil fuels and a transfer to renewables and emerging technologies such as carbon capture and storage.
In his first face-to-face interview since leaving BP last year, Lord Browne said investment in the booming market for renewable energy had produced “a great bubbling” of new developments. But there would be a shake-out.
It was “inevitable that as the finance markets are closed, the debt markets are closed, that will fall off”, he said. “There has been a tremendous amount of activity. There might have been too much . . . It’s producing a lot of casualties. Maybe some of the more unlikely-to-succeed things will just be shut down as a result of tougher times.”
Lord Browne said fossil-fuel companies were facing upheaval as the energy mix was changing for the first time in three decades.
This would result in more demand for renewables and other low-carbon forms of energy, while greater energy efficiency spelt decline in some traditionally strong oil markets. US gasoline demand may already be in long-term decline, he said, because the car fleet was becoming more efficient.
Oil companies risked being caught out – like some telecommunications companies when first confronted by mobile technology.
“When mobile phones came in, I don’t think it was the fixed-line operators who were fastest and first to move to mobiles,” he said.
Lord Browne was speaking to the Financial Times ahead of a meeting of European energy experts in London on Monday at the Royal Academy of Engineering, of which he is president. At the gathering, he will call for world leaders urgently to pursue a global deal on climate change despite the economic downturn.
Since leaving BP, Lord Browne has taken on the chairmanship of the Accenture Global Energy Board and is managing director at the private equity firm Riverstone. He rejected the idea – put forward by a small group of UK companies last week – that the world’s oil supply would soon start to diminish.
“There’s plenty of oil, but it’s getting tougher to deliver and develop,” he said. Despite the recent fall in the oil price, the difficulty of exploiting new sources would have the effect of keeping prices high relative to past norms.
He called for the European Union’s emissions trading scheme (ETS) to be strengthened and dismissed claims that it was raising prices. The energy price rise resulting from it had been “infinitesimal”, compared with other factors.
“Moving these things around hardly changes the pool price of electricity – the cost of energy has gone up as it has become more expensive to make,” he said. “It does not make much difference in what we actually pay. Reductions in the base oil and gas [price] overwhelm anything that is happening in the [renewable subsidy] and ETS space.”
Consumers of energy should also face tougher regulation, he said. He pointed to “building codes, [the phasing out of incandescent] lightbulbs, offices in how long they should keep their lights on. And continuous regulation of [emissions from] cars should be tightened up.”
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Published: November 2 2008 23:36
Subsidies to fossil-fuel companies must be “dismantled”, says the former chief of BP, who has given warning of a “shake-out” among green energy companies that are struggling to survive.
Globally, about $200bn (£124bn) a year is spent on subsidies to the fossil-fuel energy industry – for example in the form of tax breaks on development. But only about $33bn is spent on subsidies to renewable and nuclear energy, says Lord Browne.
To move to a low-carbon economy requires a “level playing field” among energy companies, which would require the “dismantling” of subsidies to fossil fuels and a transfer to renewables and emerging technologies such as carbon capture and storage.
In his first face-to-face interview since leaving BP last year, Lord Browne said investment in the booming market for renewable energy had produced “a great bubbling” of new developments. But there would be a shake-out.
It was “inevitable that as the finance markets are closed, the debt markets are closed, that will fall off”, he said. “There has been a tremendous amount of activity. There might have been too much . . . It’s producing a lot of casualties. Maybe some of the more unlikely-to-succeed things will just be shut down as a result of tougher times.”
Lord Browne said fossil-fuel companies were facing upheaval as the energy mix was changing for the first time in three decades.
This would result in more demand for renewables and other low-carbon forms of energy, while greater energy efficiency spelt decline in some traditionally strong oil markets. US gasoline demand may already be in long-term decline, he said, because the car fleet was becoming more efficient.
Oil companies risked being caught out – like some telecommunications companies when first confronted by mobile technology.
“When mobile phones came in, I don’t think it was the fixed-line operators who were fastest and first to move to mobiles,” he said.
Lord Browne was speaking to the Financial Times ahead of a meeting of European energy experts in London on Monday at the Royal Academy of Engineering, of which he is president. At the gathering, he will call for world leaders urgently to pursue a global deal on climate change despite the economic downturn.
