World's first carbon capture pilot fires up clean-coal advocates

German project will burn coal in an atmosphere of pure oxygen – producing CO2 waste which can be buried – creating enough electricity to power 1,000 homes

Alok Jha, green technology correspondent
guardian.co.uk,
Friday September 05 2008 12:09 BST

The world's first complete demonstration of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology will begin next week at a coal-fired power station in Germany.
Built alongside the 1,600MW Schwarze Pumpe power plant in north Germany, the demonstration experiment will capture up to 100,000 tonnes of CO2 a year, compress it and bury it 3,000m below the surface of the depleted Altmark gas field, about 200km from the site.
The €70m (£57m) project has an output of around 12MW of electricity and 30MW of thermal power, enough for more about 1,000 homes.
The pilot plant will use an oxyfuel boiler, one of three types of CCS technology. This involves burning coal in an atmosphere of pure oxygen – the resulting waste gas is almost pure CO2 and this can be buried, preventing it from entering the atmosphere and contributing to global warming. The other CCS methods are pre-combustion, involving the removal of CO2 before burning by pre-treating the coal, and post-combustion, which scrubs the exhaust gases from a power station.
"It's a very important and tangible step forward," said Stuart Haszeldine, a geologist and CCS expert at the University of Edinburgh. "It is the first full-chain demonstration of oxyfuel as a carbon capture technology. It connects all that for the first time in a working system." He added the Schwarze Pumpe pilot "shows what can be done if the state and company are aligned and have confidence in each other".
CCS is seen as a potential solution to the projected increased use of coal in power stations around the world. At its best, it would trap up to 90% of a plant's carbon emissions and, though each element of the capture, transportation and storage process is already proven and in use, until now no one had demonstrated a full-cycle system, even at the small scale of a pilot. A full-scale system remains years away, largely because developing such a system is likely to be very expensive. As a result, many leading power companies have been reluctant to fund CCS individually, arguing that governments should also shoulder some of the financial risks.
"Coal, which represents 40-50% of electricity [generation], is necessary and will continue to be necessary because of fuel safety and accessibility. It is one of the most shared resources around the world," said Philippe Joubert, chief executive of Alstom, the company that built the specially equipped oxyfuel boiler for the Schwarze Pumpe's Swedish owners, Vatenfall.
He said Alstom's research is aimed at keeping the world's options open on how electricity is generated in the coming decades. "Coal has to be used but it has to be clean."
The Schwarze Pumpe pilot, which will run for three years initially, is just one of several projects that are gearing up to demonstrate the full chain of CCS technology in the next few years. Alstom will commission another project of a similar size to Schwarze Pumpe later in 2008 at a power station in Lacq in southern France, in collaboration with the oil company Total.
The Mountaineer project in West Virginia, US, due to begin in 2009, is likely to be the first of the pilot plants to put all the pieces of post-combustion CCS technology together. It is a testbed for a more ambitious plan to capture and store emissions from a coal-fired power station in Oklahoma which should begin operations early next decade, trapping and burying 1.5m tonnes of CO2 a year in a nearby oilfield. Vatenfall also has plans for a post-combustion pilot plant in Janshwalde in Germany - a 120MW coal-burning demonstration should become operational around 2013.
In the UK, plans for a government-funded CCS demonstration plant are moving relatively slowly. In 2006, the government announced a competition to fund the construction of a 400MW CCS demonstration project that would go on line in 2014. Critics argue, however, that plans are too small-scale and too slow, despite government claims that the country is in a perfect place for CCS due to the easy access to suitable burial sites for CO2 in the North Sea. They also say that the government made a mistake in pre-selecting post-combustion technology as the only type of project it would fund. The government argues this is the only type of CCS that can be retrofitted.
The decision on the UK's first CCS demonstration will be made in 2009, after the results of an ongoing consultation into how to implement the technology. Even some environmental groups have come together to recommend CCS as a way to reduce carbon emissions from the inevitable construction of coal-fired power stations in the UK and abroad. The EU has plans for 12 demonstration plants running by 2015.
Haszledine said there are few excuses left for not starting CCS projects. "There is no opposition to doing this [apart from] the lethargy of the UK government."