Since leaving BP, Lord Browne has taken on the chairmanship of the Accenture Global Energy Board and is managing director at the private equity firm Riverstone. He rejected the idea – put forward by a small group of UK companies last week – that the world’s oil supply would soon start to diminish.
“There’s plenty of oil, but it’s getting tougher to deliver and develop,” he said. Despite the recent fall in the oil price, the difficulty of exploiting new sources would have the effect of keeping prices high relative to past norms.
He called for the European Union’s emissions trading scheme (ETS) to be strengthened and dismissed claims that it was raising prices. The energy price rise resulting from it had been “infinitesimal”, compared with other factors.
“Moving these things around hardly changes the pool price of electricity – the cost of energy has gone up as it has become more expensive to make,” he said. “It does not make much difference in what we actually pay. Reductions in the base oil and gas [price] overwhelm anything that is happening in the [renewable subsidy] and ETS space.”
Consumers of energy should also face tougher regulation, he said. He pointed to “building codes, [the phasing out of incandescent] lightbulbs, offices in how long they should keep their lights on. And continuous regulation of [emissions from] cars should be tightened up.”
Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2008
Sunday, 2 November 2008
Gulf States to invest in Britain's renewable energy in 'green deal'
By Jane MerrickSunday, 2 November 2008
Gordon Brown is to announce a "Gulf green deal", with oil-rich nations investing in renewable energy in the UK.
The Prime Minister arrived in Saudi Arabia last night as part of a four-day mission to secure billions of pounds from the Gulf States for an expanded IMF bailout fund for nations caught up in the economic chaos. He will call on leaders to maintain oil production to keep prices low and help countries to survive the recession.
The "Gulf green deal", to be unveiled by Energy Secretary Ed Miliband during the visit, will see Qatar and Abu Dhabi invest in renewable energy projects in the UK. Mr Brown said yesterday: "The Saudis and other countries in the Gulf States are very important. They are the countries with great revenues and oil wealth. Everybody has got a part to play in solving the world downturn. I think the oil-rich states will want to play their part."
Two weeks ago Abu Dhabi's Masdar Initiative announced it would invest in the London Array offshore wind farm, buying 40 per cent of E.ON's half share, giving it a 20 per cent stake.
Mr Miliband said: "The Gulf's oil and gas will continue to be a vital source of power for the UK, but with the impending threat of climate change, we need to find cleaner and greener ways of running our economies and heating our homes."
Gordon Brown is to announce a "Gulf green deal", with oil-rich nations investing in renewable energy in the UK.
The Prime Minister arrived in Saudi Arabia last night as part of a four-day mission to secure billions of pounds from the Gulf States for an expanded IMF bailout fund for nations caught up in the economic chaos. He will call on leaders to maintain oil production to keep prices low and help countries to survive the recession.
The "Gulf green deal", to be unveiled by Energy Secretary Ed Miliband during the visit, will see Qatar and Abu Dhabi invest in renewable energy projects in the UK. Mr Brown said yesterday: "The Saudis and other countries in the Gulf States are very important. They are the countries with great revenues and oil wealth. Everybody has got a part to play in solving the world downturn. I think the oil-rich states will want to play their part."
Two weeks ago Abu Dhabi's Masdar Initiative announced it would invest in the London Array offshore wind farm, buying 40 per cent of E.ON's half share, giving it a 20 per cent stake.
Mr Miliband said: "The Gulf's oil and gas will continue to be a vital source of power for the UK, but with the impending threat of climate change, we need to find cleaner and greener ways of running our economies and heating our homes."
Gulf petrodollars help UK go green
Brown calls for Saudis to give more cash to IMF
Gaby Hinsliff, political editor
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
The fight against climate change will get an unexpected boost today from oil-rich Gulf states which will pledge to invest some of their petrodollar profits in British green energy projects.
The surging oil price over the past year has left parts of the Middle East awash with cash as the rest of the world is squeezed by the credit crunch, making Arab royals some of the few active investors worldwide. The Gulf states have enjoyed a $1.4 trillion windfall from higher oil prices since 2003.
Ed Miliband, the Climate Change Secretary, arrived in Saudi Arabia yesterday with Gordon Brown at the start of a tour of the region. He said some of that cash would now 'help our firms reap the rewards from going low carbon and providing green energy to thousands of families' under a so-called 'green Gulf deal' to be announced today.
Brown, who is accompanied by a high-level trade delegation seeking Gulf investment, including the CEOs of BP and Shell, was due to hold talks yesterday with the Saudi government on plans to boost the International Monetary Fund's capacity to help distressed economies during the current crisis. Britain wants the Gulf states to release more funds to the IMF, with Saudi Arabia likely to play a key role in talks later this month in Washington.
As the government attempted to deal with the financial crisis in the UK, it emerged yesterday that Jim Murphy, the Scottish Secretary, has discussed a rival bid for the troubled HBOS bank, which could provide an alternative to the planned merger with Lloyds TSB. Ministers have been challenged over whether the new 'superbank' is still the right option following the bail-out of British banks.
Murphy, who has met Jim Spowart, founder of Intelligent Finance, which is part of HBOS, said yesterday that if there was 'a second serious bid then [the Treasury] would be happy to talk to them.' Spowart, who has previously accused ministers of trying to railroad the merger through, said he had been told by merchant bankers that an unnamed financial services organisation was interested and thought he should 'alert the government' to the possibility.
The potential bid risks causing confusion hours after Peter Mandelson announced on Friday that he would rubber-stamp the merger with Lloyds despite a report from the Office of Fair Trading warning that bank customers could get a worse deal as a result. The OFT concluded the merger would remove an aggressive competitor from the market and increased risks that banks across the sector would offer less competitive deals on personal bank accounts: 'The value for money of personal current account propositions is expected to worsen, not only for the merged entity but for the industry as a whole.'
The merger also risked 'substantial lessening of competition' for mortgages, with the new merged bank controlling 20-30 per cent of the market. In Scotland, it also predicted a lessening of competition and therefore potentially worse deals for small and medium-sized businesses seeking loans and services such as overdrafts.
However, Mandelson, the new Business Secretary, ruled the merger was in the public interest because it would protect the stability of the financial system.
Gaby Hinsliff, political editor
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
The fight against climate change will get an unexpected boost today from oil-rich Gulf states which will pledge to invest some of their petrodollar profits in British green energy projects.
The surging oil price over the past year has left parts of the Middle East awash with cash as the rest of the world is squeezed by the credit crunch, making Arab royals some of the few active investors worldwide. The Gulf states have enjoyed a $1.4 trillion windfall from higher oil prices since 2003.
Ed Miliband, the Climate Change Secretary, arrived in Saudi Arabia yesterday with Gordon Brown at the start of a tour of the region. He said some of that cash would now 'help our firms reap the rewards from going low carbon and providing green energy to thousands of families' under a so-called 'green Gulf deal' to be announced today.
Brown, who is accompanied by a high-level trade delegation seeking Gulf investment, including the CEOs of BP and Shell, was due to hold talks yesterday with the Saudi government on plans to boost the International Monetary Fund's capacity to help distressed economies during the current crisis. Britain wants the Gulf states to release more funds to the IMF, with Saudi Arabia likely to play a key role in talks later this month in Washington.
As the government attempted to deal with the financial crisis in the UK, it emerged yesterday that Jim Murphy, the Scottish Secretary, has discussed a rival bid for the troubled HBOS bank, which could provide an alternative to the planned merger with Lloyds TSB. Ministers have been challenged over whether the new 'superbank' is still the right option following the bail-out of British banks.
Murphy, who has met Jim Spowart, founder of Intelligent Finance, which is part of HBOS, said yesterday that if there was 'a second serious bid then [the Treasury] would be happy to talk to them.' Spowart, who has previously accused ministers of trying to railroad the merger through, said he had been told by merchant bankers that an unnamed financial services organisation was interested and thought he should 'alert the government' to the possibility.
The potential bid risks causing confusion hours after Peter Mandelson announced on Friday that he would rubber-stamp the merger with Lloyds despite a report from the Office of Fair Trading warning that bank customers could get a worse deal as a result. The OFT concluded the merger would remove an aggressive competitor from the market and increased risks that banks across the sector would offer less competitive deals on personal bank accounts: 'The value for money of personal current account propositions is expected to worsen, not only for the merged entity but for the industry as a whole.'
The merger also risked 'substantial lessening of competition' for mortgages, with the new merged bank controlling 20-30 per cent of the market. In Scotland, it also predicted a lessening of competition and therefore potentially worse deals for small and medium-sized businesses seeking loans and services such as overdrafts.
However, Mandelson, the new Business Secretary, ruled the merger was in the public interest because it would protect the stability of the financial system.
Hot prospects for a company with a conscience
Simon Caulkin, management editor
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
John Clough smiles wryly at the news that the number of fuel-poor has just increased by a third to 3.5 million. As chief executive of Eaga, a green services company whose job is to help people out of fuel poverty, he can't ignore the prospect of a few hundred thousand more homes to insulate and heat. As the son of a Northumberland miner who can remember huddling around a coal fire to keep warm, he shivers at the thought.
Newcastle-based Eaga - originally the Energy Action Grants Agency - is a company for which the time ought to have come; and the same might go for the forthright, charismatic Clough, its driving force. The inspired offspring of the public sector, Eaga is now a publicly quoted company co-owned by employees, 'selling' low carbon and social inclusion - 'public-sector values delivered in a very effective way', as Clough puts it.
The company could be a poster-child for post-crunch capitalism, the embodiment of Peter Drucker's definition of the socially responsible business, turning 'a social problem into economic opportunity and economic benefit, into productive capacity, into human competence, into well-paid jobs, and into wealth'.
For this, thank a series of bold, entrepreneurial and fortuitous decisions. Eaga came into being in 1990 to manage a £25m contract to insulate and draught-proof poorly built homes under the government's Heating and Energy Efficiency Scheme. Clough was employee number 1, of five. The luck (or genius) was for Whitehall to establish the organisation as a company limited by guarantee, rather than as an agency, which allowed for a relatively easy transition to the employee-owned business - modelled on John Lewis - which it became in 2000, with 150 on the payroll.
From then on, things speeded up. As Clough intuited, the partnership ethos was a good match for the daily job of improving the homes and living conditions of the less well-off. A clean sweep of the government's Warm Front residential energy efficiency contracts in 2005 was the cue for Eaga to stop just managing programmes and start delivering services itself. Since then, it has built its own insulation and heating companies - what it proudly calls its 'national blue-collar delivery capability' - both organically and through acquisition.
By 2007, though, the company's ambitions were running ahead of its means. Clough and his colleagues could see other and much bigger issues looming.The move to a low-carbon, inclusive society, he predicts, will throw up a whole range of environmental issues to solve: not just energy efficiency, but access to technology and, in the future, water as well. 'In a 50-year time frame, the needs - and opportunities - are enormous.'
As early proof, Eaga has picked up a £200m contract to deliver Scottish Power's commitments to reduce overall carbon emissions, and will earn £500m from the BBC to carry out the digital switchover. Building on its work on fuel poverty, it has developed a one-stop benefits advisory service which has enabled a third of enquirers to claim, on average, an extra £1,500 a year. It is now busily expanding into the social housing sector.
To get into these markets, Eaga needed to take a risk on the balance sheet. The partnership trustees had been signalling for more than a year that this kind of expansion would be impossible without access to the capital markets, says Clough. So after some heart-searching - and scrutiny of eight different options - Eaga went public in June 2007 in an IPO that valued the company at about £450m and handed each partner a payout of around £100,000. With the Eaga Partnership Trust holding 37 per cent of the shares, and individual partners a further 11 or 12 per cent, the co-ownership ethos is secured, believes Clough, while others can invest in it too.
In fact, even in today's chilly financial climate, the tighter constraint on Eaga's growth may not be capital but people. 'In the established parts of the company, the level of engagement that co-ownership gives is palpable,' Clough says; and maintaining and strengthening it is primordial. Eaga pays a lot of attention to recruitment and induction, and works hard to convince those acquired (there are now 4,500 partners in all) of the virtues of an open, respect-driven management style. And if it can't? 'Rome fell because it ran out of Romans,' notes Clough. 'The hardest thing is to part with effective people who make the numbers but don't share the ethos. But it's stick or twist and if they stick, these are the values we ask them to live by.'
As everyone acknowledges, that takes work - including on outside shareholders, who at the moment don't much care about partnership, just whether Eaga meets its numbers. If the credit crunch teaches anything, however, it's that the numbers are only as reliable as the manner in which they are made. Here, too, Eaga may be able to teach the city slickers a thing or two.
Simon.Caulkin@observer.co.uk
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
John Clough smiles wryly at the news that the number of fuel-poor has just increased by a third to 3.5 million. As chief executive of Eaga, a green services company whose job is to help people out of fuel poverty, he can't ignore the prospect of a few hundred thousand more homes to insulate and heat. As the son of a Northumberland miner who can remember huddling around a coal fire to keep warm, he shivers at the thought.
Newcastle-based Eaga - originally the Energy Action Grants Agency - is a company for which the time ought to have come; and the same might go for the forthright, charismatic Clough, its driving force. The inspired offspring of the public sector, Eaga is now a publicly quoted company co-owned by employees, 'selling' low carbon and social inclusion - 'public-sector values delivered in a very effective way', as Clough puts it.
The company could be a poster-child for post-crunch capitalism, the embodiment of Peter Drucker's definition of the socially responsible business, turning 'a social problem into economic opportunity and economic benefit, into productive capacity, into human competence, into well-paid jobs, and into wealth'.
For this, thank a series of bold, entrepreneurial and fortuitous decisions. Eaga came into being in 1990 to manage a £25m contract to insulate and draught-proof poorly built homes under the government's Heating and Energy Efficiency Scheme. Clough was employee number 1, of five. The luck (or genius) was for Whitehall to establish the organisation as a company limited by guarantee, rather than as an agency, which allowed for a relatively easy transition to the employee-owned business - modelled on John Lewis - which it became in 2000, with 150 on the payroll.
From then on, things speeded up. As Clough intuited, the partnership ethos was a good match for the daily job of improving the homes and living conditions of the less well-off. A clean sweep of the government's Warm Front residential energy efficiency contracts in 2005 was the cue for Eaga to stop just managing programmes and start delivering services itself. Since then, it has built its own insulation and heating companies - what it proudly calls its 'national blue-collar delivery capability' - both organically and through acquisition.
By 2007, though, the company's ambitions were running ahead of its means. Clough and his colleagues could see other and much bigger issues looming.The move to a low-carbon, inclusive society, he predicts, will throw up a whole range of environmental issues to solve: not just energy efficiency, but access to technology and, in the future, water as well. 'In a 50-year time frame, the needs - and opportunities - are enormous.'
As early proof, Eaga has picked up a £200m contract to deliver Scottish Power's commitments to reduce overall carbon emissions, and will earn £500m from the BBC to carry out the digital switchover. Building on its work on fuel poverty, it has developed a one-stop benefits advisory service which has enabled a third of enquirers to claim, on average, an extra £1,500 a year. It is now busily expanding into the social housing sector.
To get into these markets, Eaga needed to take a risk on the balance sheet. The partnership trustees had been signalling for more than a year that this kind of expansion would be impossible without access to the capital markets, says Clough. So after some heart-searching - and scrutiny of eight different options - Eaga went public in June 2007 in an IPO that valued the company at about £450m and handed each partner a payout of around £100,000. With the Eaga Partnership Trust holding 37 per cent of the shares, and individual partners a further 11 or 12 per cent, the co-ownership ethos is secured, believes Clough, while others can invest in it too.
In fact, even in today's chilly financial climate, the tighter constraint on Eaga's growth may not be capital but people. 'In the established parts of the company, the level of engagement that co-ownership gives is palpable,' Clough says; and maintaining and strengthening it is primordial. Eaga pays a lot of attention to recruitment and induction, and works hard to convince those acquired (there are now 4,500 partners in all) of the virtues of an open, respect-driven management style. And if it can't? 'Rome fell because it ran out of Romans,' notes Clough. 'The hardest thing is to part with effective people who make the numbers but don't share the ethos. But it's stick or twist and if they stick, these are the values we ask them to live by.'
As everyone acknowledges, that takes work - including on outside shareholders, who at the moment don't much care about partnership, just whether Eaga meets its numbers. If the credit crunch teaches anything, however, it's that the numbers are only as reliable as the manner in which they are made. Here, too, Eaga may be able to teach the city slickers a thing or two.
Simon.Caulkin@observer.co.uk
Green power sell-off scheme slated as 'not radical enough'
Nick Mathiason
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
Government plans to let communities sell renewable energy to the grid have been criticised for being insufficiently radical by an unlikely alliance of giant retailers, housebuilding groups and country landowners ahead of a Lords' vote this week.
Last week, new Energy and Climate Change Secretary Ed Miliband published an amendment to his Energy Bill, which stated that renewable projects of under two megawatts would be eligible for so-called feed-in tariffs, allowing owners to sell power and so reduce the cost of schemes.
But Friends of the Earth and bodies such as the Country Land and Business Association argue that to make renewable energy schemes take off, a ceiling of 10 megawatts needs to be adopted.
Furthermore, there is concern that the government has failed to set a time-table for bringing in the measure. An alternative amendment could be tabled, supported by such groups as The British Retail Consortium and the Home Builders Federation.
While the government is struggling to meet the EU target that 15 per cent of UK energy should come from renewables by 2020, power firms are concerned that allowing individuals and communities the chance to profit from energy creation will mean companies make less money.
The Observer,
Sunday November 2 2008
Government plans to let communities sell renewable energy to the grid have been criticised for being insufficiently radical by an unlikely alliance of giant retailers, housebuilding groups and country landowners ahead of a Lords' vote this week.
Last week, new Energy and Climate Change Secretary Ed Miliband published an amendment to his Energy Bill, which stated that renewable projects of under two megawatts would be eligible for so-called feed-in tariffs, allowing owners to sell power and so reduce the cost of schemes.
But Friends of the Earth and bodies such as the Country Land and Business Association argue that to make renewable energy schemes take off, a ceiling of 10 megawatts needs to be adopted.
Furthermore, there is concern that the government has failed to set a time-table for bringing in the measure. An alternative amendment could be tabled, supported by such groups as The British Retail Consortium and the Home Builders Federation.
While the government is struggling to meet the EU target that 15 per cent of UK energy should come from renewables by 2020, power firms are concerned that allowing individuals and communities the chance to profit from energy creation will mean companies make less money.
Third runway at Heathrow would wreck climate target
The Sunday Times
November 2, 2008
Marie Woolf, Whitehall Editor
Gordon Brown has been warned by senior ministers that approving a third runway at Heathrow could wreck the government’s green credentials and undermine efforts to combat climate change.
Weeks before a formal announcement on expanding the airport is due, the prime minister is facing a revolt from the cabinet and senior MPs.
They fear building the runway could harm the party’s electoral prospects and damage Britain’s chances of hitting its target of cutting greenhouse gas emissions by 80% by 2050.
Among the critics is Harriet Harman, Labour’s deputy leader, who has been told that residents angry at the increased noise and congestion could eject a clutch of the party’s MPs in west London at the next election.
Hilary Benn, the environment secretary, has expressed concerns that Britain may not meet European Union air quality targets because of extra traffic at an expanded Heathrow.
Britain is three years behind European requirements for cutting emissions and may have to sacrifice pollution standards across London to allow at least an extra 60,000 flights a year at Heathrow. Benn, who lives under the Heathrow flight path in west London, has warned that the government may have to ask Brussels for a special deal to exempt the capital from official limits on exposure to pollutants.
David Miliband, the foreign secretary, who championed tough climate change measures when he was environment secretary, is also understood to be worried about the effect on greenhouse gas emissions of an expanded Heathrow airport.
Joan Ruddock, the climate change minister and London MP, is said to share concerns that the targets may be in jeopardy.
Other local MPs opposed to the scheme include Ann Keen, the health minister, and Andrew Slaughter.
The prime minister is due to meet a group of Labour MPs in Downing Street in the next fortnight to discuss fears that the expansion is so unpopular it could cost the seats of members nearest the airport.
At least 100 MPs from all parties, including 38 on the Labour benches, have signed a parliamentary motion opposing the third runway.
Among those who have made representations to Brown is Martin Salter, an MP who is vice-chairman of the Labour party with responsibility for the environment.
He has told the prime minister that allowing the runway could harm Labour’s green credentials.
Salter said: “It is clear Gordon is in listening mode from the interest he has shown in hearing all points of view.”
The prime minister’s spokesman said Brown had made up his mind in principle that the expansion should go ahead.
“The government has taken a political decision that it is right to go for a third runway at Heathrow but now it is going to be a planning judicial decision subject to very stringent environmental concerns,” said the spokesman.
“We have taken the decision in principle. It is now a planning decision.”
David Cameron, the Conservative party leader, has announced that a Tory government would tear up plans for a third runway.
Boris Johnson, the mayor of London, wants to build a hub airport in the Thames estuary.
November 2, 2008
Marie Woolf, Whitehall Editor
Gordon Brown has been warned by senior ministers that approving a third runway at Heathrow could wreck the government’s green credentials and undermine efforts to combat climate change.
Weeks before a formal announcement on expanding the airport is due, the prime minister is facing a revolt from the cabinet and senior MPs.
They fear building the runway could harm the party’s electoral prospects and damage Britain’s chances of hitting its target of cutting greenhouse gas emissions by 80% by 2050.
Among the critics is Harriet Harman, Labour’s deputy leader, who has been told that residents angry at the increased noise and congestion could eject a clutch of the party’s MPs in west London at the next election.
Hilary Benn, the environment secretary, has expressed concerns that Britain may not meet European Union air quality targets because of extra traffic at an expanded Heathrow.
Britain is three years behind European requirements for cutting emissions and may have to sacrifice pollution standards across London to allow at least an extra 60,000 flights a year at Heathrow. Benn, who lives under the Heathrow flight path in west London, has warned that the government may have to ask Brussels for a special deal to exempt the capital from official limits on exposure to pollutants.
David Miliband, the foreign secretary, who championed tough climate change measures when he was environment secretary, is also understood to be worried about the effect on greenhouse gas emissions of an expanded Heathrow airport.
Joan Ruddock, the climate change minister and London MP, is said to share concerns that the targets may be in jeopardy.
Other local MPs opposed to the scheme include Ann Keen, the health minister, and Andrew Slaughter.
The prime minister is due to meet a group of Labour MPs in Downing Street in the next fortnight to discuss fears that the expansion is so unpopular it could cost the seats of members nearest the airport.
At least 100 MPs from all parties, including 38 on the Labour benches, have signed a parliamentary motion opposing the third runway.
Among those who have made representations to Brown is Martin Salter, an MP who is vice-chairman of the Labour party with responsibility for the environment.
He has told the prime minister that allowing the runway could harm Labour’s green credentials.
Salter said: “It is clear Gordon is in listening mode from the interest he has shown in hearing all points of view.”
The prime minister’s spokesman said Brown had made up his mind in principle that the expansion should go ahead.
“The government has taken a political decision that it is right to go for a third runway at Heathrow but now it is going to be a planning judicial decision subject to very stringent environmental concerns,” said the spokesman.
“We have taken the decision in principle. It is now a planning decision.”
David Cameron, the Conservative party leader, has announced that a Tory government would tear up plans for a third runway.
Boris Johnson, the mayor of London, wants to build a hub airport in the Thames estuary.
VT set to join US-led group in building up to 14 nuclear plants in the UAE
By Mark LeftlySunday, 2 November 2008
VT, the FTSE250 support services group, is this week expected to be named as a member of the US-led consortium to manage the United Arab Emirates' civilian nuclear programme.
CH2M Hill, which is helping to oversee the construction of the London 2012 Olympics venue, was awarded the 10-year contract last month. A UAE source said the construction programme could involve six to 14 nuclear plants.
The source added that Colorado-based CH2M Hill has approached VT to provide "design support" for the proposed facility. "We think that a US/UK solution is a real winner," he said. It is anticipated that VT will be announced as a consortium partner to coincide with a visit by the Prime Minister Gordon Brown to the UAE this week.
FTSE100 engineering group Amec and the UK Atomic Energy Authority are understood to have been among the parties that failed to land the main contract. A VT spokesman declined to comment.
VT, the FTSE250 support services group, is this week expected to be named as a member of the US-led consortium to manage the United Arab Emirates' civilian nuclear programme.
CH2M Hill, which is helping to oversee the construction of the London 2012 Olympics venue, was awarded the 10-year contract last month. A UAE source said the construction programme could involve six to 14 nuclear plants.
The source added that Colorado-based CH2M Hill has approached VT to provide "design support" for the proposed facility. "We think that a US/UK solution is a real winner," he said. It is anticipated that VT will be announced as a consortium partner to coincide with a visit by the Prime Minister Gordon Brown to the UAE this week.
FTSE100 engineering group Amec and the UK Atomic Energy Authority are understood to have been among the parties that failed to land the main contract. A VT spokesman declined to comment.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
